Submission 215
Australian Library and Information Association
Submitter group: Industry bodies.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
Describes libraries' existing lawful use of AI to transcribe, discover and deliver collections, and argues libraries should be consulted in AI policy. Supports balanced AI regulation, including disclosure, privacy, creator licensing and ICIP protection, while retaining copyright exceptions, and recommends funding libraries for digital and media literacy.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues that libraries already deliver responsible AI use at national scale under existing law and must be included in national AI discussions.
Australia does not need to imagine what responsible AI use looks like: libraries are already doing it, at national scale, under existing law. As such, they must be included as a vital voice of experience and balance in the national AI conversation.
ALIA says libraries are experiencing technical and staffing pressures from automated scraping, bot access, non-disclosure of AI-generated material and demand for media literacy education.
Libraries are experiencing massive increases in automated scraping, intensive bot access to digital collections, challenges relating to non-disclosure of AI generated material, and rising demand for public digital and media literacy education, straining available resourcing.
ALIA says mechanisms for creator control and remuneration should ensure that benefits from LLM licensing deals flow to the original creators.
These mechanisms should include provisions to ensure that when licensing deals are made in relation to LLMs - whether with news media companies, social media platforms or others - clear and identifiable benefits flow through to the original creators.
ALIA argues Australia's AI regulatory framework must retain flexibility for exceptions and other lawful pathways alongside licensing, so good-faith developers, researchers, libraries and other public-benefit actors can use AI lawfully.
At the same time, Australia’s AI regulatory framework must retain flexibility for exceptions and other lawful pathways alongside licensing. Australia must ensure there are legitimate, workable pathways that allow good-faith developers, researchers, libraries, archives, educational institutions and other public-benefit actors to use AI tools lawfully and ethically.
Describes an ALIA–PressReader report finding that 99 per cent of public librarians value media literacy but only 10 per cent feel equipped, with staff time, funding and resources the main barriers.
A recent joint report by ALIA and PressReader found that while 99 per cent of Australian public librarians view media literacy as important for their communities, only 10 per cent feel well equipped to support it, with staff time, funding and resourcing the primary barriers.
Describes the National Library’s Trove API governance framework as a working example, offering extended access for uses including AI training and analysis.
The National Library of Australia's Trove API governance framework offers a working example. The framework provides extended access to Trove for uses such as AI training and analysis through an Application Programming Interface (API) key.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Consult libraries directly, alongside creators, technology developers and other stakeholders, as AI policy, standards and regulatory settings are developed.
Libraries should be consulted directly, alongside creators, technology developers and other stakeholders, as Australia's AI policy, standards and regulatory settings are developed.
Formally recognise libraries as a proven working model of ethical, legal and public-interest AI use.
The Committee should formally recognise libraries as a proven, working model of ethical, legal and public-interest AI use and ensure they are consulted as key stakeholders in Australia’s AI policy decisions
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Design AI regulation to constrain harmful, irresponsible and unreasonable use while continuing to enable ethical, lawful, public-interest use of the kind libraries demonstrate.
We urge the government to ensure that regulation is designed to constrain harmful, irresponsible and unreasonable use of AI while continuing to enable the kind of ethical, lawful, public-interest use that libraries already demonstrate is possible.
Promote mechanisms that enable or require disclosure of AI use in creative production.
Enable or require disclosure of AI use in creative production. Such transparency measures could assist in addressing the risk that established and emerging creators may be displaced by generative AI products, while simultaneously providing libraries with tools to manage the surge in AI publications and combat the misinformation and disinformation that our sector battles every day.
Promote mechanisms that protect individuals' privacy and let them manage the retention and use of their data online.
Protect the privacy of individuals and allow them to manage the retention and use of their data in online environments.
Promote mechanisms that empower creators and websites to manage automated access to and use of the data they make available online.
Empower creators and websites to managed automated access to and use of the data they make available online, both as a practical matter and to ensure individual choices are respected.
Complete the IP Australia-led process to give legal recognition to ICIP rights as a matter of priority.
We therefore urge the government to complete the current process being led by IP Australia to provide legal recognition of ICIP rights as a matter of priority.
Encourage fair, workable licensing for authors’ and other creators’ work used with AI.
ALIA supports authors' and other creators' calls for regulation that encourages fair, workable licensing arrangements for the use of their work in conjunction with AI.
Establish mechanisms enabling legitimate AI use while ensuring appropriate control and remuneration for creators.
We support the government’s ongoing effort to establish mechanisms that both enable legitimate pathways for AI use and ensure appropriate control and remuneration for creators.
Ensure mechanisms for LLM licensing deals provide that clear and identifiable benefits flow through to the original creators.
These mechanisms should include provisions to ensure that when licensing deals are made in relation to LLMs - whether with news media companies, social media platforms or others - clear and identifiable benefits flow through to the original creators.
Consider whether the rate of change warrants industry transition arrangements or targeted support for highly impacted professions such as writers.
For highly impacted professions such as writers, the government may also wish to consider whether the likely rate of change warrants industry transition arrangements or targeted support.
Consider further mechanisms supporting Australian authors, including direct funding to promote Australian authors and stories through bookshops and libraries.
We encourage the government to consider further mechanisms that could support Australian authors, including direct funding to promote Australian authors and stories through Australia’s bookshops and libraries.
Retain flexibility for exceptions and other lawful pathways alongside licensing, so good-faith developers, researchers, libraries, archives, educational institutions and other public-benefit actors can use AI tools lawfully.
Australia’s AI regulatory framework must retain flexibility for exceptions and other lawful pathways alongside licensing. Australia must ensure there are legitimate, workable pathways that allow good-faith developers, researchers, libraries, archives, educational institutions and other public-benefit actors to use AI tools lawfully and ethically.
Protect libraries' own ability to use AI with their collection material and to work with researchers on that material.
In particular, any regulatory framework must protect libraries’ own ability to make use of AI with their collection material and to work with researchers on that material
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Protect libraries’ AI use under the existing library/archive exceptions, especially s200AB flexible dealing for public-interest uses that do not harm creators; avoid legislation restricting that provision.
This ability currently relies heavily on the existing library and archive exceptions in the Copyright Act 1968, most notably the flexible dealing exception (s200AB) which enables libraries and other archives to make use of AI with their collection materials as long as it is in the public interest and does not harm creators. We would strongly oppose any legislative model that intentionally or unintentionally restricts the library sectors’ use of this provision, as it would risk undoing all the good actions currently being undertaken by libraries in the AI space.
Recognise libraries as a key government partner in digital and media literacy education.
As a trusted, community-based frontline for digital and media literacy education, libraries have an important role to play in equipping Australians to take full advantage of the AI future. They should be recognised as a key partner by government in this endeavour and funded accordingly.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Examine library governance models, such as the NLA's Trove API access framework, as a template for transparent and accountable public sector AI use.
That the Committee examine library governance models, such as the National Library of Australia's Trove API access framework, as a template for transparent and accountable public sector AI use.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Close the public and school library resourcing gap through partnerships and targeted funding.
Closing this gap in public and school library resourcing through partnerships and targeted funding would give the Committee's workforce and skills and community safety objectives a delivery channel that already has the community's trust, rather than requiring one to be built from nothing.
Read the original
In some quotes a program corrected obvious text-recognition errors for display.