AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Give people a right to an explanation of automated decisions

8 submissions. Each submission counts once for this shared ask. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

A shared ask groups requests for substantially the same action from three or more submissions when the group was created. Groups remain listed if withdrawals reduce their counts. AI models summarised recommendations, grouped them and checked the groups. The label summarises the requests; it is not a quote. A shared ask does not mean agreement on anything else.

Theme: Automated decision-making in government

Recommendations from submissions

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Extracts are chosen by an AI model. Submissions are listed in submission number order; recommendations follow their order on each submission’s page.

  1. Human Technology Institute, University of Technology Sydney Submission 18

    1. Give anyone affected by ADM reasons; provide a plain-language legal and factual explanation when a decision affects legal or human rights or otherwise significantly impacts them.

      Anyone affected by an automated decision should be given reasons for the decision. When a decision is made affecting a person’s legal or human rights, or otherwise significantly impacting them, they should be provided with a plain language explanation of the legal and factual basis for the decision.

  2. SA Unions Submission 175

    1. Give workers and representatives a right to an explanation when AI is used in decision making.

      Workers and their representatives must have a “right to an explanation” when AI is used for decision making purposes.

  3. Digital Economy Council of Australia Submission 239

    1. Introduce targeted rights to notice, an intelligible explanation and meaningful review where automated processing materially influences a consequential decision and existing arrangements provide no equivalent protection, recognising sectoral complaint mechanisms.

      DECA supports targeted rights to notice, an intelligible explanation and meaningful review where automated processing materially influences a consequential decision and existing arrangements provide no equivalent protection, recognising established sectoral complaint mechanisms.

  4. Forum on Information and Democracy Submission 252

    1. Develop a legal framework defining individuals' rights to be informed, receive an explanation, challenge an outcome and non-discrimination, and mandate complaint-handling procedures.

      Developing a comprehensive legal framework that clearly defines the rights of individuals including the right to be informed, to receive an explanation, to challenge an outcome, and to nondiscrimination, and mandating AI systems to establish complaint-handling procedures.

  5. Mr Stuart Le Gros Submission 344

    1. Give affected people notice when automation materially influenced a result, with the decisive factors, relevant input categories and accessible reasons.

      Give notice and meaningful reasons. Tell affected people when automation materially influenced a result and provide the decisive factors, relevant input categories and accessible reasons.

  6. Ms Litsa Roberts Submission 352

    1. Establish a statutory Right of Challenge (notice, explanation, correction, challenge, human review, remedy, audit) where AI materially influences a decision affecting a person's rights, livelihood, safety, essential services or opportunities.

      Where AI materially influences a decision affecting a person’s rights, livelihood, safety, essential services or opportunities, there should be a statutory Right of Challenge: NOTICE → EXPLANATION → CORRECTION → CHALLENGE → HUMAN REVIEW → REMEDY → AUDIT

  7. Mr Mark Neugebauer Submission 361

    1. For AI materially affecting rights, obligations, health, livelihood or government-service access, provide notice, explanation, challenge and genuine human reconsideration rather than confirmation of automated recommendations.

      Where AI materially contributes to decisions affecting a person’s rights, obligations, health, livelihood or access to government services, I believe several principles should apply. The affected person should be able to know that AI was materially involved. There should be a meaningful explanation of the decision. The individual should be able to challenge it. A human decision-maker should be capable of genuinely reconsidering the matter rather than merely confirming an automated recommendation.

  8. Name withheld Submission 477

    1. Individuals affected by automated decisions entitled to meaningful explanation

Open in the interactive guide