Submission 325
National Tertiary Education Union (NTEU)
Submitter group: Unions.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
Argues from the perspective of tertiary education workers that AI has been introduced ad hoc in universities, intensifying workloads and risking research integrity, de-skilling and job displacement, while acknowledging positive uses in research. Sets out seven numbered recommendations, including AI Safety Institute funding and regulatory powers, a national approach to AI in higher education, moral-rights protection and a research repository.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
States that failing to develop a sector-wide approach with full stakeholder input is a significant strategic risk to the higher education sector.
It is the view of NTEU that the failure to have developed a sector-wide approach with full input from stakeholders is a significant strategic risk to the higher education sector.
Says staff in universities report that AI introduction has increased and intensified workload despite promised productivity gains.
Despite the promises of increased productivity and removal of tedious work to allow more time for reflection and higher-level tasks, staff in Australian universities report that workload has significantly increased and intensified with the introduction of AI systems, especially as it is occurring without an adequate framework for them to work within.
Argues that GenAI-produced content has entered academic literature, resulting in published articles containing hallucinations, falsified data and false attributions.
Regarding research, there is clear evidence that GenAI produced content has infiltrated the academic literature and that as a result research articles have been published that contain hallucinations, falsification of data and false attributions.
Argues academic authors lack practical means to prosecute moral-rights breaches beyond monitoring the internet and approaching each platform for removal.
There is currently no practical way for academic authors to prosecute the breaches of their moral rights. The only avenue they have (as confirmed in discussions with Microsoft) is to monitor the internet and approach each platform to seek that offending work be taken down.
Argues educational digital sovereignty is needed to educate students consistently with Australian norms, values and expectations and retain control of education.
Educational digital sovereignty is needed to ensure that we are educating students consistent with Australian norms, values and expectations and retain control of our education system
Argues that the AI Safety Institute is under-funded and under-resourced, at just 25 FTE, for its remit.
Investment is a measure of interest, and the AI Safety Institute of Australia (AISI) is shockingly under-funded and resourced by Government at just 25 FTE for a body tasked to work across all portfolios in a time of revolutionary change with such profound safety issues.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Provide funding to the AI Safety Institute sufficient to meet the significance of the challenge AI poses across work, the economy and the community.
Provide funding to the AISI sufficient for it to meet the significance of the challenge that AI poses to Australia across all aspects of work, the economy and the community;
Confer regulatory powers on the AI Safety Institute to protect the Australian community from AI-derived harms.
confer regulatory powers on the AISI to protect the Australian community from AI derived harms;
Oversee a nationally consistent approach to AI in higher education, developed with stakeholders including unions, that defines the role and value of higher education and ensures AI use serves those goals.
oversee a nationally consistent approach to the use of AI in higher education developed with stakeholders, including unions, that defines the role and value of higher education to the community and ensures that AI use is in service of those goals;
Improve protection of the moral rights of authors.
improve protection of the moral rights of authors;
Establish a national repository of Australian research within the National Library of Australia, with strict rules on any AI use in research production, to provide reliable information.
NTEU supports the development of a national repository of Australian research situated within the National Library of Australia with strict rules surrounding the use, if any, of artificial intelligence in the production of the research. This will ensure that the Government and the community have a reliable source of factual information and will add value to the work of Australian researchers whose work is included.
Prioritise development of educational digital sovereignty, consistent with Australian norms and values, for use in all levels of education.
prioritise development of educational digital sovereignty, that is consistent with Australian norms and values, for use in all levels of education;
Make specific provisions to protect Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander heritage and culture.
make specific provisions to protect Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander heritage and culture.
Invest in sovereign AI capacity for education, research integrity and competitive advantage, and preservation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander lived experiences, culture, language and arts.
Australia urgently needs to invest in sovereign AI capacity to: • Protect, support and retain control of our education systems • To support research integrity and to protect our research and competitive advantage in research and innovation • To ensure that the lived experiences, culture, language and arts of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders is preserved and available for future generations
Use sovereign AI capacity and regulation to protect Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander culture, language and arts from exploitation and provide systems reflecting those communities’ experiences.
Finally sovereign AI capacity and regulation is needed to protect the culture, language and arts of Aboriginal and Torres Strait islanders, by protecting it from exploitation and by providing a system that reflects the experiences of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities.