Submission 214
Australian Libraries and Archives Copyright Coalition
Submitter group: Industry bodies.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
Describes libraries’ and archives’ AI and copyright perspective. It recommends attribution and provenance standards, supports licensing alongside other mechanisms while protecting existing exceptions such as section 200AB, and asks for ICIP protocols and sector consultation on AI governance. It also describes infrastructure costs from AI scrapers.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Says libraries and archives are one of the few sectors currently able to deploy AI at scale under existing copyright exceptions in a lawful, ethical and transparent manner.
Our sector is simultaneously a major steward, supplier, creator, and user of copyright material, and one of the few sectors currently able to deploy AI at scale under existing copyright exceptions in a lawful, ethical, transparent, and socially beneficial manner.
States that ALACC supports licensing and other mechanisms for text and data mining, but does not believe licensing is the only appropriate solution.
The ALACC supports licensing and other legitimate mechanisms enabling text and data mining (TDM) and AI use of copyright material, however, it does not believe that licensing is the only appropriate solution.
Argues that a broad licensing scheme giving rightsholding bodies exclusive control over TDM/AI use could unintentionally cost libraries and archives their existing exceptions, including section 200AB.
Any broad licensing scheme that would give rights- holding bodies exclusive control over TDM/AI use could unintentionally come at the cost of libraries' and archives' existing exceptions, particularly section 200AB of the Copyright Act for preserving, maintaining, and enhancing access to collections.
States that ALACC supports requiring engagement with cultural protocols and consultation with Indigenous communities before ICIP is used or represented in AI content.
The ALACC supports a position requiring engagement with cultural protocols and consultation with Indigenous communities prior to the use or representation of ICIP within AI content.
Says libraries and archives bear tangible infrastructure costs and risks from AI bots and scrapers, including bandwidth consumption and server strain.
The ALACC will continue to highlight the tangible infrastructure costs and risks that libraries and archives bear from AI bots and scrapers, bandwidth consumption, server strain, and in some cases the need to bring staff on-site to restart systems
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Adopt standards-based attribution and provenance requirements for AI systems and outputs, protecting creators through attribution and, where appropriate, remuneration, and protecting library and archive users.
The ALACC supports attribution and provenance requirements for AI systems and their outputs through a standards- based mechanism that protects both creators (through attribution and, where appropriate, remuneration) and patrons/users of library and archival collections.
Support licensing and other legitimate TDM/AI mechanisms without making licensing the only solution or sacrificing libraries’ and archives’ existing exceptions, particularly section 200AB.
The ALACC supports licensing and other legitimate mechanisms enabling text and data mining (TDM) and AI use of copyright material, however, it does not believe that licensing is the only appropriate solution. Any broad licensing scheme that would give rights- holding bodies exclusive control over TDM/AI use could unintentionally come at the cost of libraries' and archives' existing exceptions, particularly section 200AB of the Copyright Act for preserving, maintaining, and enhancing access to collections.
Require engagement with cultural protocols and consultation with Indigenous communities before ICIP is used or represented in AI content.
The ALACC supports a position requiring engagement with cultural protocols and consultation with Indigenous communities prior to the use or representation of ICIP within AI content.
Include ALACC and other library and archive representatives in consultation on the Office of AI's standards for AI governance.
the ALACC and other library and archive sector representatives should be included in consultation around the Office of AI's development of standards for shaping AI governance.