AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 150

Australian Fusion Industry

Submitter group: Industry bodies.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

Argues AI infrastructure needs integrated energy, water, sovereign compute and regional planning, with accountable decisions and resilient civilian hubs separated from defence systems. Treats fusion as a conditional future option, with available technologies needed near term. A supplement proposes investigating a nationally networked Queensland AI, quantum and fusion centre, expressly without project approval or government endorsement.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Argues that Australia should treat AI as enabling national infrastructure, not merely as software or an additional source of data centre demand.

    Australia should treat artificial intelligence as enabling national infrastructure, not merely as software or an additional source of data centre demand.

  2. Argues that advanced computing capacity should not remain concentrated in southern metropolitan corridors and that sovereign compute and supporting industries should also be developed in the north.

    A large share of Australia’s advanced computing capacity should not be concentrated indefinitely in a small number of southern metropolitan corridors. Appropriate sovereign compute, data centres, and supporting industries should also be developed closer to northern population, production, and defence-supporting regions.

  3. In a supplementary submission, proposes a Queensland-based, nationally networked Centre of Excellence joining sovereign AI and data-centre capability with quantum computing, fusion research and other fields.

    The proposed next step is a Queensland-based, nationally networked Centre of Excellence that joins sovereign AI and data-centre capability with quantum computing, fusion research and future Fusion Machines, renewables and storage, robotics, digital twins, water security, and advanced manufacturing.

  4. Says fusion is a strategic option that policy should not exclude, and is not presented as a guaranteed or immediate answer.

    Fusion is not presented here as a guaranteed or immediate answer. It is a strategic option that should not be excluded by technology-specific policy designed only around present systems.

  5. Argues that sovereignty is not achieved merely because servers are physically located in Australia.

    Sovereignty is not achieved merely because servers are physically located in Australia.

  6. Argues that Commonwealth AI use should always leave a clearly accountable decision maker.

    Commonwealth AI use should always leave a clearly accountable decision maker.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Prepare a National AI Infrastructure, Energy and Water Plan covering compute, electricity, transmission, water production, treatment and storage, communications, land, workforce, housing and emergency resilience.

    Prepare a National AI Infrastructure, Energy and Water Plan covering compute capacity, electricity, transmission, water production, treatment and storage, communications, land, workforce, housing, and emergency resilience.

  2. Develop a northern and regional AI infrastructure strategy that identifies suitable civilian growth hubs near, but appropriately separated from, defence-supporting and critical industrial centres.

    Develop a northern and regional AI infrastructure strategy that identifies suitable civilian growth hubs near, but appropriately separated from, defence-supporting and critical industrial centres.

  3. Require nationally significant data centre proposals to assess whether regional or northern locations could give stronger sovereign, productivity and resilience outcomes than further metropolitan concentration.

    Require nationally significant data centre proposals to assess whether regional or northern locations could provide stronger sovereign, productivity, and resilience outcomes than further metropolitan concentration.

  4. Establish a network of secure regional compute and energy hubs using distributed generation, storage, microgrids, redundant communications and controlled grid connection.

    Establish a network of secure regional compute and energy hubs using distributed generation, storage, microgrids, redundant communications and controlled connection to the wider electricity system.

  5. Require critical AI facilities to demonstrate proportionate physical hardening, cyber segmentation, backup capability, black-start planning and the capacity to sustain priority local operations during network disruption.

    Require critical AI facilities to demonstrate proportionate physical hardening, cyber segmentation, backup capability, black-start planning and the capacity to sustain priority local operations during wider network disruption.

  6. Ensure data centre proponents fund attributable electricity, water production and security, communications and transport upgrades without avoidable costs falling on households, small businesses, agriculture or existing regional industries.

    Ensure that data centre proponents fund attributable electricity, water production and security, communications and transport upgrades and do not transfer avoidable costs to households, small businesses, agriculture, or existing regional industries.

  7. Create an Australian sovereign compute procurement framework considering ownership, operational control, data location, supply-chain assurance, maintainability and Australian access during emergencies.

    Create an Australian sovereign compute procurement framework that considers ownership, operational control, data location, supply-chain assurance, maintainability, and Australian access during emergencies.

  8. Support narrow, domain-specific AI models trained under Australian governance for sectors including resources, agriculture, maritime, electricity systems, manufacturing, health, emergency management and fusion engineering.

    Support narrow, domain-specific AI models trained under Australian governance for resources, agriculture, maritime operations, electricity systems, advanced manufacturing, health, emergency management, and fusion engineering.

  9. Establish national programmes for AI-enabled digital twins, robotics, remote maintenance and predictive asset management across critical infrastructure and future Fusion Machines.

    Establish national programmes for AI-enabled digital twins, robotics, remote maintenance and predictive asset management across critical infrastructure and future Fusion Machines.

  10. Build technical education pathways linking schools, TAFEs, universities, defence industry, resources, utilities and manufacturers, including retention of experienced workers’ practical knowledge.

    Build technical education pathways linking schools, TAFEs, universities, defence industry, resources, utilities, and manufacturers, including mechanisms to retain the practical knowledge of experienced workers.

  11. Require transparent Commonwealth AI procurement, documented human accountability, auditable decision pathways and effective review rights where decisions materially affect individuals or businesses.

    Require transparent Commonwealth AI procurement, documented human accountability, auditable decision pathways, and effective review rights where decisions materially affect individuals or businesses.

  12. Treat the security of AI models, training data, hardware, cloud services, energy supply and communications as one connected critical-infrastructure problem.

    Treat the security of AI models, training data, computer hardware, cloud services, energy supply, and communications as one connected critical-infrastructure problem.

  13. Maintain technology-neutral energy policy allowing future Fusion Machines to be assessed separately from Nuclear Fission on their demonstrated characteristics.

    Maintain technology-neutral energy policy that allows future Fusion Machines to be assessed separately from Nuclear Fission and on their demonstrated characteristics.

  14. Commission an independent assessment of future energy-dense generation for northern civilian, industrial and defence-supporting growth, covering desalination and water treatment, safety, cooling water, logistics, workforce, waste, security, cost and decommissioning.

    Commission an independent assessment of future energy-dense generation for northern civilian, industrial and defence- supporting growth, including its capacity to support desalination and water treatment, and its safety, cooling-water, logistics, workforce, waste, security, cost, and decommissioning requirements.

  15. Coordinate AI infrastructure planning across the Commonwealth, states, territories, local government and regional communities rather than relying on isolated project approvals.

    Coordinate AI infrastructure planning across the Commonwealth, states, territories, local government, and regional communities rather than relying on isolated project approvals.

  16. Link public support to measurable Australian research, domestic procurement, apprenticeships, regional employment, exports, cyber resilience and secure compute access for Australian institutions and smaller businesses.

    Public support should be linked to measurable benefits such as Australian research, domestic procurement, apprenticeships, regional employment, export capability, cyber resilience, and secure access to compute for Australian institutions and smaller businesses.

  17. Use scenario-based planning rather than one demand forecast; test average and peak demand, cooling, grid effects, backup arrangements and cumulative regional impacts in approvals.

    This strengthens the case for scenario-based planning rather than a single demand forecast. Approvals should test average and peak demand, cooling requirements, grid effects, backup arrangements, and cumulative regional impacts.

  18. Include housing, health services, food and water security, transport, emergency services and liveable communities in regional planning rather than assuming indefinite fly-in labour.

    Planning must include housing, health services, food and water security, transport, emergency services, and liveable communities, rather than assuming that labour can be flown in indefinitely.

  19. Select resilient northern hubs through transparent, evidence-based assessment, considering site hazards and costs rather than compulsorily relocating all data centres north.

    Location decisions must remain evidence based. Heat, humidity, cyclones, floods, water availability, supply- chain distance, workforce depth, and insurance cost can make some northern sites unsuitable. The answer is not a compulsory northward relocation of all data centres. It is a national portfolio that avoids excessive concentration and selects several resilient hubs through transparent assessment.

  20. Keep civilian facilities geographically, operationally and institutionally separated from sensitive defence systems, and omit exploitable dependencies, precise vulnerabilities and single points of failure from public documents.

    Civilian facilities should have appropriate geographic, network and governance separation from sensitive systems. Public documents should not identify exploitable dependencies, precise vulnerabilities, or single points of failure.

  21. Have the Commonwealth assess strategic value without defence demand absorbing all local capacity or shifting costs to communities; deliver stronger civilian grids, communications, skills and services.

    The Commonwealth should assess strategic value without allowing defence demand to absorb all local capacity or transfer costs to regional communities. Civilian users should gain from the investment through stronger grids, communications, skills, and services.

  22. Allow defence, commercial and public-service functions to share enabling infrastructure only where safe, with suitable access controls and independent fail-safe arrangements.

    Defence requirements, commercial operations and public-service functions may share enabling infrastructure where safe, but must retain suitable access controls and independent fail-safe arrangements.

  23. Keep infrastructure hardening proportionate to consequence and threat, without concealing environmental or community impacts.

    Hardening should be proportionate to consequence and threat. It can include cyclone and flood design, fire separation, protected control rooms, spare transformers and switchgear, cyber segmentation, manual operating modes, black-start capability, fuel diversity, protected water systems, and tested recovery plans. It should not be interpreted as a licence to conceal environmental or community impacts.

  24. Design water security alongside energy, land use and settlement planning; prevent data-centre development displacing household, agricultural, environmental or existing industrial water needs.

    Water security must therefore be designed alongside energy security, land use, and settlement planning. Data-centre development should not displace household, agricultural, environmental, or existing industrial water needs.

  25. Have regional resilience plans assess protected catchments, recycled water, stormwater recovery, efficient cooling, wastewater treatment and desalination where appropriate.

    Regional resilience plans should assess diversified water sources, including protected catchments, recycled water, stormwater recovery, efficient cooling, wastewater treatment, and desalination where appropriate.

  26. Plan water networks with distributed storage, redundant pumping, secure controls and operating plans for cyclone, flood, drought, contamination, cyber incidents and loss of the wider grid.

    Water networks should include distributed storage, redundant pumping, secure controls and operating plans for cyclone, flood, drought, contamination, cyber incident, and loss of the wider electricity grid.

  27. Do not approve northern projects on an assumed water advantage.

    No northern project should be approved on an assumed water advantage.

  28. Retain fusion as an option for transparent comparison with renewables, storage, transmission and other firm supply when credible commercial designs become available.

    Fusion should be retained as an option to be compared transparently with renewable generation, storage, transmission, and other firm supply when credible commercial designs are available.

  29. Use available, commercially supportable technologies near term; preserve future energy-dense options only if safety, performance, regulatory compliance and commercial viability are demonstrated.

    Near-term supply must use technologies that are technically available and commercially supportable. In parallel, policy should preserve a pathway for future energy-dense technologies, including Fusion Machines, if and when they demonstrate safety, performance, regulatory compliance, and commercial viability.

  30. Allow evidence-based fusion assessment when proponents demonstrate performance, safety, financing, fuel and materials supply, environmental protection, security and decommissioning.

    Australia should therefore neither promise fusion delivery nor exclude it. A technology-neutral pathway would allow a Fusion Machine to be assessed on evidence when a proponent can demonstrate performance, safety, financing, fuel and materials supply, environmental protection, security, and decommissioning.

  31. Focus a national AI industrial programme on transferable capability and verified industrial problems; condition research funding on data governance, reproducible evaluation, cyber security and Australian commercialisation pathways.

    A national programme should focus on transferable capability and verified industrial problems. Research funding should require credible data governance, reproducible evaluation, cyber security, and pathways to Australian commercialisation.

  32. Respect privacy, Indigenous data governance, commercial confidence, security classifications and intellectual property when accessing Australian domain data for narrow models.

    Australia has valuable domain data from resources, agriculture, maritime operations, harsh-environment engineering, electricity systems, health, and emergency management. Narrow models trained for defined Australian purposes may create more defensible capability than attempting to reproduce every general-purpose model. Access must respect privacy, Indigenous data governance, commercial confidence, security classifications, and intellectual property.

  33. Assess the domestic training pipeline’s capacity by numbers, occupations and locations; use migration to complement training where insufficient, rather than substitute for it.

    Australia must determine whether its domestic training pipeline can supply the numbers, occupations and locations required. Where it cannot, migration policy should complement training rather than substitute for it.

  34. Keep a clearly accountable decision maker for Commonwealth AI use.

    Commonwealth AI use should always leave a clearly accountable decision maker.

  35. Tell people affected by significant automated decisions when AI materially contributed, provide intelligible explanations and effective review pathways.

    People affected by significant automated decisions should be told when AI materially contributed, given an intelligible explanation and provided with an effective review pathway.

  36. Prevent procurement confidentiality clauses from blocking authorised public-body audits.

    Procurement contracts should not permit commercial confidentiality to prevent audit by authorised public bodies.

  37. Test critical-infrastructure AI for cyber compromise, manipulated training data, drift, deceptive inputs, unsafe automation and foreign-support dependence; require safe failure, manual recovery and realistic disruption exercises.

    Critical-infrastructure AI should be tested for cyber compromise, manipulated training data, model drift, deceptive inputs, unsafe automation, and dependence on foreign support. Systems should fail safely, retain manual recovery paths, and be exercised under realistic disruption scenarios.

  38. Have security assurance cover AI models, data, hardware, communications, energy and human operators as one system.

    Security assurance must cover the model, data, hardware, communications, energy, and human operators as one system.

  39. Have the Committee recommend staged implementation rather than another stand-alone strategy.

    The Committee should recommend staged implementation rather than another stand-alone strategy.

  40. Within twelve months, establish a Commonwealth taskforce covering industry, energy, infrastructure, regional development, defence, education, home affairs, science and communications.

    Within twelve months, the Commonwealth should establish a cross-portfolio taskforce covering industry, energy, infrastructure, regional development, defence, education, home affairs, science, and communications.

  41. Publish an initial national map of compute demand, energy and water requirements, skills constraints and regional opportunities without disclosing security-sensitive information.

    It should publish an initial national map of compute demand, energy and water requirements, skills constraints and regional opportunities at a level that does not disclose security-sensitive information.

  42. Within two years, openly select regional demonstration hubs testing generation, storage, communications, islanding, compute access, workforce and community benefits; independently compare cost, reliability, emissions, water, employment and recovery.

    Within two years, governments should select several regional demonstration hubs through open assessment. Each should test local generation and storage, secure communications, islandable operation, shared compute access, workforce development, and community benefit arrangements. Independent evaluation should compare cost, reliability, emissions, water use, local employment, and recovery performance.

  43. Plan long term to preserve sites, corridors, skills and regulatory pathways for technologies that may mature in the 2030s and beyond, including Fusion Machines, only after evidence-based assessment.

    Longer-term planning should preserve sites, corridors, skills, and regulatory pathways for technologies that may mature in the 2030s and beyond. This includes Fusion Machines, but only after evidence-based assessment.

  44. Provide regular parliamentary reporting so assumptions can be corrected as AI demand, energy technology and strategic conditions change.

    Regular parliamentary reporting would allow assumptions to be corrected as AI demand, energy technology and strategic conditions change.

  45. Supplementary: make the Centre a national coordination node connecting universities, governments, defence-supporting industry, communities, manufacturers, SMEs and research organisations across Australia, rather than concentrating capability exclusively in one state.

    The Centre should be a national coordination node rather than an exclusive concentration of capability in one state. It should connect universities, governments, defence-supporting industry, regional communities, manufacturers, smaller businesses, and research organisations across Australia.

  46. Supplementary: complement established programmes without duplication, requiring national participation, transparent access, Australian benefit tests and interstate collaboration in the Centre’s governance.

    A Centre should complement, not duplicate, established programs. Its governance should require national participation, transparent access, Australian benefit tests and collaboration with other states and territories.

  47. Supplementary: compare complete, site-specific energy and water systems while preserving fusion as an option.

    The correct policy is to preserve the option and compare complete, site-specific energy and water systems.

  48. Supplementary: consider staged public investment in common-user research, testing, workforce development and proportionate regulation.

    Australia should adapt, not copy, these models. A staged program could comprise: • public investment in common-user research, testing, workforce development, and proportionate regulation;

  49. Supplementary: consider competitive consortia linking Australian universities, manufacturers, AI, quantum and fusion organisations, with milestone-gated public co-investment, independent technical review and increasing private capital.

    competitive consortia linking Australian universities, manufacturers, AI and quantum organisations and fusion companies; • milestone-gated public co-investment with independent technical review and increasing private capital;

  50. Supplementary: consider a privately led demonstration subject to every legal, safety, environmental and community requirement, with Australian procurement, IP, skills, supply-chain and public-value conditions and no open-ended subsidy.

    a privately led demonstration proposal, subject to every legal, safety, environmental and community requirement; and • Australian procurement, intellectual-property, skills, supply-chain, and public-value conditions, without open-ended subsidy.

  51. Supplementary: commission a time-limited feasibility study for a Queensland-based, nationally networked AI, Quantum and Fusion Centre of Excellence, with participation open across all states and territories.

    That the Australian Government commission a time-limited feasibility study for a Queensland-based, nationally networked AI, Quantum, and Fusion Centre of Excellence, with participation open across all states and territories.

  52. Supplementary: require major AI data-centre policy to include integrated plans for additional electricity, grid impacts, water, communications, housing, transport, cyber security, emergency operation and attributable infrastructure costs.

    That major AI data-centre policy require integrated plans for additional electricity, grid impacts, water, communications, housing, transport, cyber security, emergency operation, and attributable infrastructure costs.

  53. Supplementary: preserve grid purchase agreements, dedicated connections, shared microgrids or assessed colocation for future fusion power at selected AI data-centre precincts, meeting safety, security, planning and environmental requirements.

    For selected AI data-centre precincts, planning should preserve four potential integration pathways when fusion-generated electricity becomes available: • a grid power-purchase agreement; • a dedicated nearby connection; • a shared local microgrid; and • assessed colocation where safety, security, planning, and environmental requirements are met.

  54. Supplementary: Commonwealth and Queensland to undertake coordinated legal analysis of fusion energy under radiation, environmental, planning, electricity and security laws, including the EPBC Act term "nuclear power station".

    That the Commonwealth and Queensland undertake coordinated legal analysis of fusion energy under radiation, environmental, planning, electricity, and security laws, including clarification of the EPBC Act expression “nuclear power station”.

  55. Supplementary: make Australian law and policy distinguish fusion energy and Fusion Machines from Nuclear Fission while maintaining proportionate, risk-based protections.

    That Australian law and policy distinguish fusion energy and Fusion Machines from Nuclear Fission while maintaining proportionate, risk-based protections.

  56. Supplementary: establish a competitive, milestone-gated public-private pathway for an Australian fusion industry, including common-user facilities, national-laboratory access, workforce programs and independently reviewed demonstrations.

    That the Australian Government establish a competitive, milestone-gated public-private pathway for an Australian fusion industry, including common-user facilities, national-laboratory access, workforce programs, and independently reviewed demonstrations.

  57. Supplementary: attach measurable Australian procurement, IP, skills, manufacturing, SME, regional benefit and export obligations to public support for AI, quantum, data-centre and fusion projects.

    That public support for AI, quantum, data-centre and fusion projects include measurable Australian procurement, intellectual-property, skills, manufacturing, SME participation, regional benefit, and export-development obligations.

  58. Supplementary: have the proposed Centre establish a secure test and assurance environment for AI in energy, water, critical infrastructure and defence-supporting industry, with human accountability and transparent evaluation.

    That the proposed Centre establish a secure test and assurance environment for AI used in energy, water, critical infrastructure, and defence-supporting industry, with human accountability and transparent evaluation.

  59. Supplementary: ensure no project is represented as approved until all government decisions, statutory approvals, financing, site selection and community consultation requirements are completed.

    That no project be represented as approved until all government decisions, statutory approvals, financing, site selection, and community consultation requirements have actually been completed.

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide