Submission 308
Australian Copyright Council (ACC)
Submitter group: Creative sector.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
The Australian Copyright Council argues that unlicensed AI training infringes copyright, supports licensing and rejects opt-outs and infringement exceptions. Says the Copyright Act applies only to activities within Australia; asks government to address overseas-developed models using unlicensed Australian content through non-copyright measures ensuring recognition and payment for past and ongoing offshore activities.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues that using copyright works in AI data sets without the owner's permission is an infringement of copyright.
The use of copyright works in data sets which form the bedrock of AI platforms, without the licence (permission) of the copyright owner, is an infringement of copyright.
Argues that AI developers' demand to access copyright material is not a legal right or claim equivalent to the rights of copyright owners.
The demand of AI developers to access copyright material is not a legal right, interest or claim equivalent to the rights of copyright owners.
Argues that responsibility and cost of seeking permission should lie with the user of copyright material, not the rights holder.
Respect for creators/copyright owners, as rights holders, must start with acceptance of the proposition that responsibility (and any associated costs) of seeking and obtaining permission to use copyright material must lie with the user (who is not a rights holder).
Argues there is no public policy reason to let AI developers assign creative inputs a zero value and use them without permission and payment.
There is no public policy reason to allow AI developers to insist that the creations of others, critical to the development of their tools, be assigned a zero value and used without permission and payment.
Argues that the assertion that copyright is a barrier to investment in Australia is false, pointing to the number of operational and pipeline data centres.
The assertion that copyright is a barrier to investment 42 in Australia is blatantly false. There are currently 162 ‘operational data centres’ in Australia already with ‘90 pipeline data centres’ 43 with $8.7b in data centres in the March quarter alone.
Argues that the Australian Government should address availability of offshore-trained AI models using unlicensed Australian content through non-copyright solutions.
The availability of AI models (developed overseas) in Australia using unlicensed Australian content must, however, be addressed by the Australian Government using non-copyright solutions to ensure recognition and payment for copyright owners for these past and ongoing offshore activities.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Keep the responsibility and costs of seeking permission with users of copyright material; do not mandate technological protections or opt-outs for rights holders to exercise their rights.
Respect for creators/copyright owners, as rights holders, must start with acceptance of the proposition that responsibility (and any associated costs) of seeking and obtaining permission to use copyright material must lie with the user (who is not a rights holder). 42. Placing the burden on the copyright owner to actively assert their rights by mandating the use of technological protection measures (TPMs) or ‘opt-outs’ goes against the Berne Convention which outlines that ‘[t]he enjoyment and the exercise of these rights shall not be subject to any formality’. 37
Maintain government support for Australia's creative industries and the existing rights of copyright owners, including their right to give or not give permission to use their work.
The ACC urges the government to maintain its support for Australia’s creative industries and the existing rights of copyright owners. Critical to that support is the right of creators/copyright owners to give (or not give) others permission to use their work.
Address overseas-developed AI models using unlicensed Australian content through non-copyright measures, potentially regulating operators as a condition of doing business, ensuring recognition and payment for past and ongoing offshore activities.
The availability of AI models (developed overseas) in Australia using unlicensed Australian content must, however, be addressed by the Australian Government using non-copyright solutions to ensure recognition and payment for copyright owners for these past and ongoing offshore activities. This could be through the regulation of AI operators as a condition of doing business in Australia.
Support the existing copyright licensing framework, to support creators' rights for onshore AI activity involving copyright material.
support for the existing copyright licensing framework 52 to support the rights of creators for onshore AI activity involving copyright material
Reject any proposal amounting to an exception to infringement for AI activities using copyright material, however the exception is labelled or named.
the rejection of any proposal that amounts to an exception to infringement for AI activities utilising copyright protected material (regardless of how that exception is labelled or named),
Work in concert with the Commonwealth Attorney-General and the advice of the Copyright and AI Reference Group.
The ACC encourages the Committee to work in concert with the Commonwealth Attorney General and the advice of the CAIRG.