AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 362

Mr Matthew Hall

Submitter group: Individuals.

Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

A school digital learning director argues Australia needs a clearer account of how schools prepare young people for an AI-enabled future, covering epistemic literacy, family employment anxiety, teacher capability, evaluation of AI products for schools, student agency, child safety and sovereign education capability. Sees considerable opportunity alongside uncertainty.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Argues that young people need both the capacity to use AI and the knowledge and confidence to question it.

    My central argument is that Australia needs a clearer account of what it means to prepare a young person for an AI-enabled future. Young Australians need the capacity to use AI. They also need the knowledge and the confidence to question it.

  2. Argues that AI literacy should explicitly include epistemic judgement, and that teachers need further guidance to teach it.

    For this reason, I believe AI literacy should include what is described as epistemic judgement or epistemic literacy. By this, I mean the capacity to make informed decisions about the knowledge an AI system produces. This is something that needs to be explicitly taught, and something that teachers need further guidance on.

  3. Says employment concerns about AI are reaching students and families in schools and becoming educational and well-being concerns.

    Parents are understandably asking whether the occupations they know will remain secure. Young people are also trying to make decisions about pathways into a labour market that can appear increasingly difficult to predict. These workforce concerns are becoming educational and well-being concerns in schools.

  4. Argues that the same AI system can have very different educational effects depending on how it is introduced, so teacher pedagogical judgement is central.

    A teacher may use generative AI to help a student overcome a technical barrier that has prevented progress with a larger task. In another setting, its use can remove much of the intellectual work that the task was designed to develop. There is no universal prompt that resolves this distinction. It requires pedagogical judgement.

  5. Says Australia would benefit from a nationally coordinated approach to evaluating or developing AI products for schools, reducing dependence on big tech.

    I believe Australia would benefit from a nationally coordinated approach to evaluating or developing AI products intended for use in schools, and thereby diversifying dependence on ‘big tech’.

  6. Says that conversational AI and persona chatbots could foster emotional reliance and isolating behaviours among young users if left unregulated.

    This raises questions about emotional reliance and the extent to which young users distinguish between a functional tool and a system designed to simulate interpersonal connection. Left unregulated, there are concerns that AI persona chatbots could fuel isolating behaviours and non-human emotional connections.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Include epistemic judgement or epistemic literacy in AI literacy, explicitly taught, with further guidance for teachers.

    For this reason, I believe AI literacy should include what is described as epistemic judgement or epistemic literacy. By this, I mean the capacity to make informed decisions about the knowledge an AI system produces. This is something that needs to be explicitly taught, and something that teachers need further guidance on.

  2. Translate Jobs and Skills Australia evidence on emerging roles and changing demand for AI-related skills into accessible, regularly updated guidance for schools.

    Jobs and Skills Australia is already analysing emerging roles and changing demand for AI-related skills. That evidence should be translated into accessible and regularly updated guidance for schools.

  3. Give career guidance a more prominent and holistic role within schools, cross-curricular and embedded in curriculum programs.

    Career guidance should therefore occupy a more prominent and holistic role within schools, where it cross-curricular and embedded into curriculum programs. Sporadic meetings are no longer sufficient.

  4. Provide national and jurisdictional support for pedagogical AI capability.

    National and jurisdictional support for pedagogical AI capability would strengthen both responsible adoption and workforce preparation.

  5. Ensure subject-specific teacher support on AI’s educational value and learning design reaches schools equitably, regardless of size or individual staff expertise.

    Teachers need opportunities to examine what AI means within their own subject. They need to decide where its use adds educational value and how learning design changes when students have immediate access to generated content. This support should reach schools equitably. A school’s capacity to respond well to AI should not depend heavily on its size or whether a particular staff member happens to have specialist expertise.

  6. Adopt a nationally coordinated approach to evaluating or developing AI products intended for use in schools, giving schools credible information on whether platforms meet expectations for educational use.

    I believe Australia would benefit from a nationally coordinated approach to evaluating or developing AI products intended for use in schools, and thereby diversifying dependence on ‘big tech’. Schools should be able to access credible information about whether a platform meets appropriate expectations for educational use.

  7. Set clear expectations for companies seeking access to Australian schools about the evidence they provide.

    Companies seeking access to Australian schools should face clear expectations about the evidence they provide.

  8. Preserve meaningful opportunities for students to exercise judgement over their own learning when using AI, including deciding whether to accept or reject creative suggestions.

    AI use in schools should preserve meaningful opportunities for students to exercise judgment over their own learning. This is especially visible in creative subjects. A student may use AI to develop possibilities for a piece of work or overcome a technical problem. The educational value depends in part on whether they can decide what goes into the final work. The decision to reject an AI suggestion can be significant.

  9. Give education authorities practical guidance that keeps pace with the technology on relational features of AI products used by children, with the AI Safety Institute and eSafety continuing to examine them.

    Relational characteristics also need consideration when these products are used by children. The Australian AI Safety Institute and eSafety are well placed to continue examining these features. Education authorities then need practical guidance that keeps pace with the technology.

  10. Consider developing education-specific AI testing capabilities that reflect local curricula and expectations for student safety.

    Australia could develop education-specific testing capabilities that reflect local curricula and expectations for student safety.

  11. Examine where sovereign or domain-specific AI capability could provide strategic value in education, especially where Australian curriculum knowledge or security requirements justify it.

    I believe Australia should examine where sovereign or domain-specific AI capability could provide strategic value in education, especially where Australian curriculum knowledge, or security requirements justify domestic capability.

  12. Consider secure environments where researchers and education authorities can examine AI behaviour before widespread adoption, ensuring models are trained on safe, accurate and verifiable information.

    Researchers and education authorities could use secure environments to examine how systems behave before widespread adoption, ensuring models are trained on safe, accurate and verifiable information.

  13. Include provenance and copyright in arts students' preparation for a creative landscape reshaped by generative AI.

    Students currently studying the arts are entering a creative landscape already being reshaped by generative AI. They need opportunities to understand authorship in that environment. Questions of provenance and copyright should form part of their preparation.

  14. Place greater emphasis on implementation of the Australian Framework for Generative AI in Schools and the National AI Plan, and on connecting schooling to future work.

    Australia already has useful policy foundations through the Australian Framework for Generative AI in Schools and the National AI Plan. The next stage should place greater emphasis on implementation and on the connection between schooling and future work.

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide