Submission 167
Screenrights
Submitter group: Creative sector.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
Screenrights, a screen-sector copyright management organisation, argues for extended collective licensing for audiovisual works used in AI training, with rightsholder opt-out, rather than a copyright exception, statutory licence or code-based opt-outs. It briefly notes the Copyright Act government-use licence as a possible route to sovereign AI capability.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues extended collective licensing is needed because smaller screen rightsholders lack market power and face high transaction costs in negotiating directly with AI companies.
Screenrights submits that ECL is needed because smaller copyright holders in screen content do not have the market power to negotiate directly with AI companies. Moreover, the transaction costs of small individual licences are likely to be prohibitive for both rightsholders and AI developers.
Describes ECL as a legislative mechanism widening a collective licence once a threshold of rightsholders agrees to participate.
ECL is a legislative mechanism that assists voluntary collective licensing by widening the reach of a collective licence once a threshold of rightsholders have agreed to participate.
Argues an ECL opt-out managed through a collecting society is viable, in contrast to code-based opt-outs such as robots.txt proposed by some in the tech sector.
Screenrights submits that an ECL opt out is viable because it is managed by an interaction between a collecting society and a copyright owner. This contrasts with the proposal of some in the tech sector who propose opt outs based on code (such as robots.txt) on web pages.
States it opposes copyright exceptions, including text and data mining exceptions, and narrowing copyright protections for AI developers in ways that leave rightsholders unremunerated.
Screenrights is strongly opposed to any form of copyright exception such as a text and data mining exception (TDM), or any narrowing of copyright protections in favour of AI developers that would leave rightsholders unremunerated.
Argues the Copyright Act government-use provision covers national security and could be used to develop sovereign AI capability.
Section 183 of the Act permits any use that is for the services of the Commonwealth (or a State or Territory). Screenrights submits that this provision clearly covers matters of national security and so could be used to develop sovereign AI capability as a response to the national security risks of AI.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Introduce a general ECL provision in the Copyright Act and authorise Australian CMOs’ AI licences alongside direct and voluntary collective licensing, preserving opt-out, agreement before use and flexible terms.
Our research confirms that introducing an ECL framework into Australia by enacting a “general” ECL provision in the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) and authorising Australian CMOs to offer ECL agreements for AI specific licences in Australia, will benefit all rightsholders including those that wish to manage their rights directly. ECL has the benefit of being one copyright licensing tool that can operate alongside direct licensing and voluntary collective licensing. The ECL structure addresses the main concerns arising in relation to a statutory licence, in that it allows copyright holders to opt-out, it requires agreement before AI developers can start using material and it allows flexibility of terms.
Do not introduce a copyright exception such as a text and data mining exception, or narrow copyright protections in favour of AI developers in a way that leaves rightsholders unremunerated.
Screenrights is strongly opposed to any form of copyright exception such as a text and data mining exception (TDM), or any narrowing of copyright protections in favour of AI developers that would leave rightsholders unremunerated.
Prefer ECL to compulsory statutory licensing and retaining ad hoc direct licensing alone for AI training and inputs.
We support the introduction of ECL in preference to retaining the status quo of only ad hoc direct licensing and in preference to the introduction of a compulsory statutory licence when considered for licensing copyrighted materials for AI training and inputs.