Prohibit specified AI practices that pose unacceptable risk, such as social scoring
6 submissions. Each submission counts once for this shared ask. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
A shared ask groups requests for substantially the same action from three or more submissions when the group was created. Groups remain listed if withdrawals reduce their counts. AI models summarised recommendations, grouped them and checked the groups. The label summarises the requests; it is not a quote. A shared ask does not mean agreement on anything else.
Theme: High-risk AI and mandatory guardrails
Recommendations from submissions
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Extracts are chosen by an AI model. Submissions are listed in submission number order; recommendations follow their order on each submission’s page.
United Nations Special Rapporteur on human rights and counter-terrorism Submission 160
Prohibit human-rights-incompatible AI, including terrorism-risk assessment solely from profiling or personality traits without human assessment of objective, verified crime-linked facts, and facial databases built through untargeted, non-consensual image scraping.
AI systems must be prohibited where they cannot be used in compliance with human rights law. 194 Examples include where: 195 the risk of an individual committing a terrorist offence is assessed solely based on profiling or personality traits, including based on biometrics or sentiment analysis, absent human assessments based on objective, verified facts linked to criminal activity; facial recognition databases are sourced from untargeted, non-consensual scraping of images from the internet or surveillance footage; “real-time” remote biometric identification is used to indiscriminately surveil in public places; biometric systems infer sensitive attributes; emotions are inferred in certain sensitive settings; and decisions about military targeting are fully automated.
Centre for Future Work Submission 221
Prohibit processing data to infer union activity and using AI to predict or dissuade workers from exercising their legal rights.
‘Red lines’ should be drawn, prohibiting practices with a high risk to workers’ human rights, dignity, safety and security, such as: o monitoring and collection, processing and use in decision-making of data collected via highly intrusive forms of surveillance, including surveillance of workers outside of work (including when on breaks), and monitoring of private conversations o the collection of data relating to workers’ emotional or psychological state o the manipulation of workers emotional or psychological state o the processing of data to infer union activity and the use of AI to predict or dissuade workers from exercising their legal rights53 o the sale of personal data to third parties.
Victorian Trades Hall Council (VTHC) Submission 293
Ban development, deployment, sale, uptake, distribution and export of AI intended to calculate workers' emotions in employment, civic, public or educational contexts or sort workers by protected attributes, including union membership.
The Federal Government should legislate prohibitions on the use of AI where it would pose an unacceptable risk to workers, consumers and the community. Prohibitions here would protect Australians from harm will improving the social license and public trust in the AI rollout. There should be a total ban on the development, deployment, sale, uptake, distribution or export of AI systems that are intended to: i. Calculate the emotions of a worker in an employment, civic, public, or educational context; ii. Calculate, categorise, or sort workers according to protected personal attributes, nothing that trade union membership should be considered a protected attribute;
Mr Noah Quinlan Submission 365
Prohibit unjustified AI-enabled digital coercion, generalised behavioural scoring and indiscriminate surveillance, with explicit legislative authority required for high-impact biometric or surveillance uses.
Protect individual freedom by prohibiting unjustified AI-enabled digital coercion, generalised behavioural scoring and indiscriminate surveillance, with explicit legislative authority required for high-impact biometric or surveillance uses.
Name withheld Submission 394
Alongside CSAM, the following are banned outright, not merely “discouraged”: manipulative or deceptive AI techniques that materially distort behavior and cause harm; exploitation of vulnerabilities based on age, disability, or socio-economic situation; social scoring by public authorities; untargeted scraping of facial images to build recognition databases;
Name withheld Submission 477
The new legislation should prohibit the following AI applications without exception: Prohibition Social scoring Real-time remote biometrics Predictive policing Subliminal manipulation Emotional inference for employment/insurance Description AI systems evaluating individuals based on behaviour, socioeconomic status, or personal characteristics Live facial recognition in public spaces except by law enforcement, except for imminent terrorist threat or missing child investigation Risk assessment profiling individuals based on protected characteristics or behavioural patterns without human oversight AI designed to bypass conscious awareness to alter behaviour or decisions Using AI to infer emotions, mental state for employment screening or insurance underwriting