AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 292

United Workers Union (UWU)

Submitter group: Unions.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

Describes, using an early member survey (342 respondents; 42% had not yet experienced negative effects) and case studies in logistics, aged care, casinos and security, how AI automation, algorithmic rostering and surveillance affect job quality, safety and consultation. Recommends mandatory AI standards covering work, a review of business tax incentives, and industry-level worker councils.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. UWU says that most survey respondents said employers introduced algorithmic management changes without proper consultation.

    The majority of UWU members responding to the survey told us their employers have introduced algorithmic management and administration changes at work without properly consulting them; only 14% positively indicated that consultation had occurred.

  2. UWU says that, without appropriate protections, its members experience AI as a way for employers to pursue old goals such as cutting labour costs and intensifying work.

    Without appropriate protections for UWU members’ workplace rights, privacy, safety and their jobs, the introduction of AI in their workplaces is already being experienced by UWU members as a new way for employers to pursue old goals: squeezing the proportion of outlay on labour costs and introducing work-intensifying labour management practices.

  3. UWU says that members are pessimistic about AI in their workplaces and lives, and feel the pace of change is not supported by Government action.

    Members across our industries tell us that these changes, often happening without adequate consultation, and the pace of AI change more generally does not feel supported by Government action. Members are pessimistic about the introduction of AI to their workplaces and more broadly in their lives

  4. UWU argues that incentives to shift the cost of tasks normally done by labour into capital expenditure must be urgently reviewed given rising employer uptake of AI.

    These positive incentives to shunt the cost of tasks normally done by labour into capital expenditure must be urgently reviewed in the context of rapidly increasing employer uptake of AI in both productive and administrative tasks.

  5. UWU says it supports industry-level councils to consult on and regulate technological innovation, ensuring worker voice and a fair share of productivity benefits.

    UWU has long supported the introduction of industry councils to consult, address and regulate industry specific approaches to technological innovation, ensuring worker voice and a fair share of productivity benefits to working people.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Include regulatory oversight of AI at work in mandatory Australian Standards for AI, including in relation to workplace rights, anti-discrimination, privacy, taxation laws, and protections for environment and First Nations culture and self-determination.

    UWU calls for regulatory oversight of AI at work as a critical aspect of mandatory Australian Standards for AI, including in relation to workplace rights, anti- discrimination, privacy, taxation laws, and for protections for environment and First Nations culture and self-determination.

  2. Review business taxation structures that may be incentivising adoption of algorithmic management and automation at the expense of wages, conditions, classification structures and jobs.

    UWU recommends a review of business taxation structures, addressing signs that our tax system is positively incentivising business adoption of algorithmic management and automation of job tasks at the expense of wages, conditions, classification structures and replacing jobs for humans.

  3. Establish industry councils to strengthen regulation and industry strategies, direct productivity gains to wages and conditions, and address health and safety risks from work intensification, inadequate consultation, surveillance and other disruptive technologies.

    UWU recommends the establishment of industry-level councils. Councils would be directed to address the need for stronger regulation and industry strategies, ensure productivity gains are directed to improvements in wages and conditions, and address the looming work, health and safety crisis caused by work intensification, lack of consultation, surveillance and other disruptive technologies.

  4. Take up the recommendations in the Australian Council of Trade Unions' submission to this inquiry, which UWU supports.

    UWU has contributed to the development of the Australian Council of Trade Unions’ submission to this inquiry and supports its recommendations to the Committee.

  5. Revive the 2022 proposal to limit large multinationals' tax deductions for royalty payments to related parties in low-tax jurisdictions.

    Another recognised strategy for international profit shifting is having a subsidiary pay royalties to parent company for the right to use its intellectual property (IP), such as license fees for proprietary software. The IP is moved to a country with low corporate taxes, and the subsidiary pays the royalty in that country, which is then deducted from the overall corporate tax bill. In 2022 the then Assistant Minister for Charities, Competition and Treasury, Andrew Leigh MP, proposed limiting the ability of large multinationals to claim tax deductions for such royalty payments in low tax jurisdictions.21 That idea should be revived.

  6. Have governments jointly regulate AI and algorithmic management so they never infringe workplace rights.

    As well as proactive regulation to ensure worker voice in decision making, Governments must work together to regulate artificial intelligence and algorithmic management systems to ensure that they are never used to infringe upon workplace rights.22 This includes:

  7. Regulate so that algorithmic management and AI never replace human oversight of workplace practices, especially in areas affecting workplace conditions and legal compliance in hiring, firing, promotions and rostering.

    Algorithmic management and artificial intelligence must never replace human oversight of workplace practices, especially in areas impacting on workplace conditions and adherence to workplace and discrimination laws in hiring, firing, promotions, rostering

  8. Ensure employers comply with work health and safety duties to inform and meaningfully consult workers and their unions before introducing new technologies affecting health and safety, including acting to control psychosocial and work intensification risks.

    In accordance with work, health and safety laws, regulations and codes of practice, employers must both inform and meaningfully consult workers and their unions before introducing new technologies impacting health and safety at work, including acting to control psychosocial and work intensification risks and hazards.

  9. Review the Fair Work Act and privacy legislation to address workers' privacy concerns about AI at work.

    The Fair Work Act and related privacy legislation must be reviewed to address workers’ privacy concerns related to AI at work.

  10. Require full disclosure and meaningful consultation on biometric surveillance, collection and retention; prohibit performance-management or disciplinary use, and ensure compliance with privacy, workplace, anti-discrimination and other relevant laws.

    Employers must provide full disclosure and meaningful consultation around the introduction of biometric surveillance, data collection and retention, and should not be used in performance management and disciplinary proceedings, and steps taken to ensure adherence to privacy laws, workplace laws, anti-discrimination laws and other relevant laws.

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide