Require disclosure to people when AI is used in a service or decision
19 submissions. Each submission counts once for this shared ask. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
A shared ask groups requests for substantially the same action from three or more submissions when the group was created. Groups remain listed if withdrawals reduce their counts. AI models summarised recommendations, grouped them and checked the groups. The label summarises the requests; it is not a quote. A shared ask does not mean agreement on anything else.
Theme: Disclosure of AI use
Recommendations from submissions
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Extracts are chosen by an AI model. Submissions are listed in submission number order; recommendations follow their order on each submission’s page.
Australian Human Rights Commission Submission 9
Apply proportionate safeguards to AI use: pre-deployment human rights assessments, meaningful human oversight, clear information on when and how AI is used, accessible reasons for AI in decisions, review, remedy and independent oversight.
Use of AI should be subject to safeguards proportionate to its potential impact. These include human rights impact assessments before deployment, meaningful human oversight, clear public information about when and how AI is used, accessible reasons for use of AI in decisions, avenues for review and remedy, and independent oversight.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Shop, Distributive and Allied Employees' Association (SDA) Submission 17
Update privacy, surveillance and workplace technology protections to give workers enforceable rights to know when AI is used in decisions affecting them, receive an explanation of automated decisions affecting their employment, and challenge those decisions.
Privacy, surveillance and workplace technology protections should be updated to give workers enforceable rights to know when AI is used in decisions affecting them, to receive an explanation of automated decisions affecting their employment, and to challenge those decisions
Workday Submission 51
Ensure workers understand when and how AI materially informs decisions affecting them, including hiring, performance management and role changes, consistently with human-oversight principles.
we encourage a focus on transparency: workers should be able to understand when and how AI materially informs a decision that affects them (such as hiring, performance management, or role changes), consistent with the human-oversight principles Workday embeds in its own Responsible AI framework.
Spinifex Press Pty Ltd Submission 112
Require all work that uses AI to disclose the extent of AI involvement.
To protect transparency and trust, all work that uses AI should disclose the extent of AI involvement.
United Nations Special Rapporteur on human rights and counter-terrorism Submission 160
Require State and private actors who deploy AI to disclose transparently when and how AI is used and publicise information about complaints and remedial processes.
State and private actors who deploy AI should transparently disclose when and how AI is used and publicise information about complaints and remedial processes.
MEGT (Australia) Ltd Submission 194
Require disclosure of AI use in recruitment decisions and a right to human review for anyone rejected by an automated system.
MEGT Group recommends that bias auditing be mandatory for AI hiring and assessment tools used in decisions affecting people who receive government-funded employment services, that the use of AI in a recruitment decision be disclosed, and that any person rejected by an automated system have a right to human review.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Consumer Policy Research Centre Submission 227
Require businesses to disclose when and how AI is used, through point-of-use transparency labels identifying AI-curated content, experiences or offers.
Businesses should be required to clearly disclose when and how AI is being used. Transparency can provide a pre-condition for good consumer protection, helping regulators, researchers and the general public understand how the technology is being applied. Recommendation: The Federal Government should incorporate obligations for a transparency label via disclosures at point of use, so there is adequate awareness that AI has been used to curate what they are viewing, experiencing or being offered.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Samantha Connor AM Submission 229
Give people the right to know when AI or automated processing materially influenced a decision about them, what information was used, which factors were significant, and what was inferred about them.
Give people the right to know when AI or automated processing materially influenced a decision about them, what information was used, which factors were significant, and what was inferred about them.
Dr Fan Yang and Dr Robbie Fordyce Submission 244
Require employers to map where AI is in use and be transparent with workers about it; give workers the option to opt out without compelled consent; protect conscientious objectors from dismissal or Performance Improvement Plans for refusing to use AI.
Employers must therefore undertake a mapping exercise to identify where AI is currently in use across their existing hardware and software, and must be transparent with workers about how it is being used. Workers must, in turn, be given the option to opt out of any engagement with AI, without being compelled to consent to its organisational use. Protections must also be established for conscientious objectors to AI use, ensuring that workers cannot be dismissed or placed on a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) for refusing to use AI.
Dr Fiona Tito Wheatland Submission 245
Require disclosure of Commonwealth AI use to consumers/service users; where benefits change or are limited, require professional scrutiny and allow an officer to override AI decisions where appropriate.
In relation to the use of AI by Commonwealth departments and agencies, there should be a duty or care to disclose to any consumers or service users that this is being used. Where benefits are going to be changed or limited, there should be scrutiny by a competent professional officer and the ability for an officer to override an AI decision where this is appropriate.
Forum on Information and Democracy Submission 252
Mandate that deployers of synthetic entities such as chatbots and virtual assistants make users aware they are engaging with an AI-driven interactive system.
Mandating deployers of synthetic entities (e.g., chatbots, virtual assistants) to make users aware that they are engaging with an AI-driven interactive system.
Intelligent Screening Australia Pty Ltd (i-screen) Submission 264
Prioritise risk-based disclosure of material AI involvement, qualified review and reviewer authority, relevant storage and processing locations, and substantiated capability and assurance claims, without revealing sensitive security or proprietary implementation details.
We recommend prioritising visible and checkable outcomes: disclosure of material AI involvement, disclosure of whether a qualified human reviewed consequential output and what authority they had, meaningful disclosure of storage and processing location where relevant, and substantiation of capability and assurance claims. These disclosures should be risk-based and should not require publication of sensitive security or proprietary implementation details.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Australian Lawyers Alliance (ALA) Submission 310
Tell individuals in plain language when AI has materially influenced a decision, with notice and reasons identifying the system's role, decisive information and inferences, responsible entity and avenues for correction and review.
it should be communicated to an individual, in plain language, when AI has materially influenced a decision. In these cases, there should be both notice and reasons identifying the system's role, the decisive information and inferences, the responsible entity and the available avenues for correction and review.
Mrs Belinda Gourlay Submission 345
Consider social legibility in Australian AI governance: visible AI, clear modes of operation and disclosure when AI is actively involved in an interaction.
Australian AI Governance should consider the principle of social legibility. AI should be visible and able to clearly convey what mode it is operating in. When AI is actively involved in an interaction, this should be clearly disclosed.
Name withheld Submission 351
Where AI materially contributes to a government decision affecting an individual, the person should ordinarily have a right to know.
Mr Joel Leslie Submission 417
Define and operationalise material AI capability change, with proportionate disclosure of changes to models, providers, data processing, decision influence, autonomy, tool access, intended use and charging.
Define and operationalise material AI capability change. Establish proportionate expectations for disclosure when AI materially enters or changes a product, service, workplace or decision process, including changes to model, provider, data processing, decision influence, autonomy, tool access, intended use or charging model.
Mrs Ivy Cook Submission 419
Provide mechanisms for people affected by important AI-supported decisions to understand that automation was involved, seek explanation, challenge errors and obtain meaningful review.
People affected by important AI-supported decisions should also have appropriate mechanisms to understand that automation was involved, seek explanation, challenge errors and obtain meaningful review.
Name withheld Submission 477
Users must be informed when interacting with AI (chatbots, voice assistants) to ensure visible disclosure on consumer-facing platforms
Community and Public Sector Union (CPSU) Submission 534
Inform individuals when AI has been used in decision-making and give them the option to opt out of AI use.
Individuals should be informed when AI has been used in decision-making processes and have the option to opt-out of AI use.