AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 329

Rightsholder Group

Submitter group: Creative sector.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

A joint submission by Australian rightsholder groups addresses copyright and AI training. It argues the existing framework is fit for purpose and that voluntary licensing is working, opposes opt-out schemes and expanded safe harbour provisions, and supports mandatory transparency for AI training datasets and licensed-only government procurement.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Argues that Australia's copyright framework is fit for purpose and enables voluntarily negotiated licensing with AI companies.

    Australia has a fit-for-purpose intellectual property framework which provides users of copyright material, including AI companies, with access to high-quality material via voluntarily negotiated licensing arrangements, while creators and rightsholders are incentivised to create through the availability of exclusive rights that give them the agency to set the price and conditions of use of their works.

  2. Argues that government intervention in exclusive rights should be a last resort and that no market failure exists.

    Government intervention with these exclusive rights and rightsholders’ control over their works, including setting the value of their works, should be a measure of last resort where there has been a clearly demonstrated market failure. No such failure exists.

  3. Argues that opt-out frameworks impose an unreasonable burden on rightsholders.

    Any framework that requires rightsholders to actively opt out of AI training creates an unreasonable burden. Rightsholders’ works can be distributed and available across numerous platforms which the rightsholders may not have control over.

  4. Argues that safe harbour was intended for passive intermediaries, not entities that actively use copyright material, and that expanding it for AI developers should be ruled out.

    Safe harbour was intended to provide a limited defence for passive intermediaries whose users/customers were infringing copyright – it was not intended to shield entities that actively use and exploit copyright-protected material to develop their own products or services. Such changes which undermine and weaken the bargaining position of rightsholders discussing licensing with AI developers should be ruled out.

  5. Argues that rightsholders must be able to identify when their works are used, with transparency obligations also applied to web-scraping bots.

    Among other things, to make AI companies accountable, rightsholders must be able to identify when their works have been accessed or used, that licensing conditions have been complied with, and to enforce their rights when necessary. Similar transparency obligations must also be applied to web- scraping bots so there is clarity on what sources data is being sourced from.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Preserve the exclusive rights in Australia's copyright framework, with rightsholders retaining ownership and control over price, use and value.

    It is key that the exclusive rights provided by Australia’s copyright framework are preserved, and that rightsholders retain ownership and control of their work. This includes the control over price, use and value.

  2. Limit government intervention in rightsholders' exclusive rights and control over value to a measure of last resort where a market failure has been clearly demonstrated.

    Government intervention with these exclusive rights and rightsholders’ control over their works, including setting the value of their works, should be a measure of last resort where there has been a clearly demonstrated market failure.

  3. Do not adopt measures that shift the burden onto rightsholders to opt out; place the burden on AI companies to seek permission and find the rightsholder.

    We oppose measures that will shift the burden onto rightsholders to take active steps to protect their property rights. The burden should be on AI companies to seek permission, utilising their technology to identify the works they want to use and find the rightsholder to negotiate access.

  4. Rule out any proposal to expand or amend Copyright Act safe harbour provisions for the benefit of AI developers.

    We strongly oppose any proposal to expand or amend safe harbour provisions in the Copyright Act for the benefit of AI developers.

  5. Implement mandatory AI dataset and service transparency so rightsholders can identify use of their works, check licensing compliance and enforce their rights.

    We encourage the implementation of mandatory transparency requirements on companies which compile, create and use AI training datasets and offer AI services to the general public. Among other things, to make AI companies accountable, rightsholders must be able to identify when their works have been accessed or used, that licensing conditions have been complied with, and to enforce their rights when necessary.

  6. Apply similar transparency obligations to web-scraping bots so there is clarity on what sources data is taken from.

    Similar transparency obligations must also be applied to web- scraping bots so there is clarity on what sources data is being sourced from.

  7. Commit to procuring AI services and products only from suppliers who have entered licensing arrangements with rightsholders.

    The Government should lead the way in displaying best practice and ethical use of AI by committing to procuring AI services and products only from suppliers who have entered licensing arrangements with rightsholders.

  8. Work closely with the creative and content sectors to identify measures that safeguard the rights and interests of creators and rightsholders.

    We urge the Joint Select Committee and Government to work closely with the creative and content sectors to identify measures that safeguard the rights and interests of creators and rightsholders.

  9. Put any proposed models out for public consultation so all affected parties can review and comment.

    Any proposed models must be put out for public consultation to allow all affected parties to review and provide comment.

  10. Ensure any licensing model or copyright law change is consistent with Australia's international treaty obligations and constitutional IP protections.

    Government must also be mindful that any licensing model or changes to copyright law must be consistent with Australia’s international treaty obligations (including under TRIPS, the Berne Convention, WIPO and WCT) and is consistent with the protections for intellectual property rights provided by the Constitution.

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide