Submission 27
Xero
Submitter group: Companies.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
Xero, an accounting software provider, describes its own AI workforce upskilling, argues small business adoption barriers are cost, capability and time, and recommends a curated marketplace, software incentives and advisor-led support. It supports existing technology-neutral frameworks, asks for review of Tax Agent Services Act definitions for AI-enabled software, and says practitioner accountability should be preserved.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Says that protected time to learn and experiment is what shifted staff behaviour on AI in Xero's own experience.
Protected time is what determines whether it happens: every step we have taken that shifted behaviour has involved deliberately clearing people's calendars.
Argues that AI adoption and productivity are different measures, since heavy use can leave processes unchanged.
Adoption and productivity are not the same measure: high daily usage across a workforce is entirely compatible with every process running as it did before, only faster.
Argues that for small businesses the main barriers are cost, capability and time, with time determining whether the others matter.
For small businesses, the barriers are cost, capability and time, and time determines whether the other two matter.
Argues that accountants, bookkeepers and industry associations are trusted advisors and should be funded to deliver practical training.
Accountants, bookkeepers and industry associations are the most trusted sources of advice for small businesses, and funding them to deliver practical, tool-specific training reaches many businesses through each intermediary.
Asks the Committee to assess both unregulated risks and rules preventing safe and useful activity.
On the adequacy of existing law, we ask the Committee to look in both directions. Adequacy is usually assessed by asking where risks are unregulated, and that question will not find a rule preventing something safe and useful from happening, because nothing goes wrong and nobody complains.
Argues that tax agent service and BAS service definitions predate the technology and create uncertainty for rules-based automation, recommending a review.
We recommend that the definitions of a tax agent service and a BAS service under the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 be reviewed for their application to AI-enabled software. These definitions predate the technology and are broad enough to capture routine, rules-based automation.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Establish a government-endorsed marketplace with $500–$5,000 co-funded vouchers; assess software quality, security and interoperability, retain co-payments and admit new and sector-specific providers.
Establish a curated marketplace of pre-qualified small business solutions, paired with co-funded vouchers. A government-endorsed portal of vetted, security-assessed small business software, with co-funding vouchers in the range of $500 to $5,000, addresses cost and search cost together. Products are assessed for quality, security and interoperability, but the model stays open to new and sector-specific providers, and co-payment keeps businesses invested in the outcome.
Introduce a prospective business software subscription incentive, capped per business, limited to the first year and promoted through accountants and bookkeepers.
A more effective design would be prospective, focused specifically on business software subscriptions, capped per business, time-limited to the first year, and promoted through accountants and bookkeepers.
Fund advisor-led, sector-specific support delivered through accountants, bookkeepers and industry associations, combining technical instruction with the organisational side of change.
Fund advisor-led, sector-specific support. Accountants, bookkeepers and industry associations are the most trusted sources of advice for small businesses, and funding them to deliver practical, tool-specific training reaches many businesses through each intermediary. Training should combine technical instruction with the organisational side of change, because small businesses consistently tell us that working out what to change, and how to keep operating through the transition, is harder than learning the tool itself.
Assess the adequacy of existing law by also asking where it constrains safe and beneficial use of AI, not only where harms are unaddressed.
Assessing adequacy by asking only where harms are unaddressed will not find rules of this kind, because nothing has gone wrong. Assessing it by also asking where existing law is constraining safe and beneficial use of AI would, and in this case it would identify a change that removes a substantial amount of manual work from small businesses and their advisors.
Prioritise reviewing tax agent service and BAS service definitions within the Government’s ongoing tax administration reform agenda.
Xero encourages the Government to prioritise a review of the definitions of a tax agent service and a BAS service as part of its ongoing tax administration reform agenda.
Preserve the practitioner-client relationship, with registered tax agents remaining responsible for advice and representation.
Accountability should stay where it is: the practitioner-client relationship, in which a registered tax agent remains responsible for advice and representation, is appropriate and should be preserved. Our interest is in relieving manual toil.
In the review, distinguish routine preparation, anomaly detection, user-confirmed classification and rules-based prompts from interpreting tax law, recommending positions or representing clients before the ATO.
Preparation means assembling and presenting information, surfacing anomalies such as duplicates, missing fields or inconsistencies, suggesting classifications for user or advisor confirmation, and prompting users with rules-based information such as an approaching GST registration threshold. ● Advice means interpreting tax law in light of a client's circumstances, recommending a position, or representing a client before the ATO.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Read the original
In some quotes a program corrected obvious text-recognition errors for display.