Submission 262
Handle My Complaint
Submitter group: Civil society.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
Handle My Complaint argues Commonwealth procurement and copyright legislation create structural AI-accountability gaps, citing court transcription, a Defence data clause and orphan works. It discloses complaints and FOI interests, supports accountable government AI rather than reduced use or staffing, and proposes transparency, procurement, privacy and copyright reforms subject to non-negotiable sovereignty, human-review, family-violence and equal-access safeguards.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues that a transparency statement covering only what an agency runs in-house will miss AI that arrives through procurement.
A transparency statement covering only what an agency runs in-house will always miss the AI that arrives through procurement — which is how most of it arrives.
Argues that across the Commonwealth, AI transparency obligations attach to the agency while AI capability arrives through the supplier.
across the Commonwealth, AI transparency obligations attach to the agency, while AI capability arrives through the supplier.
States that a released consultancy agreement contains a data clause permitting recorded material to be used to develop, train, tune and improve the vendor's commercial speech recognition and language software.
The consultancy agreement released with it contains a data clause permitting the recorded material to be used to develop, train, tune and improve the vendor's commercial speech recognition and natural language software.
Says the Copyright Amendment Bill creates an orphan works scheme allowing use without permission or payment, and that AI appears nowhere in the Bill.
It creates an orphan works scheme allowing copyright material to be used without permission or payment where the owner is unknown or untraceable, after a "reasonably diligent search" — a term the Act does not define. Artificial intelligence appears nowhere in the Bill.
Argues that personal information generated by court proceedings is not adequately protected, because at each link the Privacy Act does not apply or is not enforced.
Personal information generated by court proceedings passes through three sets of hands. At each link, the Privacy Act 1988 either does not apply or applies and is not enforced.
Argues that the difference between its three examples is whether anyone decided, wrote it down and accepted responsibility.
The difference is not the technology. It is whether anyone decided, wrote it down, and accepted responsibility for it. In two of those three, nobody did.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Ask what data, including any existing court data, was used to train the AI behind the amica family law property tool.
amica does not, however, explain what data, specifically if it was existing court data, that was used to train its AI to provide its recommendations. This is a question worth asking by this committee.
Extend the AI Transparency Statement regime to cover AI used by contractors and subcontractors in delivering government services, not only AI operated in-house.
That the AI Transparency Statement regime be extended to cover AI used by contractors and subcontractors in the delivery of government services, not only AI operated in-house by the agency.
Require transparency statements to state what AI is not used and why, as well as what is used.
That transparency statements be required to state not only what AI is used but what AI is not used and why, so that a decision to abstain is itself visible and reviewable
Match any AI disclosure obligation imposed on users of a public institution with an equivalent obligation on the institution itself.
That any obligation of AI disclosure imposed on the users of a public institution be matched by an equivalent obligation on the institution itself.
Require sensitive-personal-information Commonwealth contracts to disclose the contractor's incorporation jurisdiction, parent and every subcontractor with data access; publish these details on the disclosure log.
That Commonwealth contracts for services involving sensitive personal information be required to disclose the contracting entity's jurisdiction of incorporation, its parent, and every subcontractor with access to the data — and that this information be published on the disclosure log rather than being discoverable only by freedom of information.
Prohibit clauses letting a vendor use Commonwealth data to train, tune or improve its models in contracts touching government records, personal information or proceeding material, and audit existing contracts within twelve months.
That clauses permitting a vendor to use Commonwealth data to train, tune or improve its own models be prohibited outright in contracts touching government records, personal information or material generated by a proceeding, with existing contracts audited for such clauses within twelve months.
Treat contractually required supplier reporting, governance and compliance records as presumptively public; have the Committee assess withholding exemptions against the objects of the Freedom of Information Act 1982.
That periodic reporting, governance and compliance records which a Commonwealth contract itself requires the supplier to produce be treated as presumptively public, and that the Committee consider whether the exemptions currently being applied to withhold them are being used consistently with the objects of the Freedom of Information Act 1982.
Fund and mandate a sovereign, onshore transcription and record capability using automated speech recognition under institutional control with human verification, rather than procuring it indirectly.
That the Commonwealth fund and mandate a sovereign, onshore transcription and record capability using automated speech recognition under institutional control with human verification, rather than continuing to procure the same automation indirectly, at labour rates, without disclosure.
Publish contemporaneously the fact of consultation, materials shared and any confidentiality instrument when the Commonwealth consults a commercial AI developer on rules that will apply to it.
That where the Commonwealth consults a commercial AI developer on rules that will apply to that developer, the fact of the consultation, the materials shared and any confidentiality instrument be published contemporaneously.
Disapply the Privacy Act s 6D small-business exemption, under s 6D(4), to entities handling information compelled under a court order or litigation disclosure obligation.
That the small business exemption in s 6D of the Privacy Act 1988 be disapplied to any entity handling personal information a person was compelled to provide under a court order or litigation disclosure obligation, under Section 6D(4).
Have the Attorney-General determine under s 116AAE(13) of the Copyright Act 1968 that training machine learning models is excluded from the orphan works scheme.
That the Attorney-General make a determination under s 116AAE(13) of the Copyright Act 1968 expressly excluding the training of machine learning models from the operation of the orphan works scheme.
Refer orphan works for Legal and Constitutional Affairs References Committee post-implementation review, particularly ss 113Q(2A)–(2D), 116AAD and 116AAE, expressly considering AI training.
That the orphan works scheme be referred to the Legal and Constitutional Affairs References Committee for post-implementation review, with particular attention to ss 113Q(2A)–(2D), 116AAD and 116AAE, and that the review expressly consider the scheme's application to AI training
Define 'reasonably diligent search', 'reasonable time before use' and 'reasonable period' by regulation or determination, with a standard that does not let an AI developer set its own.
That "reasonably diligent search", "reasonable time before use" and "reasonable period" be defined, by regulation or determination, with a standard that does not permit an AI developer to set its own.
Adopt the recommendations only with sovereignty of processing and storage.
And the conditions are not optional. We would rather these recommendations be rejected than adopted without: sovereignty of processing and storage;
Prohibit training or tuning models on proceeding-generated material without express legislative authority.
a prohibition on training or tuning models on material generated in proceedings without express legislative authority;
Disclose on the face of the record wherever an automated system contributed.
disclosure on the face of the record wherever an automated system contributed;
Retain human decisions always; make any narrowing of what decision-makers see visible and reversible.
human decision always, with any narrowing of what a decision- maker sees being visible and reversible;
Provide a right to obtain underlying material and require human review.
a right to obtain the underlying material and require human review;
Provide family-violence safeguards; keep forensic analysis court-controlled and scope-limited, and expressly prohibit its use for coercive control.
family violence safeguards, with any forensic analysis capability court-controlled, scope-limited and expressly prohibited from use as an instrument of coercive control;
Ensure equal access so capability is not available only to parties able to pay.
and equality of access, so that no capability is available only to the party who can pay for it.