Submission 32
Independent Music Publishers International Forum (IMPF)
Submitter group: Industry bodies.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
Argues that Australia's copyright framework is fit for purpose and opposes a commercial text and data mining exception. Proposes building an AI licensing market on authorisation, transparency, remuneration and accountability, supported by record-keeping and disclosure measures, and raises sustainability and First Nations cultural material considerations.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues that existing copyright principles already require AI providers to seek permission, so no new AI exception is needed.
There is no gap in the underlying copyright principles that requires a new AI exception or a reduction in the rights of creators and rightsholders. The framework already supplies the basis for lawful access: AI providers should seek permission and agree licence terms when they use protected works.
Argues against a commercial text and data mining exception as unnecessary for innovation and harmful to creators and licensing markets.
There is no justification for introducing a commercial text and data mining exception. As IMPF has previously communicated1, such an exception is unnecessary for innovation, would undermine creator livelihoods and developing licensing markets, and would create further legal uncertainty.
Says rightsholders must be able to determine whether their works were used, by whom and for what purpose.
Rightsholders must be able to determine whether their works were used, by whom and for what purpose.
Proposes that Australia build a licensing market on four established elements, beginning with AI providers obtaining permission before protected works are used for training.
We would propose that Australia build a licensing market on four established elements: ➢ Authorisation: AI providers obtain permission before protected works are used for training or other commercial model-development purposes.
Says AI governance should account for resource intensity, with transparency on energy, water and infrastructure impacts.
AI governance should also account for resource intensity. Measures promoting adoption should prioritise applications that create meaningful human, cultural or economic value, and require transparency and accountability for material energy, water and infrastructure impacts.
Says use of First Nations cultural material in AI development must respect community authority and cultural protocols.
Australian creative, cultural and media content is not a free raw material. Its use in AI development must respect copyright and, where First Nations cultural material is involved, the authority of relevant communities and observation of cultural protocols.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Use mandatory records, proportionate disclosure, evidence preservation and effective remedies to support compliance and licensing without altering copyright’s substantive framework.
Mandatory records, proportionate disclosure, preservation of evidence and effective remedies would support compliance and licensing without altering copyright's substantive framework.
Do not introduce a commercial text and data mining exception.
There is no justification for introducing a commercial text and data mining exception.
Build the licensing market on authorisation: AI providers obtain permission before using protected works for training or other commercial model development.
We would propose that Australia build a licensing market on four established elements: ➢ Authorisation: AI providers obtain permission before protected works are used for training or other commercial model-development purposes.
Require licensing-market transparency: identify relevant datasets, sources and work categories, retain item-level records where technically feasible, and respond to substantiated rightsholder queries.
Transparency: Providers identify relevant datasets, sources and categories of works, retain item-level records where technically feasible, and respond to substantiated rightsholder queries.
Use licences to let creators and rightsholders share in value from their works, with terms reflecting the nature and scale of use.
Remuneration: Licences allow creators and rightsholders to share in the value produced from the use of their works, with terms reflecting the nature and scale of use.
Ensure accountability cannot be avoided through opaque datasets, offshore processing or contractual allocation within the AI supply chain; provide practical, timely remedies.
Accountability: Responsibility cannot be avoided through opaque datasets, offshore processing or contractual allocation within the AI supply chain; remedies must be practical and timely.
Measures promoting AI adoption should prioritise applications creating meaningful human, cultural or economic value and require transparency and accountability for material energy, water and infrastructure impacts.
Measures promoting adoption should prioritise applications that create meaningful human, cultural or economic value, and require transparency and accountability for material energy, water and infrastructure impacts.
Include efficiency and sustainability in Australia’s conception of trustworthy AI.
Efficiency and sustainability should form part of Australia's conception of trustworthy AI.
Ensure AI use of Australian creative, cultural and media content respects copyright and, for First Nations cultural material, relevant communities’ authority and cultural protocols.
Australian creative, cultural and media content is not a free raw material. Its use in AI development must respect copyright and, where First Nations cultural material is involved, the authority of relevant communities and observation of cultural protocols.