Submission 178
Professor Rodrigo Praino
Submitter group: Individuals.
Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
Argues, in a private capacity, that sovereign AI and critical minerals strategies are one problem: AI raises mineral demand and speeds discovery. Recommends integration, exploration-AI funding, subsurface data governance, verification and low-impact, consent-based operations. States that the author’s Centre is discussing possible research collaboration with Fleet Space Technologies and that the author holds no financial interest in any named company.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues that sovereign AI and sovereign critical-minerals strategies are one problem, since AI both drives mineral demand and aids discovery.
Australia is discussing sovereign AI capability and sovereign critical-minerals capability as two separate problems. They are one problem. AI is the largest new source of demand for critical minerals this decade and, at the same time, the most powerful new tool for discovering and producing them responsibly.
Argues that, under the framework, Australia is capable but not sovereign.
In the language of the framework, Australia sits in the “skilled” quadrant: capable but not sovereign.
Argues that narrow, domain-specific exploration AI from Australian-controlled providers should count as sovereign AI capability and be funded.
Australia should count exploration AI, that is, narrow, domain-specific models developed by Australian-controlled providers, as sovereign AI capability under paragraphs (e) and (f), fund it accordingly, and extend the public precompetitive data that feeds it, building on Geoscience Australia’s Resourcing Australia’s Prosperity program.
Argues that no Australian rule covers who may hold privately accumulated subsurface models, foreign acquisition review or treatment under duress.
No Australian rule reaches the interpreted three-dimensional models and, above all, the cross-project learning that accumulates with the technology provider rather than the tenement holder. No rule says who may hold that layer, whether its acquisition by a foreign buyer triggers review, or what happens to it under duress.
States that 'low-impact' claims for AI exploration are currently self-reported and unverified, and argues government should make them measurable and reward them.
But “low-impact” claims are today self-reported and not independently verified. Government should make them measurable and reward them through existing and new instruments that actually reach exploration.
Argues that the US-Australia critical minerals framework should add a discovery-and-data pillar.
Add a discovery-and-data pillar to the US—Australia critical minerals framework
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Integrate the strategies: critical minerals as a pillar of sovereign AI capability, and AI-enabled discovery and processing as a pillar of the Critical Minerals Strategy, with a single accountable owner in government.
Integrate the two strategies: recognise critical minerals as a pillar of Australian sovereign AI capability, and AI-enabled discovery and processing as a pillar of the Critical Minerals Strategy, with a single accountable owner in government.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Classify critical-minerals investments as capacity-building or autonomy-building, as the Centre proposes for Commonwealth AI investments.
In addition, consistent with the Centre’s proposal that Commonwealth AI investments be classified as capacity-building or autonomy-building, apply the same classification to critical-minerals investments.
Count narrow, domain-specific exploration AI developed by Australian-controlled providers as sovereign AI capability and fund it accordingly.
Australia should count exploration AI, that is, narrow, domain-specific models developed by Australian-controlled providers, as sovereign AI capability under paragraphs (e) and (f), fund it accordingly
Treat discovery velocity as a national strategic metric.
Treat discovery velocity as a national strategic metric.
Procure narrow, domain-specific exploration AI from Australian-controlled providers where they exist, and expand precompetitive data programs.
Procure narrow, domain- specific exploration AI from Australian-controlled providers where they exist: expand precompetitive data programs;
Make verified low-impact exploration methods a criterion in public procurement and Reserve-related decisions.
make verified low-impact exploration methods a criterion in public procurement and Reserve-related decisions.
Register the existence, coverage and custodianship, not the data itself, of large private datasets and derived models about Australian endowments, limited to the layer state lodgement rules do not already capture.
Establish a national framework for strategic subsurface data, scoped to data and models about Australian endowments and to the layer that state lodgement rules do not already capture: registration of the existence, coverage and custodianship of large privately held datasets and derived models, not deposit of the data itself
For strategic subsurface data about Australian endowments not already captured by state lodgement rules, provide access for defined emergencies with confidentiality safeguards and compensation.
Establish a national framework for strategic subsurface data, scoped to data and models about Australian endowments and to the layer that state lodgement rules do not already capture: registration of the existence, coverage and custodianship of large privately held datasets and derived models, not deposit of the data itself: access provisions for defined emergencies, with confidentiality safeguards and compensation: Indigenous data governance under the CARE principles, with Indigenous-led design: and protocols for allied sharing.
For strategic subsurface data about Australian endowments not already captured by state lodgement rules, apply CARE principles with Indigenous-led design and protocols for allied sharing.
Establish a national framework for strategic subsurface data, scoped to data and models about Australian endowments and to the layer that state lodgement rules do not already capture: registration of the existence, coverage and custodianship of large privately held datasets and derived models, not deposit of the data itself: access provisions for defined emergencies, with confidentiality safeguards and compensation: Indigenous data governance under the CARE principles, with Indigenous-led design: and protocols for allied sharing.
Set an independent verification standard for AI-derived geological intelligence used in public decisions, including offtakes, public finance and defence supply.
Set an independent verification standard for AI-derived geological intelligence used in public decisions, including offtakes, public finance, and defence supply.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Reward measurable low-impact, consent-based operations, whatever technology delivers them, through permitting pathways, state exploration-licence conditions, Critical Minerals Facility lending criteria and Strategic Reserve offtake criteria.
Write AI-enabled efficiency and social licence into the capacity instruments: permitting pathways, state exploration-licence conditions, the lending criteria of the Critical Minerals Facility and Strategic Reserve offtake criteria should reward measurable low-impact, consent-based operations, whatever technology delivers them.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Add a discovery-and-data pillar to the US-Australia critical minerals framework.
Add a discovery-and-data pillar to the US—Australia critical minerals framework
Commission an annual independent assessment of the material politics of AI, covering concentration, export controls, exposure and discovery.
commission an annual independent assessment of the material politics of AI, looking at concentration, export controls, exposure and discovery, so that Parliament’s AI and minerals policies rest on the same evidence.
Read the original
In some quotes a program corrected obvious text-recognition errors for display.