Submission 170
Quantum DC SA Tungkillo
Submitter group: Companies.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
A data-centre proponent supports the intent of proposed siting standards but asks for measured, component-specific separation and land-capability definitions, state assessment recognition, transitional provisions and co-location incentives. Its own Tungkillo project will be in assessment when legislation is introduced. The attached desktop study reports many nearby rural dwellings and few other sensitive receivers, without field verification.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues that key terms in the announced siting criteria are not yet defined and should be defined by measurement and land capability.
None of “near”, “prime agricultural land”, “appropriate” or “large” has yet been defined. QDC supports the intent of the criteria. Its submission is that they will work if they are defined by measurement and by land capability, using tools the states already use
Argues that a poorly drafted rule could exclude suitable regional sites without protecting communities.
Regional sites that adjoin existing transmission infrastructure, sit on grazing land outside any protective overlay and have few sensitive receptors are exactly where facilities of this scale should be located. A poorly drafted rule could exclude them while doing nothing for the communities the rule is intended to protect.
Describes the attached desktop assessment as finding many nearby rural dwellings, including close to the site, but very few other sensitive receivers, all at least 4 km away.
There are a large number of rural dwellings in the vicinity, including close to the project site. * There are very few other sensitive receivers in the locality, with all located at least 4km away from the project site.
Recommends transitional provisions for projects already in a state assessment pathway.
Include transitional provisions for projects lodged or accepted into a state assessment pathway before commencement, and let a completed state assessment satisfy the standards (Recommendation 3).
Recommends that co-location with transmission and firmed generation count as a positive siting attribute.
Recognise co-location with existing transmission and with new firmed generation and storage as a positive siting attribute, with access to a streamlined connection pathway (Recommendation 4).
States that the assessment used desktop searches without field verification of its results.
The assessment was based on desktop search only. No field verification has been undertaken to confirm results.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Define prime agricultural land by land capability and agricultural land use potential, using the classification systems and spatial datasets the states already maintain.
That “prime agricultural land” be defined by reference to land capability and agricultural land use potential, using the classification systems and spatial datasets the states already maintain
Set the prime agricultural land threshold at high or very high cropping or horticulture potential, with grazing land captured only where very high.
That “prime agricultural land” be defined by reference to land capability and agricultural land use potential, using the classification systems and spatial datasets the states already maintain (in South Australia, the land use potential classes for cropping and pasture), with the threshold set at land of high or very high potential for cropping or horticulture, and grazing land captured only where it is of very high potential.
Do not use zoning, regional planning overlays or the bare fact of agricultural use as proxies for prime agricultural land.
That “prime agricultural land” be defined by reference to land capability and agricultural land use potential, using the classification systems and spatial datasets the states already maintain (in South Australia, the land use potential classes for cropping and pasture), with the threshold set at land of high or very high potential for cropping or horticulture, and grazing land captured only where it is of very high potential. Zoning, regional planning overlays and the bare fact of agricultural use should not be used as proxies.
Apply any displacement test to the built footprint of the facility rather than the cadastral area of the holding.
Any displacement test should be applied to the built footprint of the facility rather than the cadastral area of the holding, recognising that agricultural use can continue on the balance of a site.
Express proximity as component-specific separation distances measured from the built component to the nearest sensitive receptor, calibrated to the noise and visual amenity criteria state agencies already apply.
That the proximity criterion be expressed as defined separation distances that are component-specific (distinguishing data halls, on-site generation, substations and storage), measured from the nearest edge of the built component to the nearest sensitive receptor, and calibrated to the environmental noise and visual amenity criteria that state environment protection and planning agencies already apply.
Define 'sensitive receptor' consistently with existing state planning regimes: dwellings, schools and childcare, places of worship, aged care and health facilities, and short-stay accommodation.
“Sensitive receptor” should be defined consistently with existing state planning regimes: dwellings, schools and childcare, places of worship, aged care and health facilities, and short-stay accommodation.
Where a proponent shows through the state assessment that the applicable amenity criteria are met at a closer distance, accept that as satisfying the Commonwealth standard.
Where a proponent demonstrates through the state assessment that the applicable amenity criteria are met at a closer distance, that demonstration should satisfy the Commonwealth standard.
Assess projects lodged or accepted into state assessment before commencement under the lodgement framework, giving Commonwealth standards effect through assessment conditions rather than further approval.
That the legislation provide that a project which, before commencement, has lodged a development application or has been accepted into a state assessment pathway is assessed under the framework in force at lodgement, with the Commonwealth standards given effect through the conditions of that assessment rather than as a further approval.
Give the framework effect through state and territory assessment processes, treating a completed state assessment that addresses the mandatory standards as satisfying them, rather than a parallel Commonwealth approval.
More generally, that the framework be given effect through state and territory assessment processes, with a completed state assessment that addresses the mandatory standards treated as satisfying them, rather than through a parallel Commonwealth approval.
Recognise co-location with high-voltage transmission and new firmed generation and storage as a positive siting attribute satisfying the criterion that facilities be appropriate for their size, function and infrastructure requirements.
That the framework recognise co-location with existing high-voltage transmission infrastructure, and with new firmed generation and storage, as a positive siting attribute that satisfies the “appropriate for their size, function and infrastructure requirements” criterion
Give projects co-located with existing high-voltage transmission and new firmed generation and storage access to the streamlined connection pathway recommended in the AEMC’s August 2026 ministerial advice.
That the framework recognise co-location with existing high-voltage transmission infrastructure, and with new firmed generation and storage, as a positive siting attribute that satisfies the “appropriate for their size, function and infrastructure requirements” criterion, and that such projects have access to the streamlined connection pathway recommended in the Australian Energy Market Commission’s August 2026 advice to Energy and Climate Change Ministers.
Publish the proposed definitions and thresholds, including what constitutes a large data centre by connection capacity, for consultation before the legislation is introduced.
That the proposed definitions and thresholds, including what constitutes a large data centre expressed by connection capacity, be published for consultation before the legislation is introduced