AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 223

Chicken & Chips Casting

Submitter group: Creative sector.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

Describes harms of generative AI to performers and casting directors in the Australian screen and advertising sectors, including use of name, image, voice and likeness to train models, synthetic performers and loss of entry-level work. Argues existing law has gaps and recommends bans, mandatory labelling, opt-in consent and education.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Argues that there are no rules performers or casting directors can point to protect their name, image, likeness, voice and performance from use in AI models without control or compensation.

    there are no rules or regulations in which we can confidently point to protect ourselves or our performing artists from having the Name, Image, Likeness, Voice and Performance stolen and used in AI models with no control or compensation for their work.

  2. Says there is a rapid increase in actors and agents being pressured to sign away image rights for clones and digital replicas, and in synthetic performers replacing actors.

    I’ve seen a rapid increase in the number of actors and agents being bullied to sign away their image rights to generate clones and digital replicas, deepfakes used on clickbait articles, and synthetic performers replacing actors altogether where there is no proven Chain of Consent on the generated images.

  3. Argues that existing copyright law leaves a serious gap for performers' name, image, voice, likeness and performance compared with other creators.

    While existing copyright law protects other Australian artists (IP holders such as visual artists, musicians, Producers, or photographers), at present the ability of AI to use a Name, Image, Voice, Likeness and Performance of actors, models, VO artists, or performers in the Screen & Advertising sectors is a serious gap in the legislation.

  4. Argues that digital replicas and synthetic performers risk removing entry-level pathways in performing arts.

    Erasure of entry level jobs in performing arts where actors were able to cut their teeth, particularly in advertising. Background work, smaller commercial roles and voice overs traditionally provided actors with a pathway into the industry. Digital replicas and synthetic fakes risk removing that pathway without any transitional support.

  5. States that brands are creating synthetic performers to replace actors in advertising.

    We are seeing an increase in brands including Sheridan, Xero, Naked Condoms, Amaysim, BankWest, Allianz and many others creating synthetic performers to blatantly replace actors in their advertising.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Strengthen consumer law on misleading and deceptive advertising by banning synthetic fake performers in all advertising across all mediums.

    Strengthen Consumer Law around misleading and deceptive advertising by banning the use of synthetic fake performers in all advertising (across all mediums).

  2. Make labelling of AI use in production mandatory, with a disclaimer preceding content produced using any AI in any format.

    Transparency: Make labelling AI production mandatory - where any AI is used in the production of the content (across any format), a mandatory disclaimer precedes the content so that the consumer is aware of AI use.

  3. Extend ad compliance to cover synthetic fake performers.

    Strengthen Ad Compliance to extend to synthetic fake performers.

  4. Make AI use opt-in, not opt-out, across all parts of the advertising and screen sectors to protect creative artists' name, image, voice, likeness and performance.

    Control: Making AI use opt in, not opt out across ALL parts of the advertising and screen sectors to protect all creative artists’ Name, Image, Voice, Likeness and Performance.

  5. Ban AI cloning and digital replicas in all screen productions, including voices.

    Ban AI cloning and digital replicas in all screen productions, including voices.

  6. Provide government-funded education resources accessible to the screen and advertising sectors on AI and performers' name, image, voice, performance and likeness.

    Government funded education resources that are accessible to the Screen & Advertising sectors so that performing artists can be educated and feel empowered when it comes to AI and their Name, Image, Voice, Performance and Likeness.

  7. Use the human rights framework to determine whether AI innovation adheres to the ethical principles of fairness and equality.

    Using the Human Rights framework to determine whether AI innovation is adhering to the ethical principles of fairness and equality.

  8. Prohibit use of children in AI model training, digital replicas or cloning regardless of parental or guardian permission.

    Children cannot consent to AI use and therefore must not be used in any AI model training, digital replicas or cloning, regardless of a parent or guardian’s permission.

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide