AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 318

Emerson Economics

Submitter group: Companies.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

Emerson Economics, commissioned by TechnologyOne to write a separate procurement report (it says its conclusions are its own), argues Australia's advantage lies in applying AI, not building frontier models, and that sovereignty means control and jurisdiction, not ownership. It recommends procurement and supply-risk measures, AI diplomacy for frontier access, a data centre net-benefit study and Pacific partnership.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Argues that Australia should not try to compete with the US and China in building frontier AI models.

    Australia cannot and should not compete with the US and China in building frontier AI models.

  2. Argues that Australian sovereignty need not depend on the software or AI provider being Australian.

    Sovereignty does not necessarily mean who owns the company: Australian can achieve sovereignty without the company providing the software or AI being Australian.

  3. Argues that access to frontier models depends on AI diplomacy and should be managed as a supply risk.

    access to frontier models depends on successful AI diplomacy and therefore must be managed as a supply risk.

  4. Describes a June 2026 US export ban on a frontier model, which it says cut Australian access for 18 days, as an example of exposure to foreign law.

    In June 2026, for legitimate national security reasons, the United States banned the export of Anthropic’s most powerful AI model, Claude Fable. Consequently, every Australian user and business lost access for 18 days, until a modified version of Claude Fable was re-released with downgraded cyber capabilities

  5. States that trade rules prevent Australia from preferring suppliers by nationality above the procurement threshold.

    Australia cannot prefer suppliers by nationality above the procurement threshold (the value at which the trade rules apply), which is $125,000 for most purchases.

  6. Recommends a Productivity Commission study of large data centres’ net national benefits before national AI standards commence.

    Ask the Productivity Commission to produce a short study, before the national AI standards commence, into the net national benefits of large data centres both in relation to training and running of foreign AI models.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Assess software and AI under Treasury's Economic Resilience and Security Stream, using the Productivity Commission's tests for supply chain vulnerability.

    Assess software and AI under Treasury’s Economic Resilience and Security Stream, using the Productivity Commission’s tests for supply chain vulnerability.

  2. Give direct feedback to Australian suppliers whose government contract bids are unsuccessful, to the extent this can be done without breaching free trade agreements.

    Support domestic industry by giving direct feedback to Australian suppliers if their bids for government contracts are unsuccessful, to the extent this can be done without breaching Australia’s free trade agreements.

  3. If feasible under Australia’s trade agreements, extend to Australian businesses of all sizes the AusTender requirement to record why an Australian supplier was not engaged for $10,000–$125,000 purchases.

    For purchases between $10,000 and the $125,000 threshold they must also record why an Australian business was not engaged (Department of Finance 2025a). If feasible within the terms of Australia’s trade agreements, this should be extended to Australian businesses of all sizes.

  4. Define sovereignty for government procurement as control, legal jurisdiction and exposure to foreign law.

    Define sovereignty for government procurement as control, legal jurisdiction and exposure to foreign law.

  5. Apply the Digital Transformation Agency's control-and-jurisdiction sovereignty test to every government purchase of software and AI, and to hosting certification.

    The DTA has now taken the first step, for one instrument. Its principles for whole-of-government contracts, the Coordinated Contracting Arrangements, were released on 31 August 2026 and require sellers to "strengthen Australia’s sovereignty". They test it through control and jurisdiction: • Is the seller or its parent "subject to laws, regulatory directions or other arrangements which could create risks that override or circumvent Australian contractual protections?”. • Can it show "transparency regarding jurisdictional control, operational control and decision-making authority?" (DTA 2026) T That is the appropriate definition. But it applies only to a handful of whole-of-government arrangements. It should apply to every government purchase of software and AI, and to hosting certification.

  6. Make AI trade and diplomacy a national security priority and seek continued access to frontier models, including non-public models with advanced cyber capabilities.

    Make AI trade and diplomacy a national security priority and seek continued access to frontier models including non-public models with advanced cyber capabilities.

  7. Seek assured frontier-model access for Australia at parity with US agencies when controls are next applied, in return for what Australia offers.

    The other half is assured access for Australia when controls are next applied, at parity with what the United States allows its own agencies (Merchant 2026). Australia should ask for it in return for what it offers.

  8. Ask the Productivity Commission for a short study, before national AI standards commence, of the net national benefits of large data centres for training and running foreign AI models.

    Ask the Productivity Commission to produce a short study, before the national AI standards commence, into the net national benefits of large data centres both in relation to training and running of foreign AI models.

  9. Have the Productivity Commission study assess dependence of productivity gains on Australian data centres, tax payments, regional construction and operating jobs, and demands on capital, skills, land, grid capacity and water.

    A Productivity Commission study, reporting before the standards commence, should examine: • how much of AI’s productivity gain depends on the data centres being in Australia, • how much tax the data centres and their tenants will pay, • the costs and benefits for regions, including jobs during construction and operations, • the domestic capital, skilled labour, land, grid capacity and water that data centres draw from the energy transition,

  10. Have the study assess whether renewable-generation matching rules deliver supply in time, effects on the 82 per cent renewable target and prices, and, with Treasury and the Reserve Bank, growth consistent with 2–3% inflation.

    whether the proposed rule that data centres pay for new renewable generation to match their use delivers that generation in time, and the effect on the 82 per cent renewable target and on prices if it does not, • with Treasury and the Reserve Bank, the effect of the investment pipeline on growth consistent with the 2 to 3 per cent inflation target.

  11. Support the Pacific Islands Forum's AI Governance Framework and examine with Forum members how Australia can be the region's trusted AI partner.

    Support the Pacific Islands Forum’s AI Governance Framework and examine with Forum members how Australia can be the region’s trusted AI partner.

  12. Use bilateral treaties and enabling legislation to protect Pacific governments’ hosted systems from legal process and provide special status, following Luxembourg’s arrangements.

    No Australian statute protects a foreign government’s systems hosted in Australia from legal process or gives them any special status. Australia’s Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 governs court proceedings, not warrants served on a provider. The two working precedents, Estonia’s and Monaco’s arrangements with Luxembourg, rest on bilateral treaties and enabling legislation (Estonia and Luxembourg 2017; Monaco and Luxembourg 2021). Australia would need the same.

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide