Submission 354
A New Approach (ANA)
Submitter group: Research institutes.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
A national arts and culture think tank argues that government decisions on AI will determine whether it strengthens Australian creativity and public participation or weakens creative livelihoods, rights and trust. It recommends AI in the National Cultural Policy, fit-for-purpose copyright law, funded AI literacy through cultural institutions, and inclusion of creative businesses in workforce and small business measures, drawing on two attached earlier papers.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
States that AI is already changing how Australians create and experience arts and culture, and that government decisions will determine who benefits and who carries the risks.
AI is already changing how Australians create, distribute, discover and experience arts and culture. The issue is immediate: government decisions will determine who benefits, who carries the risks and whether Australians trust AI and the content it produces.
Says its analysis identifies two key risks, impact on the incentive to create and on connections people have with arts and culture, both tied to trust.
impact on the incentive to create ● impact on connections people have with arts and culture Both go to concerns about trust – trust that creativity is valued (through, for example, remuneration and protection of copyright), and trust in what is created (ensuring that people can distinguish between human creations and those involving generative AI).
Says government should develop cultural policy and AI policy together, as arts and culture is a distinct area of focus for AI risks, benefits and trust.
Government should develop cultural policy and AI policy together. Arts, culture and creativity is a distinct and important area of focus when grappling with the risks and benefits of AI, and the impact AI has on trust.
Argues that copyright reform should consider the risks and benefits of AI in arts and culture and the differing subsectors and business models within the creative industries.
The approach to reform should consider both the risks and benefits of AI in arts and culture, alongside the interests and ambitions of different parts of the cultural and creative industries and audiences. This should include looking at the different subsectors and business models within the cultural and creative industries.
Argues that trusted local cultural organisations such as libraries and galleries should be funded to build public AI literacy.
Local cultural organisations such as libraries and galleries are deeply trusted, highly accessible community infrastructure and should be funded to build AI literacy.
Argues that most cultural and creative businesses are sole traders or small businesses and should be specifically considered when assessing AI adoption barriers.
It is also important to consider that the great majority of Australia's cultural and creative businesses are sole traders and small businesses. When assessing AI adoption barriers for small and family businesses, creative businesses should be specifically considered.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Ensure fit-for-purpose copyright and intellectual property law for creative content used by AI.
Ensure Australia has fit-for-purpose copyright and intellectual property law for creative content used by AI
Fund cultural institutions and organisations to build practical AI literacy across Australia.
Fund cultural institutions and organisations to build practical AI literacy across Australia
Include creative workers and businesses in national AI workforce and small business measures.
Include creative workers and businesses in national AI workforce and small business measures
Coordinate cultural, industry, education and technology policy and align action across jurisdictions to realise AI benefits and manage risks.
Governments must coordinate cultural, industry, education and technology policy, and align action across jurisdictions, to realise the benefits and manage the risks.
Develop cultural policy and AI policy together.
Government should develop cultural policy and AI policy together.
Include a standing AI work program in the next National Cultural Policy, with Cultural Ministers and the Australian Local Government Association reviewing progress and settings regularly, publishing agreed actions and updating them.
The Australian Government should include a standing AI work program in the next National Cultural Policy. Cultural Ministers and the Australian Local Government Association should review progress and policy settings regularly, publish agreed actions and update them as the technology changes.
Consider AI risks and benefits, audience interests, and the differing interests, ambitions, subsectors and business models of cultural and creative industries when reforming copyright.
The approach to reform should consider both the risks and benefits of AI in arts and culture, alongside the interests and ambitions of different parts of the cultural and creative industries and audiences. This should include looking at the different subsectors and business models within the cultural and creative industries.
Specifically consider the creative workforce in any examination of workforce and skills implications, including incentives to create, quality and security of creative work and career pathways.
Any examination of workforce and skills implications should specifically consider the creative workforce, including impacts on incentives to create, the quality and security of creative work, and sustainable career pathways.
Specifically consider creative businesses when assessing AI adoption barriers for small and family businesses.
When assessing AI adoption barriers for small and family businesses, creative businesses should be specifically considered.
In the attached 2024 paper, have cultural policies at every government level acknowledge and address AI impacts on both production and consumption of arts and culture.
Cultural policies at all levels of government should explicitly acknowledge the real impacts of AI on arts and culture, both in production and consumption contexts, and commit to addressing these impacts.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
In an attached 2024 paper: have agencies responsible for AI policy and government AI use consider and address impacts relevant to arts and culture.
Government agencies responsible for AI policy and government use of AI should consider and address the impacts relevant to arts and culture when making policy.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
In the attached 2024 paper, have representative government, academic and industry surveys vigilantly track why and how Australians use AI in cultural and creative activities.
Representative surveys by government, academia and industry on AI usage should vigilantly track why and how Australians use AI across cultural and creative activities.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
In an attached 2024 paper: take a cross-portfolio approach to regulating deepfakes that explicitly considers arts and culture.
Governments should take a cross-portfolio approach to regulating deepfakes that explicitly considers arts and culture.
In the attached 2024 paper, have major galleries, libraries, archives and museums share AI knowledge and benefits with smaller institutions to benefit communities.
Major galleries, libraries, archives and museums should actively share knowledge and the benefits of AI with smaller institutions to help ensure uses of AI are beneficial for arts and culture in all communities.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
In the attached 2024 paper, use Australian industry knowledge, including generative-AI developers’ insights, to inform domestic policy and engagement with overseas regulators.
Governments should harness the knowledge of Australian industry regarding the impacts of AI in arts and culture, including insights from generative AI developers, to inform domestic policy and engagement with overseas regulators of AI.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
In the attached 2024 paper, use cultural and creative activities as an accessible way to improve AI understanding and equip Australians to use AI safely, innovatively and inclusively.
Equip Australians to apply AI in safer, more innovative and inclusive ways by using cultural and creative activities as an accessible means toimprove awareness and understanding.
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
In the attached 2024 paper, explore government-industry partnerships using arts and culture to shape AI impacts.
Governments and cultural and creative industries should explore partnerships to leverage arts and culture to shape Governments and cultural and creative industries are AI’s impacts.
In the attached 2023 paper, consider broad, risk-based AI governance to safeguard Australians and people in Australia.
In ANA’'s view, Australia should consider a broad, risk-based approach to help safeguard the interests of Australians (and people in Australia, more broadly).
Read the original
In some quotes a program corrected obvious text-recognition errors for display.