AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 232

Cr Rachel Russell

Submitter group: Individuals.

Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

A local councillor, writing in a personal capacity, questions whether Australia has a mandate or shared vision for adopting AI. Draws on personal experience and humanist and First Nations governance to argue against dependence on AI and data centres, and uses a proposed gas-fired power plant as a case study.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Asks how AI adoption can be judged against a shared national vision that has not first been given an election mandate.

    How can we assess if the adoption of Artificial Intelligence and associated infrastructure is consistent with that shared vision if we haven’t developed an election mandate for our shared vision first?

  2. Asks whether there is a plan to switch AI off if things go wrong.

    Have we got, or is there a plan as to how we can switch it off if/when things go pear-shaped?

  3. Argues that, instead of outsourcing skills to computers, people should up-skill and build real relationships, citing humanist philosophy.

    Why are we ignoring what we know is best practice for the promotion of a sustainable and resilient economy, which is the humanist philosophy: to up-skill ourselves and build real relationships, not outsource our brains, skills and resources to a computer

  4. Suggests the push to adopt AI and build data centres may be driven by fear of missing out.

    Could we be in a FOMO amygdala response demanding that we must take up AI and build data centres as fast as possible?

  5. Argues that planning-approval issues should be fact- and process-checked by qualified department staff rather than by AI.

    It may mean that work needs to be redone to bring information to a point where a project can be assessed on it’s actual merit.These issues need to be fact-and process checked by qualified individuals within the DPHI: not Artificial Intelligence.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Model and implement best-practice government systems designed to help rather than harm people.

    Also, if we are in government as we are, it is our role and responsibility to model and implement best practice systems that are intrinsically designed to help, not harm each other.

  2. Include Treasury budgetary implications and alignment with adopted strategic land use planning visions in any assessment of the viability of AI and data centres.

    the assessment of the viability of the use of AI and data centres must include consideration of Treasury budgetary implications, and the integrity of it’s alignment with the adopted strategic land use planning visions, strategies, and best practice guiding principles

  3. Obtain a cost-benefit analysis comparing pausing for upstream regenerative catchment interventions with downstream intervention or diversion costs if extractive or hazardous industry such as the power plant is approved.

    To have the relevant assurances, we need to see a cost-benefit analysis on the multi-million dollar value/benefit to NSW Treasury if we pause and choose OPTION A : funding of upstream regenerative interventions in the Drinking Water Catchment instead of proceeding on a path of development approvals that commit our NSW State Government to the costs associated with OPTION B: downstream interventions or diversions if extractive and/or hazardous industry like this power plant is approved because we have no other option with our Government insisting that we need AI.

  4. Fund preventive drinking-catchment protections, resolving neutral-or-beneficial water-quality issues before approval; restore riparian areas and incentivise regenerative farming that retains water and greenfield land.

    Option A: Positive interventions and consistent, regenerative approaches in the Drinking Water Catchment (Wingecarribee/parts of Wollondilly/Goulburn). Support funding for: - Preventative, pro-active, best-practice protections in the Drinking Catchment for the development of all projects and associated infrastructure. Issues that ensure development is fully aligned with assurances for a neutral or beneficial effect on water quality must be resolved prior to DPHI development approval. - restoration of riparian areas - regenerative farming practices appropriately incentivised that hold water in the land, and that Green field be retained for this purpose.

  5. Align all development with the Southern Highlands Innovation Park’s clean-and-green strategic masterplan, council strategic planning documents, and state and local integrated transport strategies.

    - All development aligned with the adopted State & Council partnership Strategic Masterplan for the Southern Highlands Innovation Park, that outlines a ‘clean and green’ vision for the area, and Wingecarribee Shire Council’s Strategic Planning documents, including our State and Local Government Integrated Transport Strategies.

  6. Support sustainable tourism, including agritourism, Hillview’s educational and regenerative-farming vision, and protection of World Heritage buffer zones.

    - Sustainable multi-million dollar tourism industry. Tourism is projected to be one of the biggest economic drivers for this region, with returns of $10 Billion across the Southern Highlands region based on: - Agritourism - King’s Foundation vision for ‘Hillview’ as an educational facility with the capacity to attract national and international tourists. Hillview’s education programmes also intend to focus on regenerative farming practices. (Gas plant proposals are incongruous with this proposal, affecting key vistas). - Greater Blue Mountains World Heritage Area (GBMWHA) maps that identify these areas as important buffer zones for the protection of World Heritage Values.

  7. Halt approval when a step is missed until it is addressed; do not proceed if the completed step shows conflict with the public good, and redo work needed for merits assessment.

    If and when we miss a step an approval process must halt until we go back and address the missed step. This may mean that the process cannot proceed if that step, once completed, demonstrates that a project is unaligned with the public good. It may mean that work needs to be redone to bring information to a point where a project can be assessed on it’s actual merit.

  8. Have qualified DPHI staff, rather than AI, fact-check and process-check planning issues.

    These issues need to be fact-and process checked by qualified individuals within the DPHI: not Artificial Intelligence.

  9. Assess downstream public-health costs from PFAS, PFOS and microplastics in drinking water, plus additional filtration and household reverse-osmosis installation rebates, in the overall public-benefit test.

    Option B: Then cost of downstream interventions and diversions to NSW Government Treasury need to be assessed in the overall public bene t test including: - Public health budget costs from PFAS/PFOS/microplastics in drinking water and associated cancers as the strain on available clean drinking water supply is put under increased duress as the degradation continues. - Costs of additional filtration measures, and rebates to every homeowner downstream that depend on the water in this Drinking Water catchment, for the installation of reverse osmosis filtration systems within all homes.

  10. Include World Heritage environmental and water impacts, visual appeal and tourism reputational damage in the downstream-cost comparison.

    - Environmental costs with the area upstream of the Greater Blue Mountains World Heritage Area: water is the lifeblood of the area acknowledged as an area of Outstanding Universal Value. - Impact on visual appeal of this area and reputational damage as a destination for international tourism (Including to GBMWHA).

  11. Assess downstream flash-flooding and cleanup costs, government insurance costs, and social-cohesion and trust costs, including instability from governments losing touch with community needs.

    - Increased flash-flooding and associated clean-up costs in the Sydney basin with increased water run-off from over-development of land that previously retained water - Increased insurance costs and premiums to government due to these related issues - Increased costs from breakdown in social cohesion and trust in government, including the instability that is caused when a government loses power because it is not listening to, and out of touch with, the best interests and needs of the community whose role it is to serve.

  12. Assess Land and Environment Court and IPC costs from conflict with planning instruments and community opposition, plus reputation and public-relations costs from World Heritage and King’s Foundation risks.

    - Legal costs in the Land and Environment Court, and IPC costs, as the DPHI will be working contrary to State Planning documents and instruments and local communities, who will subsequently oppose the proposal in great numbers and through lengthy court cases. - Reputation & PR costs: increased risk to the GBMWHA and the King’s Foundation could attract international condemnation and ridicule.

  13. Apply stringent controls on AI use to reduce dependence on AI and demand for data centres.

    Proactive risk management would be looking at stringent controls on the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and how it is used, to minimise the increasing dependence on AI. This would proactively drive down demand for data centres and associated heavy industry.

  14. Begin structural reform by shifting planning to First Nations/Humanist governance principles focused on what can be done with available resources for all stakeholders.

    Structural reform would be the first step: a shift to First Nations /Humanist governance principles throughout the planning system that simply outline what you ‘Can Do’, and how to focus on and work with the resources that we do have that benefit all stakeholders.

  15. Do not proceed where Council was not consulted during EIS preparation.

    A key step was missed as Council - an acknowledged stakeholder - was not consulted during the preparation of the EIS. Therefore the process must not proceed.

  16. Require the Department of Planning to check all boxes before allowing applications to be lodged or to proceed.

    It is the responsibility of the Department of Planning to check all boxes before allowing applications to be lodged or to proceed.

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide