AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 100

CHOICE

Submitter group: Civil society.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

Argues gaps in consumer, competition, scams and privacy law expose consumers to AI-enabled harms, including surveillance pricing and scams. Recommends legal reforms, ACCC investigation, regular reviews, stronger regulatory powers and resources, and external dispute resolution for online complaints.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Argues that current laws may not prevent AI from reducing competition, inflating prices and worsening consumer experiences.

    Current laws may not prevent AI reducing competition, inflating pricing and worsening consumer experiences

  2. Argues that consumers' personal information should never be used to exploit vulnerability or willingness to pay, as in surveillance pricing.

    Surveillance pricing – the ability for businesses to change prices on an individual level based on personal information – is a particularly concerning example of harmful algorithmic pricing. Consumers’ personal information should never be used against them to exploit vulnerability or a perceived willingness to pay.

  3. Argues that agentic commerce could dampen competition if agents favour dominant players or if dominant players pay for prominence.

    Agentic commerce could also dampen competition where agents develop a tendency to self-preference, are more likely to recommend or preference dominant players, or if dominant players are able to pay more to increase their prominence.

  4. Argues that the Scams Prevention Framework lacks flexibility to adapt to evolving threats.

    the Government’s new Scams Prevention Framework lacks the necessary flexibility to adapt to evolving threats, and risks becoming outdated before it has even been fully implemented.

  5. Argues that digital platforms cannot be trusted to regulate scam content voluntarily because some profit from it.

    Digital platforms cannot be trusted to regulate this content voluntarily, when some of them are actively profiting from it.

  6. Argues that privacy reforms should apply economy-wide, including by removing the small business exemption.

    CHOICE continues to call on the Federal Government to implement other priority reforms from the Privacy Act review, including removing the small business exemption, to ensure privacy protections are fair and consistent regardless of the size of a business.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Ban businesses from using personal information to set individualised prices for consumers; if addressed via tranche II privacy reforms, clarify this through guidance.

    Businesses should be banned from using personal information to set individualised prices for consumers. If the Government intends to address this practice through their proposed tranche II privacy reforms, this should be clarified by providing guidance.

  2. If tranche II privacy reforms capture surveillance pricing, clarify this in explanatory-memorandum guidance; otherwise address it through further reform.

    If these reforms are intended to capture surveillance pricing, then this should be clarified through guidance in the explanatory memorandum to provide certainty for consumers and businesses. If these reforms will not be sufficient to address the practice, then it should be addressed through further reform.

  3. Extend the unfair trading prohibition under the Consumer and Competition Act to cover financial services under the ASIC Act.

    The unfair trading prohibition under the Consumer and Competition Act should be extended to cover financial services under the ASIC Act.

  4. Introduce a new provision into section 46 of the Competition and Consumer Act making it an offence to use market power to charge excessive prices.

    The Government should introduce a new provision into section 46 of the Australian Competition and Consumer Act, making it an offence for businesses to use their market power to charge excessive prices.

  5. Direct the ACCC to investigate the competition impacts of algorithmic pricing models, agentic commerce and adverse impacts on consumer bargaining power.

    The ACCC should be directed to investigate the competition impacts of algorithmic pricing models, agentic commerce and the potential adverse impacts on consumer bargaining power.

  6. Commit to regular reviews of the ACL and ASIC Act to keep pace with emerging issues with AI-based goods and services.

    The Government should commit to conducting regular reviews of the ACL and ASIC Act to ensure that it is keeping pace with new and emerging issues with AI-based goods and services.

  7. Require, under the Scam Prevention Framework, all digital platforms to undertake ongoing testing, review and updating of scam detection and disruption capabilities.

    The Scam Prevention Framework should require all digital platforms to undertake ongoing testing, review and updating of scam detection and disruption capabilities, to ensure platforms remain capable of responding to evolving scam threats.

  8. Require, under the Scam Prevention Framework, platforms that run advertisements to maintain accessible, searchable ad libraries for users and regulators.

    The Scam Prevention Framework should require digital platforms that run advertisements to maintain accessible and searchable ad libraries for users and regulators to cross-check ads.

  9. Apply the Scam Prevention Framework across all digital platform services, including generative AI services.

    The Scam Prevention Framework prevention framework should apply across all digital platform services, including generative AI services.

  10. Require platform-wide monitoring under the Scams Prevention Framework.

    the Framework should require platform-wide monitoring

  11. Pass and implement tranche II Privacy Act reforms.

    The Government should pass and implement tranche II Privacy Act reforms.

  12. Strengthen tranche II Privacy Act reforms by removing the small business exemption and broadening the right to erasure beyond large digital platforms.

    The proposed tranche II Privacy Act reforms should be further strengthened by removing the small business exemption and broadening the right to erasure beyond large digital platforms.

  13. If removing the small-business exemption and broadening erasure beyond large digital platforms are omitted from tranche II, commit to third-tranche consultation on them.

    The proposed tranche II Privacy Act reforms should be further strengthened by removing the small business exemption and broadening the right to erasure beyond large digital platforms. 11.If these key reforms are not included in tranche II, the Government should commit to further consultation to progress them in a third tranche.

    A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  14. Give regulators, including the ACCC, ASIC and OAIC, increased enforcement powers and resourcing to monitor and respond to emerging AI harms.

    Regulators — including the ACCC, ASIC and OAIC — should be given increased enforcement powers and resourcing to monitor and respond to emerging AI harms.

    A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  15. Provide a clear external dispute-resolution pathway, such as a digital ombuds scheme, that is fair, free, comprehensive, independent, effective and transparent.

    There must be a clear pathway, such as a digital ombuds scheme, for consumers to access external dispute resolution that is fair, free, comprehensive, independent, effective and transparent.

  16. Expand the TIO’s remit to resolve online issues, including AI disputes.

    The TIO’s remit should be expanded to resolve online issues and complaints, including disputes arising from the use of AI.

    A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

Read the original

In some quotes a program corrected obvious text-recognition errors for display.

Open in the interactive guide