AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 132

Music Victoria

Submitter group: Creative sector.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

Describes the perspective of Victorian artists and small music businesses, arguing that AI policy should secure consent, transparency and fair remuneration for the use of creative work, protect voice and likeness, identify synthetic content, protect Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property, and support small businesses to adopt AI.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Argues that use of copyright works for AI training should require rights holder consent, and no compulsory licence should remove it.

    The use of copyright works for AI training should require the consent of the relevant rights holder. Australia should not introduce a compulsory licence or other mechanism that effectively removes that consent.

  2. Argues that aI developers should provide information about copyright works and datasets used in training so creators can identify use and enforce rights.

    AI developers should be required to provide appropriate information about copyright works and datasets used in training so creators and rights holders can identify use of their work and enforce their rights.

  3. Argues that if a new market is being built from artists' work, artists should share in the value it creates.

    If a new market is being built from artists' work, artists should share in the value it creates.

  4. Recommends protection against unauthorised replication of voice, image and likeness, and clear identification of AI-generated content.

    Australia should provide accessible and enforceable protection against the unauthorised digital replication of voice, image and likeness, including effective takedown mechanisms. AI generated content should also be clearly identified so audiences know what they are hearing and artists and businesses can distinguish between human created and synthetic content.

  5. Recommends further investigation of music streaming and recommendation systems, including the AAM proposal for an ACCC inquiry into music streaming.

    Music Victoria therefore supports further investigation of music streaming and recommendation systems, including the AAM proposal for an ACCC inquiry into music streaming.

  6. Argues that national AI skills and small business programs should explicitly include the creative industries and use existing industry networks to reach people.

    National AI skills and small business programs should explicitly include the creative industries and make use of existing industry networks to reach the people who need them.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Require rights holder consent for use of copyright works in AI training, and do not introduce a compulsory licence or other mechanism that effectively removes that consent.

    1. Protect consent and copyright. The use of copyright works for AI training should require the consent of the relevant rights holder. Australia should not introduce a compulsory licence or other mechanism that effectively removes that consent.

  2. Require AI developers to provide appropriate information about copyright works and datasets used in training so creators and rights holders can identify use and enforce their rights.

    2. Require transparency. AI developers should be required to provide appropriate information about copyright works and datasets used in training so creators and rights holders can identify use of their work and enforce their rights.

  3. Support the AAM artist protection framework, including meaningful artist consent and fair artist and songwriter shares of revenue from AI training uses.

    3. Protect artists as well as rights holders. Music Victoria supports the AAM artist protection framework, including meaningful artist consent and mechanisms to ensure artists and songwriters share fairly in revenue generated from AI training uses of their work.

  4. Introduce effective protection against unauthorised digital replication of voice, image and likeness, with accessible remedies and platform takedown mechanisms.

    4. Protect voice, image and likeness. Australia should introduce effective protection against unauthorised digital replication, supported by accessible remedies and platform takedown mechanisms.

  5. Clearly identify AI-generated music and investigate AI-enabled streaming fraud.

    5. Improve transparency in synthetic content and music discovery. AI generated music should be clearly identified. Government should also investigate AI enabled streaming fraud and the role of algorithmic recommendation systems in determining how Australian music is served to Australian audiences.

  6. Progress standalone protection for Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property, developed and led by First Nations organisations and knowledge holders.

    6. Protect Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property. The Australian Government should progress standalone protection developed and led by First Nations organisations and knowledge holders.

  7. Include creative workers and music businesses in national AI skills and adoption initiatives, with sector-specific support delivered through trusted industry bodies.

    7. Help creative workers and small businesses benefit from AI. Creative workers and music businesses should be included in national AI skills and adoption initiatives, with practical sector specific support delivered through trusted industry bodies.

  8. Support licensing based on genuine consent, credit and compensation.

    Music Victoria supports a licensing market based on genuine consent, credit and compensation.

  9. Ensure artists have meaningful knowledge and agency over new uses of their work and creative identity, particularly under contracts entered before generative AI training was contemplated.

    Artists should have meaningful knowledge and agency over new uses of their work and creative identity, particularly where contracts were entered into before generative AI training was contemplated.

  10. Include AI-enabled impersonation, fraudulent artist profiles and streaming manipulation in the regulatory response.

    AI enabled impersonation, fraudulent artist profiles and streaming manipulation should also form part of the regulatory response.

  11. Investigate music streaming and recommendation systems through an ACCC inquiry, as proposed by the AAM.

    Music Victoria therefore supports further investigation of music streaming and recommendation systems, including the AAM proposal for an ACCC inquiry into music streaming.

  12. Introduce proportionate transparency requirements on the representation of Australian and AI-generated content in recommendations, without requiring disclosure of proprietary algorithms.

    We also support proportionate transparency requirements that allow government and industry to understand the representation of Australian content and AI generated content in recommendations. This does not require platforms to disclose proprietary algorithms.

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide