AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 153

Dr Samantha Pillay OAM

Submitter group: Individuals.

Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

A surgeon, writing personally, not for the College, proposes sovereign health data, data-centre conditions, an Australian-controlled open health model and AI-assisted training. Says model control matters more than savings and costs initially exceed subscriptions. Recommends Indigenous data governance, use-based clinical AI regulation, independent testing and supplier liability, and distinguishing copyright learning from copying while preserving public-health training access.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Proposes that approval of a large data centre carry four conditions: Australian health, government and public-model data stays in Australia; that data is not used to train any model without Australian approval; computers reserved for Australian public use; and the company trains Australian workers.

    Approval of a large data centre should carry four conditions: Australian health, government and public-model data stays in Australia; that data is not used to train any model without Australian approval; a set of computers inside the building is reserved for Australian public use; and the company trains Australian workers.

  2. Argues that data location alone is insufficient; health data should be held by Australian-owned and controlled providers on their own servers with locally held encryption keys.

    For health data the rule should be: an Australian-owned and controlled provider, running its own servers, in Australia, with the data encrypted and the key held here.

  3. Proposes that the Commonwealth fund an Australian health model: a free open model adapted to Australian guidelines and data, run under Australian control and offered to the public through healthdirect.

    The Commonwealth should fund an Australian health model: a free open model, trained on Australian guidelines and data, tested here, run here, updated under Australian control, and offered to the public through healthdirect or similar.

  4. Argues that a chatbot whose fine print says it is not intended for diagnosis or treatment sits outside the TGA while millions use it for exactly that.

    A chatbot whose fine print says it is not intended for diagnosis or treatment sits outside the TGA while millions use it for exactly that.

  5. Says the Australian Consumer Law is the vehicle for making suppliers of clinical AI responsible for their products, including disclosure, notice of model changes and no contracting out of liability for defects.

    The Australian Consumer Law is Commonwealth law and the vehicle. Suppliers of AI used in clinical care should be responsible for their products: disclose what the model was trained on, notify users before the model changes and give them time to check it, and be unable to contract out of liability for defects.

  6. Argues that the Copyright Act needs an express rule keeping published scientific and medical research available for training public-health models in Australia, since treating learning from published work as theft would undercut an Australian health model.

    If learning from published work is theft, the Australian health model in A4 is built from stolen goods, and the price is paid by the patient who could never afford the consultation. The Copyright Act needs an express rule that published scientific and medical research remains available for training models used for public health purposes in Australia.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Condition large data-centre approvals on Australian health/government/public-model data staying in Australia, no training on that data without Australian approval, reserved computers for Australian public use and company training of Australian workers.

    Approval of a large data centre should carry four conditions: Australian health, government and public-model data stays in Australia; that data is not used to train any model without Australian approval; a set of computers inside the building is reserved for Australian public use; and the company trains Australian workers.

  2. Require new data centres to bring at least 80 per cent of annual demand as domestically generated renewable electricity, following Ireland’s approach before the grid runs out.

    In December 2025 Ireland changed course: new data centres must bring at least 80 per cent of their annual demand as renewable electricity generated in Ireland. Australia's standards should ask the same thing before the grid runs out, not after.

  3. Require Australian health data to be held by Australian-owned and controlled providers on their own servers in Australia, encrypted with keys held here; location alone should not count as compliance.

    Australian health data should be held by Australian-owned and controlled providers, on their own servers, in Australia, encrypted with keys held here. Location alone should not count as compliance because a foreign owner answers to its own country's laws as well as ours.

  4. Fund an Australian health model: a free open model trained on Australian guidelines and data, tested and run in Australia, updated under Australian control and offered to the public through healthdirect or similar.

    The Commonwealth should fund an Australian health model: a free open model, trained on Australian guidelines and data, tested here, run here, updated under Australian control, and offered to the public through healthdirect or similar.

  5. Test the health model at NCI and Pawsey, then run it at scale on reserved commercial data-centre computers on Australian soil.

    Where it runs: test on the supercomputers Australia already owns at NCI in Canberra and Pawsey in Perth, then run at scale on the reserved computers inside commercial data centres on Australian soil.

  6. Use healthdirect for the Australian health model, answering only from Australian guidelines and PBS information, directing chest pain to triple zero and logging and auditing every question.

    The Australian health model is its next job: answers only from Australian guidelines and PBS information, chest pain sent to triple zero, every question logged and audited the way hospitals already are.

  7. Write Indigenous data sovereignty principles into the AI standards, with funding for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander organisations to hold and govern their communities' data on their own servers.

    Indigenous data sovereignty principles, agreed by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander leaders in 2018 and recognised by the Commonwealth in 2024, should be written into the AI standards, with funding for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander organisations to hold and govern their communities' data on their own servers.

  8. Fund Indigenous community control: local organisations own data, train local collectors/analysts and keep data on community-controlled Australian servers; communities choosing models train them locally without data leaving.

    The model that works is simple: a local organisation owns the data, local people are trained to collect and analyse it, and the data never leaves. Communities keep their data on servers they control, in Australia, and if they want a model, they take the same free model and train it on their own data on their own servers. Nothing leaves. The Commonwealth framework should become part of the AI standards, with funding so communities can do this.

  9. Regulate AI tools by their actual use at scale, not marketing claims, so tools used for diagnosis or treatment come under the TGA whatever their fine print says.

    AI tools should be regulated by their actual use at scale, not their marketing claims, so that tools used for diagnosis or treatment come under the TGA whatever their fine print says.

  10. Regulate AI companies where they are reachable, through their Australian offices, revenue and government contracts: require transparency about training data, testing in Australia before model updates reach Australians, and opt-in training on Australians' personal data.

    Second, regulate where the companies are reachable: they have Australian offices, revenue and government contracts. Require transparency about training data, no model update reaching Australians before it is tested here, and training on Australians' personal data to be opt-in.

  11. Make suppliers of clinical AI responsible under the Australian Consumer Law: disclose training data, notify users before model changes and allow time to check, and bar contracting out of liability for defects.

    The Australian Consumer Law is Commonwealth law and the vehicle. Suppliers of AI used in clinical care should be responsible for their products: disclose what the model was trained on, notify users before the model changes and give them time to check it, and be unable to contract out of liability for defects.

  12. Give AISI or a government/industry-independent body powers over privately supplied models to test clinical/public-facing AI before and after each change, publish results and accept public/clinician complaints.

    Give the Institute, or a body independent of both government and industry, the job of testing AI tools used in clinical and public-facing settings before and after each model change, publishing the results, and taking complaints from the public and clinicians, with the power to reach privately supplied models.

  13. Fund AI-assisted simulation, feedback and video review across health training, with the same tools extended to training and ongoing support for rural and remote doctors.

    The Commonwealth should fund AI-assisted simulation, feedback and video review across health training, so scarce supervisors can train more people to the same standard, with the same tools extended to training and ongoing support for rural and remote doctors.

  14. Ask the committee to explain what makes machine learning different before treating it differently in law.

    I ask the committee to say what makes the machine different before the law treats it differently.

  15. Distinguish learning from copying in copyright law.

    The distinction the law needs is between copying and learning.

  16. Pursue AI reproduction of songs or books under existing copyright law; legislate at the output end against selling imitations of identifiable artists’ voices or likenesses.

    A machine that reproduces a song or a book has broken existing copyright law and should be pursued under it. A machine that imitates an identifiable artist's voice or likeness and sells it has caused the harm the Prime Minister described, and Australia can legislate against that cleanly at the output end.

  17. Expressly keep published scientific and medical research available for training models used for public health purposes in Australia.

    The Copyright Act needs an express rule that published scientific and medical research remains available for training models used for public health purposes in Australia.

  18. If Parliament requires training payments, use a collective licence fee paid to a collecting society for distribution to authors.

    If Parliament decides payment for training is required regardless, collective licensing is the only workable mechanism: one licence fee paid to a collecting society that distributes it to authors

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide