AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Adopt a proportionate, risk-based approach to AI regulation

31 submissions. Each submission counts once for this shared ask. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

A shared ask groups requests for substantially the same action from three or more submissions when the group was created. Groups remain listed if withdrawals reduce their counts. AI models summarised recommendations, grouped them and checked the groups. The label summarises the requests; it is not a quote. A shared ask does not mean agreement on anything else.

Theme: Risk-based regulation

Recommendations from submissions

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Extracts are chosen by an AI model. Submissions are listed in submission number order; recommendations follow their order on each submission’s page.

  1. Australian Institute of Insider Threats Submission 39

    1. Ask the Committee to consider increasing oversight, intervention and assurance as the potential consequences of AI actions increase.

      The greater the potential consequence of an AI system's actions, the greater the level of oversight, intervention and assurance that may be required.

  2. Airwallex Submission 54

    1. Keep high-impact AI criteria proportionate, distinguishing decisions about individual rights or service access from routine, established finance automation.

      we recommend that regulatory criteria for high-impact use cases remain proportionate, ensuring a clear distinction between AI that makes consequential decisions about an individual's rights or service access, and routine, well-established finance automation.

  3. Vault Submission 84

    1. Keep AI regulation proportionate, use-case based and technology-neutral, with clear accountability for higher-risk applications.

      Regulation should remain proportionate, use-case based and technology-neutral, with clear accountability for higher-risk applications.

  4. Atlassian Submission 89

    1. Assess further AI regulation against contextual risk and harms, target problems and responsible actors, default to technology neutrality unless harms are technology-specific, and favour interoperability with emerging international standards.

      Any measures that we implement should be: ● risk-based by their nature, grounded in the context of use and application, and in the categorisation and prioritisation of actual and potential harms; ● targeted at where and how the problem actually arises, and its relationship to those who provide, implement or use the relevant AI technologies (as applicable); ● technology-neutral by default, unless the harm or problem being addressed is specific to a singular technology; and ● cognisant of emerging international practice and standards in the circumstances, with a bias towards being interoperable with those standards.

  5. Chameleon Confidential Solutions Pty Ltd Submission 99

    1. Recommendation 5: develop proportionate AI governance using factors such as function, autonomy, control, consequence, dependency, affected people and communities, cumulative effects and operating environment.

      Further develop proportionate AI governance using objective factors that could include intended function, autonomy, control, consequence, dependency, people and communities affected, cumulative effects and operating environment.

  6. Soroptimist International Australia Inc Submission 115

    1. Adopt a human-centred, risk-based, enforceable AI governance framework combining safeguards with support for innovation, workforce transition, Australian capability and responsible investment.

      S| Australia therefore calls for an AI governance framework that is human-centred, risk-based, and enforceable. It should combine strong safeguards for people with measures that support innovation, workforce transition, Australian capability and responsible investment (Australian Government Department of Industry, Science and Resources, 2025; UNESCO, 2025).

      A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  7. Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Radiologists Submission 117

    1. Make AI regulation in healthcare risk-proportionate and nationally consistent, with the level of evidence for safety and efficacy commensurate with risk, designed to complement rather than duplicate existing regulatory systems.

      That regulation of AI in healthcare be risk-proportionate and nationally consistent, with the level of evidence required to demonstrate safety and efficacy commensurate with the level of risk, and designed to complement existing regulatory systems rather than duplicate them.

  8. Royal Australasian College of Surgeons Submission 118

    1. Support a nationally consistent, risk-based AI governance framework that promotes innovation while protecting patients and the public.

      Support a nationally consistent, risk-based framework for AI governance that promotes innovation while protecting patients and the public.

  9. Trustethica Submission 159

    1. Develop a nationally consistent, technology-neutral AI assurance framework distinguishing low-risk from consequential/high-risk use, with baseline accountability, recordkeeping, risk-assessment and incident-management expectations and enhanced requirements where harms are substantial, scalable or hard to reverse.

      Establish a nationally consistent, risk-proportionate AI assurance framework. The Australian Government should develop a technology-neutral framework that differentiates low- risk AI use from consequential and high-risk use. It should establish baseline expectations for accountability, recordkeeping, risk assessment and incident management, with enhanced requirements where potential harms are substantial, scalable or difficult to reverse.

  10. Stripe Submission 163

    1. Support innovation through a risk-based approach, using existing regulation as the starting point for AI-enabled commerce.

      Policymakers should support innovation through a risk-based approach, using existing regulation as a starting point for addressing aspects of AI-enabled commerce.

  11. Moderna Australia Submission 193

    1. Enable adaptive, risk-based regulation: equip TGA/relevant agencies to apply existing frameworks by context/risk; add AI-specific requirements only for genuine gaps, aligning where possible with leading international regulators and evolving international AI governance.

      Enable AI innovation through risk-based, internationally aligned and adaptive regulation, ensuring the TGA and other relevant agencies have the capability to apply existing regulatory frameworks to AI according to context and risk, with new AI-specific requirements introduced only where genuine gaps exist and aligned, where possible, with leading international regulators and evolving international AI governance approaches.

  12. AQ Intelligence (AQI), Guardrail Technologies Australia (GTA) and First Nations Strategic Alliance (FNSA) Submission 202

    1. Apply proportionality within the technology-neutral framework: minimal burden for low-risk uses, and the strongest obligations and independent assurance for high-risk uses affecting health, liberty, essential services or safety.

      Apply proportionality within the technology-neutral framework. Let expected practice scale with the stakes of the use case: minimal burden for low-risk uses; the strongest obligations and independent assurance for high-risk uses affecting health, liberty, essential services or safety.

  13. Australian Telecommunications Alliance Submission 217

    1. Adopt AI regulatory approaches that are risk-based, proportionate, technology-neutral and aligned with existing regulatory frameworks wherever possible.

      The ATA supports regulatory approaches that are:  risk-based;  proportionate;  technology-neutral; and  aligned with existing regulatory frameworks wherever possible.

  14. Better Hatch Network Submission 218

    1. Base any future risk-based classification of AI systems on what a system does, not its industry, distinguishing narrow task-specific applications from general-purpose or higher-risk systems so obligations stay proportionate.

      That any future risk-based classification of AI systems under Australian law or standards consider what a system does, not the industry it operates in: distinguishing narrow, task-specific applications, such as sensor-based classification used in agriculture, from general-purpose or higher-risk decision-making systems, including future systems within agriculture itself, so that compliance obligations remain proportionate to actual risk.

  15. CPA Australia Submission 231

    1. Adopt a proportionate, risk-based and technology-neutral approach to AI regulation that builds on existing frameworks wherever possible.

      Australia should adopt a proportionate, risk-based and technology-neutral approach to AI regulation that builds on existing frameworks wherever possible.

  16. Digital Economy Council of Australia Submission 239

    1. Direct AI regulation at the deployed system and decision pathway, with deployer obligations proportionate to the consequence of the decision, rather than at model capability or infrastructure.

      Direct AI regulation at the deployed system and the decision pathway, applying obligations to deployers in proportion to the consequence of the decision, rather than at model capability or the infrastructure on which a model runs.

  17. FinTech Australia Submission 250

    1. Maintain a proportionate, technology-neutral, risk-based approach to AI regulation, with economy-wide intervention only at demonstrated gaps that existing laws or targeted reform cannot adequately address.

      The Australian Government should maintain a proportionate, technology-neutral and risk-based approach to AI regulation, with economy-wide intervention directed only at demonstrated regulatory gaps that cannot adequately be addressed through existing laws or targeted reform.

  18. Business Council of Australia (BCA) Submission 290

    1. Make Australian AI Standards principles-based, risk-proportionate, internationally interoperable and complementary to existing law; avoid prescriptive technical requirements that may become outdated or undermine effectiveness.

      The Government's intention to establish nationally consistent Australian Standards for AI'* provides an opportunity to give businesses practical guardrails for responsible adoption, strengthen public confidence and provide greater certainty for investment and deployment. The standards should be principles-based, proportionate to risk, interoperable with relevant international standards and designed to complement rather than duplicate existing legal obligations. They should avoid overly prescriptive technical requirements that could quickly become outdated or undermine their effectiveness

      A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  19. Science & Technology Australia Submission 291

    1. Adopt proportionate, technology-agnostic, risk-based AI regulation with strong human oversight and protections for privacy, security, transparency and accountability, while enabling responsible research, development and adoption.

      The Australian Government should adopt proportionate, technology-agnostic and risk-based AI regulation, with strong human oversight and protections around privacy, security, transparency and accountability, while enabling responsible research, development and adoption.

  20. Tech Council of Australia Submission 299

    1. Adopt risk-based, role-based regulation reflecting harm seriousness and context and developers’, providers’, deployers’ and substantial modifiers’ control, knowledge and scale; simplify compliance for low-risk uses.

      Adopt risk-based and role-based regulation. Obligations should reflect the seriousness and context of potential harm and the control, knowledge and scale of developers, providers, deployers and substantial modifiers. Low-risk uses should have simplified compliance pathways.

  21. Australian Lawyers Alliance (ALA) Submission 310

    1. Supplement, rather than displace, existing rights and remedies with a nationally consistent, risk-based AI framework.

      A nationally consistent, risk-based framework should supplement, rather than displace, existing rights, duties and remedies.

  22. Chartered Accountants Australia and New Zealand (CA ANZ) Submission 315

    1. Adopt a nationally consistent, risk-based and proportionate AI framework focused on high-risk use cases and unacceptable harms.

      a nationally consistent, risk-based and proportionate AI framework focused on high-risk use cases and unacceptable harms.

  23. Name withheld Submission 351

    1. Regulation should therefore be proportionate to potential harm. Higher-risk applications should attract stronger requirements concerning testing, transparency, recordkeeping, human oversight and accountability. Low-risk uses should not be buried under unnecessary bureaucracy.

  24. Ms Litsa Roberts Submission 352

    1. Have regulators publish and periodically update practical classification and assurance thresholds so lower-risk AI is not burdened by controls designed for high-impact systems.

      Regulators should publish and periodically update practical classification and assurance thresholds so lower-risk AI is not burdened by controls designed for high-impact systems.

  25. Mr Noah Quinlan Submission 365

    1. Adopt a risk-based national AI framework with enforceable baseline duties (accountability, privacy, security, data governance, testing, transparency, human oversight, contestability), with proportionately stronger obligations for high-impact and critical systems.

      Adopt a risk-based national AI framework with enforceable baseline duties for accountability, privacy, security, data governance, testing, transparency, human oversight and contestability, with proportionately stronger obligations for high- impact and critical systems.

  26. Mrs Elizabeth Morrish Submission 390

    1. Establish proportionate, risk-based AI regulation, avoiding unnecessary burdens for lower-risk commercial adoption while applying mandatory safeguards to frontier systems.

      Establish proportionate, risk-based AI regulation, avoiding unnecessary compliance burdens for lower-risk commercial adoption while applying mandatory safeguards to frontier systems.

  27. Name withheld Submission 477

    1. AI-specific regulation should not be "last resort" but rather proportionate first response for high-risk applications, calibrated to Australia's innovation objectives while establishing baseline consumer and worker protections.

  28. Name withheld Submission 485

    1. Australia should adopt a risk-based regulatory framework. Low-risk AI applications should face relatively light regulation, while high-risk systems should require independent testing, cybersecurity measures, privacy protections, incident reporting, transparency and meaningful human oversight.

  29. ACT Chief Minister Submission 521

    1. Make AI governance proportionate, risk-based and adaptable, focusing regulatory attention on high-risk uses while enabling responsible innovation.

      Effective AI governance should therefore be proportionate, risk-based and adaptable, focusing regulatory attention on high-risk uses while enabling responsible innovation.

      A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  30. Special Broadcasting Service (SBS) Submission 535

    1. Adopt a risk-based approach to AI regulation focused on settings and activities posing the greatest potential for individual or societal harm, taking account of existing regulatory protections to avoid duplication or undue complexity, and adopting a consultative approach to avoid unintended consequences.

      SBS supports a risk-based approach to AI regulation, focusing on settings and activities that pose the greatest potential for individual and/or societal harm, taking account of existing regulatory protections to avoid duplication or undue complexity, and adopting a consultative approach to avoid unintended consequences.

  31. Thomson Reuters Submission 552

    1. Apply risk-tiered governance to high-consequence AI and preserve the value of protected human-created content.

      ToR I & J: Apply risk-tiered governance to high-consequence AI and preserve the value of protected human- created content.

Open in the interactive guide