Submission 228
Copyright Agency
Submitter group: Creative sector.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
A copyright collecting society that negotiates and distributes licence fees argues that AI developers should license Australian creators' content under the existing copyright framework. It asks the Government to resist replacing copyright, and fund content-supply infrastructure. It asks the Committee to condemn book destruction for training and seeks separate consideration of overseas-trained models using unlicensed Australian content.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Says Australia's clear and reiterated copyright position has removed the uncertainty AI developers said they faced, and that licensing is a clear requirement for AI development and deployment in Australia.
Australia’s clear and reiterated position on copyright has removed any ‘uncertainty’ that AI developers claimed that they faced. Licensing arrangements for the use of other people’s content is a clear and unequivocal requirement for AI development and deployment in Australia.
Says AI developers are generally not taking steps to put licensing arrangements in place in Australia.
They are generally not taking steps to put licensing arrangements in place for AI development in Australia, under Australia’s copyright framework.
Argues the Government should resist suggestions that copyright be replaced with another system.
The Government should resist suggestions, including those coming from the global technology sector, that copyright should be replaced with another system.
Says smaller content creators need additional infrastructure to supply content with metadata and participate in emerging AI licensing markets.
AI to deliver revenue to local content organisations requires additional infrastructure to enable efficient content supply (with associated metadata) by smaller content creators, so that they have opportunities to participate in the emerging markets.
Says scanning of books by or for AI developers in Australia is clearly prohibited by Australian law.
Scanning of books by or on behalf of AI developers in Australia is clearly prohibited by Australian law.
Says it remains very difficult for Australians whose works were used for overseas AI development to obtain payment.
It remains very difficult for Australians whose works have been used for AI development overseas to get payment, despite the models being available in Australia.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Not provide AI developers with any assistance with their US court cases.
The Australian Government should not be providing AI developers with any assistance with the US cases, particularly given that the developers have used Australian content creators’ works without permission or payment.
Reiterate to AI developers, particularly multinationals, that the social licence to develop and deploy AI in Australia includes licensing arrangements for the use of other people's content.
The Government needs to reiterate to AI developers, particularly multinational companies, that the social licence to develop and deploy AI in Australia includes licensing arrangements for the use of other people’s content.
Resist suggestions that copyright should be replaced with another system.
The Government should resist suggestions, including those coming from the global technology sector, that copyright should be replaced with another system.
Use non-legislative measures to facilitate licensing, such as funding requirements for government-supported AI development, procurement requirements, the Government's exemplar role and infrastructure support.
the Australian Government should also look to non-legislative measures to facilitate licensing. Examples could be funding requirements for Government-supported AI development, procurement requirements, the Government’s commitment to be an exemplar for AI adoption, and infrastructure support.
Provide funding to assist development of infrastructure enabling smaller content creators to supply content with metadata to AI developers.
requires additional infrastructure to enable efficient content supply (with associated metadata) by smaller content creators, so that they have opportunities to participate in the emerging markets. The Government should provide funding to assist the development of that infrastructure.
Condemn the scanning and destruction of books to create AI training datasets, irrespective of whether it may be legal under US law.
very large numbers of books being scanned and destroyed to create new datasets for AI training. This appears to be based on a belief that that is allowed under US law. We ask the Committee to unequivocally condemn this practice, irrespective of whether or not it may be legal under US law
Rule out any suggestion that datasets of scanned books could be brought to Australia for AI development or deployment here.
The Committee should clearly rule out any suggestion that datasets of scanned books could be brought to Australia for AI development or deployment here.
Consider separately the use in Australia of AI models developed overseas using unlicensed Australian content, including pirated book datasets.
There needs to be separate consideration for the use in Australia of AI models developed overseas, that were developed using unlicensed content of Australians, including datasets of pirated books.
Give special consideration to Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property issues; have regard to codes of conduct and best practice guidelines of organisations representing creative-sector workers.
special consideration must be given to issues relating to Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property (ICIP). Also, regard should be given to the Codes of Conduct and best practice guidelines for organisations representing workers in the creative sector.