Submission 121
Professor Ritesh Chugh
Submitter group: Individuals.
Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
An ICT professor argues that AI policy should be judged by whether it strengthens human capability, and that Australia's existing AI plans and education frameworks need a connected implementation pathway. Covers AI literacy, assessment reform, educator support and equity, and makes five recommendations including a national capability roadmap and an outcomes and equity evaluation program.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues AI policy should strengthen human capability rather than displace the cognitive effort through which it develops.
AI policy should be judged by whether it strengthens human capability. AI should extend human judgement, creativity, inquiry and problem-solving rather than displace the cognitive effort through which these capabilities develop.
Says the central problem is not a lack of national ambition but the absence of a coherent learner journey.
From my perspective, the central problem is not a lack of national ambition. It is the absence of a coherent learner journey.
Argues that assessment reform should make learning more visible and verifiable rather than relying on detection, which it says cannot establish AI use with certainty.
Detecting generative AI use with certainty is currently all but impossible, and relying on detection does not address why an assessment was vulnerable in the first place. Assessment reform should instead make learning more visible and verifiable, while preparing students to use generative AI ethically, critically and responsibly.
Says current evidence supports neither uncritical adoption nor blanket prohibition, noting much of the literature is short-term with limited longitudinal evidence.
Current evidence supports neither uncritical adoption nor blanket prohibition. Much of the literature is based on user perceptions and short-term, relatively small-scale studies, with limited longitudinal evidence.
Says making generative AI tools available does not mean everyone will benefit equally, based on experience across metropolitan and regional higher education.
My experience across metropolitan and regional higher education has shown me that making generative AI tools available does not mean that everyone will benefit equally.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Connect existing foundations through an implementation pathway specifying progressive capabilities, responsibilities, minimum supports and outcome measures, allowing adaptation across sectors, disciplines and communities.
The policy opportunity is to connect the existing foundations through a national implementation pathway that identifies progressive capabilities, responsibilities, minimum supports and outcome measures, while allowing appropriate adaptation across sectors, disciplines and communities.
Guide publicly funded initiatives, institutional pilots and procurement by evaluating retained and transferable capability, reasoning and effects on inequalities.
The important evaluation questions are not simply whether generative AI was used or whether users were satisfied. What capability improved, for whom and under what conditions? Was that capability retained and transferred? Could users explain and defend their reasoning? Did the intervention reduce or widen existing inequalities? These questions should guide publicly funded initiatives, institutional pilots and procurement decisions.
Clarify permitted generative AI use, required acknowledgement, information barred from external systems and work students must explain independently; support educators to apply expectations consistently and fairly.
Students also need clear and consistent expectations. They should know how generative AI may be used, what use must be acknowledged, what information must not be entered into external systems, and which aspects of their work they must be able to explain independently. Educators need institutional support to apply these expectations consistently and fairly.
Extend educator professional development beyond tool familiarity to learning design, assessment judgement, privacy, bias, accessibility and disciplinary applications.
Professional development must move beyond familiarity with generative AI tools to address learning design, assessment judgement, privacy, bias, accessibility and disciplinary applications.
Provide educators with dedicated time, technical assistance and secure institutional tools.
Educators also need dedicated time, technical assistance and access to secure institutional tools.
Consider growing energy and infrastructure demands in procurement and decisions about large-scale adoption.
Their growing energy and infrastructure demands add an environmental dimension that should be considered in procurement and decisions about large-scale adoption.
Develop a cross-sector national AI-capability roadmap through industry, education, employment and skills portfolios, building on existing frameworks, consulting states and sector bodies, clarifying responsibilities, supporting transitions and prioritising implementation.
1. Develop a national AI capability implementation roadmap: The Australian Government, through the portfolios responsible for industry, education, employment and skills, should build on the National AI Plan and existing sector frameworks by identifying the AI capabilities Australians should progressively develop across schools, VET, higher education and workplaces. Developed in consultation with state and territory governments and relevant sector bodies, the roadmap should clarify responsibilities, support transitions between sectors and focus on implementation rather than creating another set of principles.
Make human capability central; define AI literacy through critical evaluation, ethical and lawful use, privacy, disciplinary judgement, disclosure and independent work when AI is unavailable, unreliable or inappropriate.
2. Make human capability development the central educational objective: Define AI literacy to include critical evaluation, ethical and lawful use, privacy, disciplinary judgement, disclosure and the ability to work independently when AI is unavailable, unreliable or inappropriate.
Evaluate whether AI strengthens sustained learning, inquiry and problem-solving rather than simply improving immediate task performance.
Evaluate whether AI strengthens sustained learning, inquiry and problem-solving, rather than simply improving immediate task performance.
Provide sustained funding for discipline-specific professional development, communities of practice, secure institutional tools and practical implementation support.
The Australian Government should provide sustained funding for discipline-specific professional development, communities of practice, secure institutional tools and practical implementation support.
Have ATEC support higher-education implementation and coordination between higher education and relevant VET bodies.
The Australian Tertiary Education Commission (ATEC) should support implementation in higher education and coordination between higher education and relevant VET bodies.
Give particular attention to regional and resource-constrained providers, involving educators and learners in designing and evaluating AI initiatives.
Particular attention should be given to regional and resource- constrained providers, with educators and learners involved in designing and evaluating AI initiatives.
Have the Department of Education support sector-specific assessment reform, with TEQSA guiding higher education and relevant authorities leading schools and VET.
The Department of Education should support sector-specific reform, with TEQSA continuing to guide higher education and relevant authorities leading work in schools and VET.
Combine authentic generative AI-enabled assessment with appropriate learning verification, including staged work, development-process evidence, oral explanation and supervised demonstration.
Providers should combine authentic, generative AI-enabled assessment with appropriate ways of verifying learning, including staged work, evidence of the development process, oral explanation and supervised demonstration.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Set clear, consistent expectations on generative AI use, disclosure, privacy and accountability, allowing adaptation across disciplines and levels of study.
Expectations concerning generative AI use, disclosure, privacy and accountability should be clear and consistent while allowing adaptation across disciplines and levels of study.
Establish and fund a national AI outcomes and equity program monitoring access, benefits, capabilities and harms by location and learner group.
5. Establish and fund a national program to evaluate AI outcomes and equity: The Australian Government should monitor who has access to AI, who benefits, what capabilities are developed and what harms emerge, with findings examined by location and learner group.
Fund longitudinal and discipline-specific research on AI's effects on learning, problem-solving, workforce capability and equity.
The program should fund longitudinal and discipline-specific research into the effects of AI on learning, problem-solving, workforce capability and equity.
Consider accessibility, social equity and environmental sustainability when expanding AI initiatives.
It should also consider accessibility, social equity and environmental sustainability when AI initiatives are expanded.
Read the original
In some quotes a program corrected obvious text-recognition errors for display.