Submission 106
Dr Morgan Serong
Submitter group: Individuals.
Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
Argues that AI is overhyped and unreliable, links its promotion to eugenic ideologies, and describes a financial bubble and harms to thinking, education, jobs and digital sovereignty. Calls for slower adoption, a data-centre moratorium, a ban on AI below postgraduate education, company liability and open source software.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues that regular AI users become more confident in AI outputs regardless of their accuracy, and cites research linking frequent AI use to reduced critical thinking.
the answers AIs give are correct and when they are not, but the more they use AI the more confident they become in the output regardless of its veracity12. The implications of this are huge. Research shows that frequent AI tool usage produces significant damage to critical thinking abilities13.
Argues that AI productivity gains will be small relative to vendor projections, citing economist Daron Acemoglu's estimate.
Nobel prize winning MIT economist Daron Acemoglu says that realistically AIs will only produce 0.55% total factor productivity gains over a decade.
Argues that reliance on proprietary AI models controlled by a few large technology companies undermines Australian digital sovereignty.
AI models are mostly proprietary software (the opposite of open source software) whose patents are jealously guarded by the big five tech companies. If we continue to work with them we will lose all digital sovereignty and forever be in thrall to these companies.
Argues that it is not legal under Australian law for AI companies to use Australian-copyrighted content to train models, and cites the Prime Minister's statement on the issue.
Under Australian Law it is not legal for AI companies to use content copyrighted in Australia to train their models. The Prime Minister said that “Our laws will spell that out, plain as day. An artist’s creative endeavour is their work and their property.
Argues that AI use in education leaves graduates unfit for work, citing employers' reports about graduates who used AI throughout their degrees.
Employers are finding that graduates who used AI throughout their entire degree are unfit for employment, finding that they have a shallowness to their thinking and as such do not meet the requirements for creative thinking employers want
Argues that if AI adoption continues at its current pace and projected job losses occur, serious social unrest would follow.
The Social Policy Group projects that, “If the adoption of AI maintains its current pace, a third (33.18 percent) of the workforce could experience a period of unemployment by 2030.”88 If this occurs it will not be long at all until serious social unrest occurs as a result of the destabilising effects of AI implementation.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Move beyond the hype and do more research into the actual effectiveness and dangers of AI.
Move beyond the hype. Do more research into the actual effectiveness and dangers of AI.
Impose an immediate moratorium on building AI data centres.
Effect an immediate moratorium on building AI data centres.
Give citizens more of a voice in whether and how AI is implemented, especially data centres.
Give citizens more of a voice in the implementation, or not, of AI, especially data centres.
Prioritise workers' input about the realities of AI.
Prioritise workers’ input about the realities of AI
Legislate to make AI companies liable for damage done by their products.
Legislate to make AI companies liable for damage done by their products.
Invest in education that nurtures students’ minds and institute an immediate ban on AI in education below postgraduate level.
Invest in education to protect our future by nurturing the minds of students rather than damaging them. Institute an immediate ban on AI in education below postgraduate level.
Disengage from the US tech oligopoly, including dependence on US companies for everyday software such as word processors, spreadsheets and databases.
Disengage from the US tech oligopoly. Not just for AI, but also remove our dependence on US companies for the everyday software which everyone uses; word processors, spreadsheets, databases.
Invest in open source software to protect digital sovereignty.
Invest in open source software to protect our digital sovereignty.
Prioritise social stability by avoiding mass disruption to the labour market.
Prioritise social stability by avoiding mass disruption to the labor market which will cause social unrest and political upheaval.
Prevent a society whose primary goal is economic success from fostering the growth of those willing to degrade others in pursuit of that goal.
Realise that any society whose primary goal is the pursuit of economic success is going to foster the growth of those who are willing to effect the degradation of others in their pursuit of that goal and that we should not allow this to happen.