AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 311

Australian Publishers Association (APA)

Submitter group: Creative sector.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

The Australian Publishers Association, which supports responsible AI development, opposes the Attorney-General's Department's proposed 'Option A' copyright framework for AI training, arguing it would authorise some uses without consent. It supports direct and opt-in collective licensing and asks for developer transparency duties, lawful procurement, support for a pilot extending TitlePage (an APA-owned service), and published legal and economic assessment.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Says Option A could weaken licensing and would authorise some AI-training uses without consent, leaving fair compensation and Australian benefits unproven.

    As presently described, the Attorney-General’s Department’s proposed copyright framework for AI training (“Option A”) combines voluntary licensing, technical opt-outs and either statutory authorisation or extended collective licensing. The APA opposes this approach: it would authorise some uses without consent, could weaken licensing, and leaves fair compensation and Australian benefits unproven.

  2. The APA argues that government should establish which capabilities it seeks and why copyright changes are necessary.

    Government should establish which capabilities it seeks and why copyright changes are necessary.

  3. The APA argues that technical opt-outs would shift responsibility onto rightsholders and impose unequal burdens on small publishers and individual creators.

    The proposed technical opt-out would shift responsibility onto rightsholders to prevent use, while leaving unresolved how their exclusions would be recognised and enforced. This would impose unequal burdens on small publishers and individual creators.

  4. Argues an opt-out from future crawling cannot by itself resolve earlier use of Australian works to train overseas models.

    An opt-out from future crawling cannot, by itself, resolve the earlier use of Australian works to train an overseas AI model. An AI service hosted here may use such a model, leaving rightsholders uncertain about the basis and continuing consequences of that use.

  5. The APA argues that primary disclosure duties should rest with developers and dataset suppliers, with auditable sourcing records.

    Primary duties to disclose sources and demonstrate compliance should rest with AI developers, dataset suppliers, scraping operators and commercial model providers. Auditable records should identify sources and acquisition dates, licences or other legal bases, datasets, model versions, onward transfers and compliance with exclusions.

  6. The APA argues that government should use procurement and funding to require lawful sourcing and support licensed Australian works.

    Government should use its purchasing and funding power to require lawful sourcing and support licensed Australian works.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Define sovereign AI objectives and require evidence connecting copyright changes to specific capabilities, enforceable Australian access/control and benefits for Australian authors and publishers.

    Define sovereign AI objectives. Require evidence connecting copyright changes to specific sovereign capabilities, enforceable Australian access and control, and benefits for Australian authors and publishers.

  2. Support an industry-led, opt-in extension of APA-owned TitlePage to encourage local licensing.

    Government could encourage local licensing by supporting an industry-led, opt-in extension of TitlePage. The APA-owned price, availability and bibliographic service covers more than 1.7 million titles.

  3. Reject a broad text-and-data-mining exception and oppose technical opt-outs and non-consensual training authorisations as substitutes for affirmative permission.

    Maintain the rejection of a broad text and data mining exception and oppose technical opt-outs and non-consensual training authorisations as substitutes for affirmative permission.

  4. Place primary disclosure/compliance duties on AI developers, dataset suppliers, scrapers and commercial model providers; require auditable source/acquisition, legal-basis, dataset/version, transfer and exclusion records distinguishing collected from actually used material.

    Primary duties to disclose sources and demonstrate compliance should rest with AI developers, dataset suppliers, scraping operators and commercial model providers. Auditable records should identify sources and acquisition dates, licences or other legal bases, datasets, model versions, onward transfers and compliance with exclusions. Records must distinguish material collected from material actually used.

  5. Require AI suppliers receiving public funding or contracts to document lawful sourcing and deliver promised Australian access and control.

    Require AI suppliers receiving public funding or contracts to document lawful sourcing and deliver the Australian access and control promised.

  6. Sustain Australian writing, publishing and reading; protect literary diversity, educational quality, research integrity, reliable information and First Nations cultural authority.

    Sustain Australian writing, publishing and reading. Protect literary diversity, educational quality, research integrity, reliable information and First Nations cultural authority.

  7. Publish copyright-reform evidence and compare economic effects with supported voluntary licensing, modelling infrastructure investment, statutory payments, direct licensing revenue and net Australian author/publisher returns separately.

    Government should publish the evidence for its proposed copyright changes and compare their economic effects with supported voluntary licensing. This requires modelling of specific proposals, distinguishing infrastructure investment, statutory payments, direct licensing revenue and net returns to Australian authors and publishers.

  8. Seek independent assessment of required security tasks/access/capabilities; control of models, sensitive data and operations; required copyright works and licensing feasibility; and costs of licensed training, secure deployment, assured-access procurement and public compute alternatives.

    The Committee should seek an independent assessment identifying: ● the security tasks, access guarantees and capabilities Australia needs; ● who controls models, sensitive data and operations; ● which copyright works are required and why they cannot practically be licensed; and ● alternatives, including licensed training, secure deployment, assured-access procurement and public computing infrastructure, and their costs.

    A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  9. Where copyright material is necessary for public security, have government pay for it; explain why licensing or funded acquisition would not suffice before reducing control through opt-outs.

    If copyright material is necessary for a public security purpose, government should pay for it as part of that capability. Reducing authors’ and publishers’ control through technical opt-outs requires an explanation of why licensing or funded acquisition would not suffice.

  10. Demonstrate what training would move onshore or remain offshore, additional creator payments and continued imported-model/dataset reliance; weigh gains against lost control, bargaining power and licensing income and compare voluntary licensing/enforcement before commitments.

    Government must demonstrate what activity would move here, what would remain offshore, what additional payments would reach Australian creators, and whether developers would continue relying on imported datasets and models. These gains must be weighed against lost control, bargaining power and licensing income, and compared with supported voluntary licensing and stronger enforcement, before commitments that presume copyright changes.

  11. Distinguish untraceable owners, costly transactions and refused permission when assessing claims that licensing is impractical; refusal or price disagreement does not establish impracticality.

    Claims that material is impractical to license must distinguish between untraceable owners, costly transactions and owners who decline to negotiate permission. Refusal or disagreement about price does not demonstrate that licensing is impractical.

  12. Specify authorised uses, payment triggers, rates and allocation rules, including rightsholder identification/notification, non-member representation and unclaimed payments.

    Government should specify the uses authorised, payment triggers, rates and allocation rules. It must explain how rightsholders would be identified and notified, non-members represented, and unclaimed payments handled.

  13. Estimate payments to Australian and overseas rightsholders net of administration costs and demonstrate practicable owner identification and distribution.

    Government should estimate payments to Australian and overseas rightsholders, accounting for administration costs, and demonstrate that identifying owners and distributing payments is practicable.

  14. Explain legal exclusion measures, compliance checks, consequences of bypassing protections and whether exclusions follow works across copies and websites; specify how robots.txt, passwords and paywalls communicate exclusion.

    Government must explain which measures would legally exclude material, how compliance would be checked, the consequences of bypassing protections, and whether an exclusion follows the work across copies and websites. Robots.txt communicates instructions to crawlers; passwords and paywalls restrict access. Government must specify how these mechanisms would communicate an exclusion from its proposed scheme.

  15. Specify treatment of overseas uses, foreign rightsholders and existing claims; provide workable foreign-rightsholder exclusions and preserve earlier claims unless rightsholders agree otherwise.

    The scheme must specify how it treats overseas uses, foreign rightsholders and existing claims. Australian statutory permission would not itself resolve liability under foreign law. Foreign rightsholders need workable ways to exercise exclusions, and future arrangements should not extinguish earlier claims without rightsholders’ agreement.

  16. Make transparency, piracy protection and enforcement conditions of statutory training permission from commencement; safeguards must not replace consent.

    Transparency, protection against piracy and enforcement must operate from commencement as conditions of any proposed statutory training permission. These safeguards are necessary for accountability; they do not replace consent.

  17. Require providers supplying models in Australia to furnish evidence about imported datasets and underlying models, accounting for laws governing overseas conduct; tailor duties and own-use due diligence to role, information and control.

    AI providers supplying models in Australia should furnish relevant evidence about imported datasets and underlying models, taking account of the laws governing overseas conduct. Schools, libraries, publishers and other customers need reliable supplier assurances because they cannot independently reconstruct a model’s training history. The duties of AI companies should reflect their role, information and control, including due diligence over their own uses.

  18. Back public summaries with regulator, independent-auditor and affected-rightsholder access to detailed sourcing records under appropriate confidentiality protections.

    Public summaries should be backed by access to detailed sourcing records for regulators, independent auditors and affected rightsholders, under appropriate confidentiality protections.

  19. Provide affordable dispute resolution, evidence access and effective remedies for authors and publishers; do not require proof of output reproduction before investigating training use.

    Authors and publishers need affordable dispute resolution, access to evidence and effective remedies. Investigating training use should not depend on first demonstrating reproduction in outputs.

  20. Exclude pirated sources from statutory permission; require sourcing checks, piracy investigations and enforceable consequences, retaining developers’ provenance-checking and copying responsibilities when intermediaries supply datasets.

    Any proposed permission must exclude pirated sources. A “best efforts” assurance is inadequate on its own. Developers must document their sourcing checks, investigate evidence of piracy and face enforceable consequences for non-compliance. Acquiring a dataset through an intermediary should not remove a developer’s responsibility to check its provenance or account for its own copying.

  21. Prevent reliance on statutory authorisation when conditions are breached; impose specified stiff sanctions for disclosure and audit breaches.

    Failure to meet statutory conditions should prevent reliance on the authorisation. Disclosure and audit breaches should attract specified (stiff) sanctions.

  22. Condition Commonwealth procurement, incentives and supported compute on licences where necessary, proportionate audit rights and enforceable remedies; address third-party datasets/models, complaints, correction, suspension and withdrawal of support where appropriate.

    Commonwealth procurement, incentives and access to supported computing infrastructure should require licences where necessary, proportionate audit rights and enforceable remedies. Contracts should address third-party datasets and models, complaints, correction, suspension and withdrawal of support where appropriate.

  23. Encourage lawful Australian books, learning resources and scholarship in purchasing where they serve the application’s purpose.

    Purchasing decisions should encourage lawful use of Australian books, learning resources and scholarship where they serve the purpose of the application.

  24. Scope the TitlePage pilot by establishing developer demand, willing participants, rights-information requirements and responsibilities among publishers, APA and rights organisations.

    Scoping and design: establish developer demand, willing participants, rights information requirements and responsibilities among publishers, the APA and rights organisations.

  25. Develop the pilot to discover Australian works, identify rightsholders, connect direct or voluntary collective licensing and deliver authorised files.

    Development and pilot: enable discovery of Australian works, identification of rightsholders, connections to direct or voluntary collective licensing, and delivery of authorised files.

  26. Include different-sized publishers and support permissions, metadata and file preparation; listing must not authorise use, rightsholders choose participation/works/uses, and collective arrangements require accountable governance, fees and distributions.

    The pilot should include publishers of different sizes and support permissions, metadata and file preparation. Listing a work would not authorise its use. Rightsholders would choose whether to participate and which works and uses to offer; collective arrangements would require accountable governance, fees and distributions.

  27. Measure pilot success through completed licences, transaction costs, payments, participation and useful Australian applications; use procurement and research partnerships to establish demand for educational, scholarly and specialist works serving defined public purposes.

    Success should be measured through completed licences, transaction costs, payments, participation and useful Australian applications. Government procurement and research partnerships could establish demand for educational, scholarly and specialist works serving defined public purposes.

  28. Examine AI/copyright policy effects on author incomes, publishing investment, literary diversity and discoverability, including independent, regional and specialist publishers.

    Copyright and AI policy development should examine author incomes, publishing investment, literary diversity and discoverability, including effects on independent, regional and specialist publishers.

  29. Develop guidance with educators, researchers and publishers covering verifiable references, AI-material disclosure, error correction and bias/privacy safeguards for developers and users.

    Guidance developed with educators, researchers and publishers should therefore set practical expectations for developers and users: verifiable references, disclosure of AI-generated material, correction of errors, and safeguards against bias and privacy breaches.

  30. Require First Nations-led AI safeguards covering free, prior and informed consent, community authority, data sovereignty, restricted material, attribution and benefit sharing.

    First Nations-led safeguards for AI must address free, prior and informed consent, community authority, data sovereignty, restricted material, attribution and benefit sharing.

  31. Assess interference with licensing markets, rights conditioned on digital action and foreign-owner obligations under Berne, TRIPS, the WIPO Copyright Treaty and AUSFTA; payment alone must not establish compatibility.

    Legal assessment should explain whether the scheme would interfere with normal licensing markets, make the effective exercise of rights depend on digital action, or fail to meet obligations to foreign copyright owners. It should address these questions under the Berne Convention, TRIPS, the WIPO Copyright Treaty and AUSFTA. Payment alone does not establish compatibility.

  32. Consider the Committee’s recommendations before investment commitments that presume copyright changes.

    The Committee’s recommendations should be considered before investment commitments that presume copyright changes.

Read the original

In some quotes a program corrected obvious text-recognition errors for display.

Open in the interactive guide