Submission 129
Nooriam and LexChip
Submitter group: Companies.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
Nooriam and LexChip, which say they build the technology proposed and have filed provisional patent applications, argue that autonomous AI agents create a 'legal attribution gap'. They propose registering agents and data against an identified legal person, and make seven recommendations, including mandatory standards, Commonwealth agency rules, sovereign infrastructure, hardware-level enforcement and Legal Profession Uniform Law reform.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues that existing legal infrastructure cannot attribute liability or allocate rights for autonomous AI agents' activity, a deficit they call the legal attribution gap.
Similarly, legal risks and rights associated with autonomous deployment cannot be managed by existing analogue legal infrastructure. The resulting deficit is bidirectional. It concerns the attribution of liability when an agent causes harm, and it concerns the allocation of rights, including data rights and economic rights, generated by agent activity.
Argues that AI agents are the first actors able to undertake consequential economic activity without an identified, capacitated and reachable responsible person as a legal precondition.
In each case, the State ensures that an identified, capacitated and reachable person exists, and it makes that identification a precondition of the right to legally undertake activities. AI agents are the first class of actor who can undertake consequential economic activity without that precondition.
Argues that agent registration could be delivered through an accredited independent registry, with the Commonwealth setting accreditation standards and interoperability with the Digital ID System, rather than a new government register.
Recommendation R1 asks for that requirement to be delivered through an accredited independent registry, with the Commonwealth setting accreditation standards and interoperability with the Digital ID System rather than building and funding a new register itself.
Argues that legal infrastructure for AI should be sovereign, independent and owned or controlled by people with duties akin to officers of the court.
Legal infrastructure should be sovereign and independent. Legal infrastructure should also be owned or at a minimum controlled by those with legal duties commensurate to those bestowed on officers of the court.
Argues that the human-in-the-loop model is strained because standards of care increasingly require tools that outperform humans while duties remain with humans.
Each of these standards therefore “ratchets toward the tool” while leaving the duty with humans, who inevitably have a more limited span of control. The human in the loop is asked to sit between a system the law requires the person to use and an outcome the law holds the person responsible for.
Says LexChip embeds legal safeguards in physical devices so enforcement operates with or without a network.
LexChip embeds a Legal Harness and its clauses into the physical device, so that the governed substrate travels with the physical device and enforcement operates with or without a network.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Use the AUL Project to inform government policy.
The AUL Project should inform Government policy
Make registration of a deployed AI agent, and of the data it acts on, against an identified legal person a condition of participation in regulated activity or any economic activity.
Make registration of a deployed AI agent, and of the data it acts on, against an identified legal person (i.e. a principal) a condition of participation in regulated activity or any economic activity.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Implement registration by extending the Digital ID Act 2024 accreditation scheme through an accredited independent registry rather than a new government-operated register.
The registration process can be implemented as an extension of the Digital ID Act 2024 (Cth) accreditation scheme through an accredited independent registry rather than a new government- operated register (Section 3.1).
Have the Commonwealth set registration accreditation standards and interoperability with the Digital ID System.
Recommendation R1 asks for that requirement to be delivered through an accredited independent registry, with the Commonwealth setting accreditation standards and interoperability with the Digital ID System rather than building and funding a new register itself.
Design mandatory Australian Standards for AI so a deployed agent's responsible person, authority and scope are verifiable at runtime, and recognise machine-readable smart legal instruments as a compliance pathway alongside conduct rules.
Design the mandatory Australian Standards for AI so that a deployed agent's responsible person, authority and scope are verifiable at runtime, and recognise machine-readable smart legal instruments as a compliance pathway alongside conduct rules
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Require Commonwealth agencies to record the accountable principal's authorisation of each agent in machine-readable form compiled into the agent's credential, and to admit only registered agents at the agentic channel.
Require Commonwealth agencies to record the accountable principal's authorisation of each agent in machine-readable form compiled into the agent's credential, and to admit only registered agents at the agentic channel
Treat AI legal infrastructure and control as sovereign and independent, owned or controlled by persons with court-officer-like duties; procure Australian-built registry/enforcement components and recognise registered data/AI as assets capable of above-cost valuation.
Treat legal infrastructure for AI and the control of AI as sovereign, independent infrastructure, owned or controlled by persons subject to legal duties analogous to those of officers of the court: procure Australian-built registry and enforcement components, and recognise registered data and AI systems as an asset class capable of valuation above cost
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Support hardware and software level enforcement of legal constraints for software, embodied and edge AI in critical infrastructure and defence, with the AI Safety Institute and ASD evaluating silicon-embedded and software-embedded compliance as a control.
Support hardware and software level enforcement of legal constraints for software, embodied and edge AI in critical infrastructure and defence, with the Australian AI Safety Institute and ASD evaluating silicon-embedded and software-embedded compliance as a control
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Define a registered legal system in s 6: an approved-register Legally Authenticated System anchored to an authorised principal, with a mandate recording scope, escalation and decommissioning triggers.
New defined term in s 6: "registered legal system". An AI system registered on an approved register as a Legally Authenticated System, anchored to an authorised principal, and governed by a mandate recording its authorised scope, escalation pathway and decommissioning trigger.
Amend s 6 and s 10 so AI providing legal services engages in legal practice, qualified only while registered; treat unregistered public-service systems as unqualified and expose their operators under s 10.
Amend "engage in legal practice" (s 6) and the s 10 prohibition. Provide that an AI system which provides legal services engages in legal practice, and that it is a qualified entity for s 10 only while it is a registered legal system. An unregistered system delivering legal services to the public is then an unqualified entity, and the person operating it is exposed under s 10 in the same way as any unqualified person.
Amend law-practice and legal-services definitions so costs, disclosure, trust-money, complaints and discipline provisions apply to registered systems working for law practices.
Amend "law practice" and "legal services". Extend "legal services" to services delivered by a registered legal system on behalf of a law practice, so the costs, disclosure, trust money, complaints and discipline provisions apply to the system's work as they apply to each legal practitioner.
Amend the principal definition and s 105 to require every registered legal system to have an authorised principal; apply the s 106 seven-day offence if none exists.
Amend "principal" (s 6) and s 105. Add to the definition of principal the authorised principal to whom a registered legal system is anchored, and require under s 105 that every registered legal system has at least one authorised principal, with the s 106 seven-day offence applying if it has none.
Amend ss 34–35 to require principals to monitor and govern registered legal systems, and recognise system governance records as evidence of steps taken to prevent contraventions.
Amend s 34 (responsibility of principals) and s 35 (liability of principals). Provide that principals of a law practice are responsible for implementing systems to monitor and govern each registered legal system, and that for s 35(1)(b) the governance record produced by the registered legal system under its control is evidence of the steps the principal took to prevent a contravention.
Amend s 212 to require approved professional indemnity policies to cover each registered legal system anchored to the practice.
Amend s 212 (professional indemnity insurance). Require the approved policy to cover the acts of each registered legal system anchored to the practice.
Extend the reform to other professions whose duties attach to registered individuals: define registered AI systems and require anchoring to a registered individual answerable for them.
In each statute below the duty attaches to a registered individual and an entity delivers the service only through that individual, so an AI platform delivering the service either sits outside the Act or is attributed after the event to whichever registered person is found behind it. The amendment proposed for the Uniform Law applies to each in the same form: a defined term for a registered AI system, a requirement that the system be anchored to a registered individual who answers for it.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Read the original
In some quotes a program corrected obvious text-recognition errors for display.