AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 289

University of Technology Sydney Centre for Media Transition

Submitter group: Universities.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

Argues that generative AI threatens public interest news and democracy through zero-click search, uncompensated use of news content, source bias and loss of trust. Recommends considering regulatory responses on funding, copyright, prominence, plurality, media literacy and publisher responsibility, and a dedicated AI inquiry modelled on the Digital Platforms Inquiry, while describing its recommendations as high-level.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Argues that generative AI, though it has positive applications, poses a threat to public interest news and, in turn, democracy.

    Generative AI, though it has positive applications, poses a threat to public interest news and, in turn, democracy.

  2. Argues that compensation for news used by AI needs to account for the value of real-time inference and web search, not only training.

    Much of the value of news for AI systems lies in AI’s web-search capabilities during inference and synthesis, rather than training. Any compensation scheme would need to account for the value of real-time inference.

  3. Says AI tools ingest news content, often without compensation, and re-create it, not always accurately and in competition with news producers.

    AI tools ingest news content, often without compensation, and re-create it, not always accurately and often in order to compete with it.

  4. Says zero-click search reduces traffic to news organisations and their ability to monetise costly original news content.

    This zero-click search causes a reduction of traffic to news organisations, affecting their ability to monetise original news content, which is costly to create.

  5. Argues that the algorithmic design of AI tools potentially prefers dubious or non-Australian sources or amplifies biases, and that regulatory intervention may need to include baseline design standards for AI systems dealing in news content.

    It concerns the algorithmic design of AI tools, which potentially preference dubious sources, prioritise non-Australian sources, or amplify biases. In keeping with our call for a holistic and multi-faceted response, regulatory intervention may need to go further and regulate baseline standards for the design of AI systems which deal in news content.

  6. Recommends considering whether and to what extent AI companies should be responsible as content publishers and subject to content regulation.

    Consider whether and to what extent Generative AI companies should be responsible as content publishers and thus subject to content regulation in line with other publishers in Australia.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Prioritise examining generative AI risks to information integrity and address them through regulatory interventions.

    the Committee should recommend that the Parliament and Government prioritise an examination of the risks to information integrity from Generative AI and address this through regulatory interventions

  2. Ensure copyright protections encompass all AI uses and make consent, attribution and other rights enforceable.

    Copyright protections for all AI uses, not just training by LLMs, and which ensure consent, attribution and other rights are enforceable;

  3. Consider extending the News Media Bargaining Incentive to include generative AI.

    Consider extending the NBI to include Generative AI.

  4. Release the Government's proposed copyright licensing scheme for public consultation and consider the relative advantages and disadvantages of copyright versus other measures.

    Release the Government’s proposed copyright licensing scheme for public consultation and consider relative advantages and disadvantages of copyright vs other measures.

  5. Ensure copyright licensing covers all uses, not just LLM training.

    Ensure that copyright licensing covers all uses, not just LLM training.

  6. Consider a small-publisher funding pool, direct funding, digital taxes or relief such as journalist-salary tax offsets; regularly review adopted mechanisms for fitness in a changing environment.

    Consider a funding pool for smaller publishers disadvantaged by Generative AI as well as alternative forms of funding to address the impact of AI such as direct funding, digital taxes, or other forms of relief for affected publishers such as tax offsets for journalist salaries.31 • Ensure that there are regular reviews of these mechanisms to determine that any scheme adopted for this purpose remains fit for purpose in a changing environment.

  7. Consider a scheme giving Australian public interest news prominence in the generative AI environment, possibly including 'must-carry' and 'non-deprioritisation' measures.

    Consider a scheme to ensure Australian public interest news is given prominence in the Generative AI environment. This may involve the adoption of novel measures such as ‘must-carry’ and ’non-deprioritisation’ measures in the AI context.

  8. Consider algorithmic prominence regulation; support an existing or new regulator monitoring algorithmic changes and impacts on news and advertising content.

    Consider algorithmic regulation to incorporate prominence requirements. In 2018, the ACCC made a preliminary recommendation for a regulatory body, whether existing or new, to monitor algorithmic changes and impacts on news and advertising content. 33 We support this recommendation.

  9. Require AI to properly attribute or credit news sources, including links to original sources.

    News sources should always be properly attributed/credited by AI, including through the inclusion of links to original sources.

  10. Consider mechanisms, which may include systemic design and transparency requirements, to ensure generative AI surfaces diverse content and a plurality of voices, not only larger media that can do deals.

    Consider mechanisms for ensuring diverse content and a plurality of voices is surfaced through Generative AI, not only those which preference larger media and other that can do deals. This may include systemic design and transparency requirements for AI systems.

  11. Strengthen media literacy programs to address the impact of generative AI, including through the proposed National Media Strategy.

    Strengthening media literacy programs to directly address the impact of Generative AI including through the proposed National Media Strategy.

  12. Increase public media literacy on AI hallucinations, narrowed sources and synthetic output, including the risks of passive consumption and the need for active verification.

    There is an urgent need to increase public media literacy around the way AI surfaces information in an environment of AI hallucination, narrowed information sources and synthetic output. Consumers need to be aware of the dangers of passive consumption and the requirement for active verification.

  13. Consider whether and to what extent generative AI companies should be responsible as content publishers and subject to content regulation, including remedies for harms from falsely attributed or faked material.

    Consider whether and to what extent Generative AI companies should be responsible as content publishers and thus subject to content regulation in line with other publishers in Australia. This may include developing remedies for harms caused by AI through falsely attributed articles, faked, cloned and other misleading materials.

  14. Consider a co-regulatory scheme that gives affected parties access to a transparent complaints system.

    Consider the applicability of a comparable co-regulatory scheme that includes the ability for affected parties to have access to a transparent complaints system.

  15. Review Australian news media standards with a view to unifying and strengthening them as a precondition of news media receiving additional protections under licensing, bargaining and compensatory schemes.

    Review Australian news media standards with a view to unifying and strengthening public interest media standards as a precondition of news media being given additional protections under licensing, news bargaining and other compensatory schemes.

  16. Ensure a regulator such as the ACMA has sufficient information-gathering powers and funding to obtain the data needed to inform policy decisions.

    Ensure that a regulator such as the ACMA has sufficient information gathering powers and funding to get the data necessary to inform policy decisions.

  17. Consider whether biennial Media Diversity Measurement Framework reports are sufficient and whether there should be annual reports and real-time data.

    Consider whether the current biennial reports on the Media Diversity Measurement Framework are sufficient and whether there should be both annual reports and availability of real time data.

  18. Engage international governments on collaborative approaches, including standardising and creating minimum standards for AI companies.

    Engage international governments in identifying opportunities for collaborative approaches to global issues, including standardising and creating minimum standards for AI companies.

  19. Regularly review AI interventions, preserve flexibility, and examine alignment with international best practice and Australian community expectations for social cohesion and democratic functioning.

    In a fast changing technology and news consumer environment, any legislative or regulatory interventions adopted to address AI impacts should incorporate regular review to ensure they remain fit for purpose. Such legislation should involve mechanisms that enable flexibility and futureproofing. • Regulatory reviews should include examination of whether Australian legislation and regulation is in line with international best practice and whether proposed regulation meets the expectations of the Australian community for interventions that protect our social cohesion and the ability of our democracy to function as it should.

  20. Establish a similarly focused inquiry for AI, through the ACCC or otherwise, covering both market impact issues and related societal issues.

    The CMT believes the Committee should recommend the establishment of a similarly focused inquiry for AI, whether through the ACCC or otherwise, encompassing both market impact issues and related societal issues.

  21. Conduct the proposed AI inquiry expeditiously, at a minimum addressing the issues raised in the submission, while developing and implementing some urgent interventions in the meantime rather than waiting for its outcomes.

    Such an inquiry should, at a minimum, address the issues raised in this submission. It should be conducted expeditiously, while recognising that, due to their urgency, some of the above interventions need to be developed and implemented in the meantime, rather than waiting for the outcomes of the inquiry.

  22. Proceed on the assumption in any such AI inquiry that the commercial interests of global AI companies should not be prioritised over Australia's national interests.

    Most importantly, it should be an assumption of any such inquiry that the commercial interests of global AI companies should not be prioritised over Australia’s national interests.

  23. Make the matters raised a key part of the standing agenda of the new Office of AI in PM&C, with transparent public consultation and regular reporting.

    In July 2026, the Government established a new Office of AI in the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet. This creates the opportunity for an integrated approach to issues that span across different government portfolios but need to be addressed holistically. The CMT believes the matters raised in this submission should form a key part of the standing agenda of the new Office, with processes for transparent public consultation and regular reporting designed for a fast-changing environment.

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide