AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 31

Environment Institute of Australia and New Zealand (EIANZ)

Submitter group: Industry bodies.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

Argues from environmental practitioners' experience that AI can raise productivity, speed climate-risk assessment and support resilience, provided qualified human oversight is retained. Raises concerns about uneven adoption, the junior workforce pipeline, data sovereignty, and the environmental footprint of data centres.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Argues that AI speed and scale gains can free specialists for higher-level judgement rather than replace human expertise.

    these technological speed and scale gains provide an opportunity to free up specialists for higher-level interpretation and judgment, rather than replace human expertise

  2. Argues that adoption is uneven and risks widening the divide between large entities and SMEs lacking in-house capacity.

    While some professionals leverage heavy usage and advanced workflows, others remain at zero adoption or lack the familiarity and confidence required to implement AI effectively, threatening to widen the competitive divide between large, well-resourced entities and small-to-medium enterprises (SMEs) that lack in-house IT, data governance, and risk oversight capacity.

  3. Argues that domain-specific models trained on Australian environmental data offer greater reliability and relevance than generic, foreign-trained models.

    Domain-specific artificial intelligence models trained on authoritative Australian environmental data, unique ecological contexts, social licence, species information, and local regulatory frameworks offer far greater reliability and relevance for specialised environmental applications than generic, foreign-trained models that risk introducing severe geographic and analytical bias.

  4. Argues that automating junior tasks risks eroding early-career roles and the talent pipeline for future oversight.

    by automating the foundational research, data drafting, and technical analysis historically assigned to junior professionals, organisations risk eliminating early-career roles, widening the competence gap between graduates and senior staff, and eroding the talent pipeline needed to cultivate future experts capable of providing critical oversight.

  5. Argues that in government, AI should act as screening and decision support while adverse decisions stay with humans.

    To avoid systemic governance failures and automated misjudgements, Australia's regulatory frameworks should include appropriate safeguards around artificial intelligence. This would help ensure that AI tools function transparently as screening, triage and decision-support mechanisms, while reserving adverse decisions and formal enforcement for human authority.

  6. Argues that AI data centre expansion brings environmental costs and resource demands that must comply with national environmental regulations.

    the construction of AI data centres, introduces significant environmental costs and resource demands that must strictly comply with national environmental regulations (which suitably qualified environmental practitioners have the skills and experience to effectively plan, assess and implement).

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Government should use trusted peak bodies to deliver sector-specific training, model policies and shared capability programmes.

    government support should leverage trusted peak bodies to deliver sector-specific training, model policies, and shared capability programmes

  2. Adopt robust data governance and sovereignty safeguards addressing storage, retention, reuse, control and provenance of information processed by AI systems, particularly confidential or sensitive information.

    Realising these benefits requires robust data governance and sovereignty safeguards. These safeguards should address the storage, retention, reuse, control and provenance of information processed by AI systems, particularly where that information is confidential, commercially sensitive, culturally sensitive or environmentally sensitive.

  3. Treat data sovereignty and output integrity as environmental and professional priorities, requiring transparent model limitations, explicit data provenance and oversight by appropriately certified local practitioners.

    Consequently, ensuring data sovereignty and output integrity must be treated as fundamental environmental and professional priorities rather than purely technical IT concerns, demanding transparent model limitations, explicit data provenance, and rigorous oversight by appropriately certified local practitioners to ethically verify that AI outputs remain accurate and fit for use within the Australian environment

  4. Adopt workforce and education policies promoting AI literacy and mandating structured entry-level training pathways.

    workforce and education policies that promote critical AI literacy and mandate structured entry-level training pathways.

  5. Have workforce and education policies reinforce Certified Environmental Practitioners’ assurance, validation and ethical accountability.

    This risk underscores the urgent need for workforce and education policies that promote critical AI literacy and mandate structured entry-level training pathways. These policies should also reinforce the essential assurance, validation, and ethical accountability provided by Certified Environmental Practitioners.

  6. Include appropriate safeguards on AI in regulatory frameworks so AI functions transparently as screening, triage and decision-support, with adverse decisions and formal enforcement reserved for human authority.

    Australia's regulatory frameworks should include appropriate safeguards around artificial intelligence. This would help ensure that AI tools function transparently as screening, triage and decision-support mechanisms, while reserving adverse decisions and formal enforcement for human authority.

  7. Keep final statutory rejections, regulatory assessments and assurance conclusions subject to human judgement, appropriately qualified professional oversight and explicit statutory accountability.

    final statutory rejections, regulatory assessments and assurance conclusions should remain subject to human judgement, appropriately qualified professional oversight and explicit statutory accountability.

  8. Use AI as decision support in consequential environmental and strategic planning, leaving ultimate responsibility, judgement and statutory decisions with accountable practitioners.

    Removing qualified human oversight from consequential environmental and strategic planning creates severe vulnerabilities regarding validity, data protection, and accountability; therefore, AI should operate as a decision-support mechanism that informs early mitigation while leaving ultimate responsibility, judgment, and statutory decisions strictly bound to accountable practitioners.

  9. Ensure AI data centre construction strictly complies with national environmental regulations.

    particularly the construction of AI data centres, introduces significant environmental costs and resource demands that must strictly comply with national environmental regulations (which suitably qualified environmental practitioners have the skills and experience to effectively plan, assess and implement).

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide