Submission 300
Transport Workers' Union of Australia (TWU) and John Curtin Research Centre (JCRC)
Submitter group: Unions.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
Argues that automated vehicles, particularly robotaxis, should be introduced only under a binding human-focused model protecting transport workers, with a workforce impact assessment before law changes. Proposes human-driver quotas, Fair Work Commission minimum standards, operator reporting and cybersecurity risk assessments. A John Curtin Research Centre appendix presents conditional exposure scenarios, not forecasts.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues that governments should establish a human-focused deployment model before automated vehicles are introduced.
governments must establish a human-focused deployment model before automated vehicles are introduced.
Says the JCRC appendix offers conditional Australian exposure scenarios based on US experience, without claiming AVs caused the observed US changes.
Each answers a conditional question: what would happen if the US experience were repeated in Australia? Neither this Appendix nor the US data on which it rests claims that AVs caused the changes observed, because the published data do not allow the effect of AVs to be separated from other influences on driver earnings in those cities.
Argues that the current regulatory pathway enables deployment before safeguards for workers and the public are in place.
Australia is building the pathway for deployment before building the safeguards needed to protect working people, road users and the public.
Argues that gig-economy regulation came too late, after powerful platforms established labour models without protections.
Australia has already seen what happens when governments allow powerful platform businesses to establish a labour model before protections are in place. In the gig economy, regulation came far too late.
Argues that Australia lacks a sufficiently robust framework to assess cybersecurity, privacy, surveillance and data risks of automated and connected vehicles.
Automated and connected vehicles are not simply road vehicles; they are data-gathering, software- dependent systems capable of collecting location, passenger, worker and operational information. Australia does not yet have a sufficiently robust framework to assess and regulate the cybersecurity, privacy, surveillance and data risks posed by these systems.
Argues that overseas robotaxi fleet disruptions show how one company's failure can become a transport-network failure.
These are not isolated technical glitches. They show how quickly one company’s fleet failure can become a transport-network failure, affecting emergency services, public transport, passengers, road users and transport workers.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Pause the Automated Vehicle Safety Law and associated state and territory changes until a comprehensive workforce impact assessment has examined effects on driver employment, hours, earnings, geographic coverage and labour-market adjustment.
The Joint Select Committee should recommend that the Automated Vehicle Safety Law and associated changes to State and Territory laws be paused until a comprehensive workforce impact assessment has examined likely effects on driver employment, hours, earnings, geographic coverage and labour-market adjustment.
Subject the introduction of automated vehicles to a public interest test, including demonstrated community benefit, transparency about risks and evidence of social licence.
The introduction of this technology should also be subject to a public interest test, including demonstrated community benefit, transparency about risks, and evidence that deployment has social licence.
If the risks outweigh the benefits, do not allow human-less vehicles to be imported or deployed in Australia at all; assessments must occur before deployment begins.
If the risks outweigh the benefits, human-less vehicles should not be imported or deployed in Australia at all. These assessments must occur before, not after, deployment begins.
Require each authorised operator, as a market-entry condition, to reserve at least 95% of early work for human drivers (maximum 5% driverless), with a minimum human/driverless ratio of 85:15 over time.
Make a human-driver obligation a condition of market entry. Every authorised operator must maintain a human-centred hybrid network, with at least 95 per cent of the work reserved for human drivers and no more than 5 per cent undertaken by human-less vehicles in early deployment phases, reducing to no less than a ratio of 85:15 over time. The obligation should apply at the operator level, not across the market as a whole, so driverless-only entrants cannot avoid this reasonable requirement.
Reinvest profit gains into the workforce and retain them within the Australian economy.
Profit gains must be reinvested into the workforce and stay within the Australian economic environment.
Have the Fair Work Commission make Minimum Standards Orders protecting earnings, including cost recovery, and other rights and conditions for remaining passenger transport drivers and workers in new automated-vehicle operation and maintenance roles.
Minimum Standards Orders made by the Fair Work Commission must protect earnings, including cost recovery, and other rights and conditions. All remaining passenger transport drivers and all workers in new roles related to the operation and maintenance of automated vehicles must have minimum rights and protections.
Require operators introducing automated vehicles to offer redeployment opportunities to the existing workforce first and fund the cost of transition, including training.
Redeployment costs, including training, must be funded by operators introducing automated vehicles Operators should offer redeployment opportunities to the existing workforce first, and fund the cost of transition.
Require monthly trip, hours, earnings, utilisation, time-of-day, geographic, safety, disruption, emergency-interference and immobilisation reporting; give regulators audit powers against platform records, with escalating non-compliance penalties.
Operators should be required to report monthly data on human and human-less trips, hours, earnings, utilisation, time of day and geographic coverage, as well as safety incidents, service disruptions, emergency-service interference, and vehicle immobilisations. Regulators should have audit powers to test reported figures against platform records, with escalating penalties for non-compliance.
Make authorisation conditional on operators keeping sufficient human-driver capacity for evening and weekend peaks, outer-metropolitan and underserved areas, passengers with accessibility needs and situations needing human judgement.
Authorisation conditions should require operators to maintain sufficient human-driver capacity for evening and weekend peaks, outer-metropolitan and underserved areas, passengers with accessibility needs and circumstances in which human judgement remains necessary.
Make worker consultation a condition of any trial, pilot, authorisation or commercial expansion of automated vehicles.
Worker consultation should be a condition of any trial, pilot, authorisation or commercial expansion.
Require independent workforce, safety and supply-chain assessments and enforceable protections before law changes enable automated driving in freight, heavy vehicles or other transport sectors.
Require separate workforce, safety and supply-chain assessments before automated driving systems are permitted in freight, heavy vehicles or other transport sectors. This submission focuses on the urgent threat posed by robotaxis in commercial passenger transport. However, automated driving systems in freight, heavy vehicle transport and broader transport supply chains raise distinct and more complex risks, including greater consequences for public safety, road users, supply-chain resilience and transport workers. No law changes should enable this technology to enter those sectors until those risks have been independently assessed and enforceable regulatory protections are in place.
Before importing, selling, trialling or deploying automated/connected vehicles, require independent confirmation of enforceable Australian protections against hacking, remote interference, surveillance, tracking, offshore transfers, unsafe updates and road-safety, privacy, national-security and transport-resilience risks.
No automated or connected vehicle should be imported, sold, trialled or deployed unless independent risk assessment confirms enforceable Australian standards are met and can protect against: hacking, remote interference, worker and passenger surveillance, location tracking, offshore data transfer, unsafe software updates and risks to road safety, privacy, national security and transport-system resilience.
Impose clear regulatory accountability on companies that design, own, operate, procure or profit from automated vehicle technology.
Regulation should impose clear accountability on companies that design, own, operate, procure, or profit from automated vehicle technology.