Submission 366
Mr Philip Gluyas
Submitter group: Individuals.
Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.
An AI model identified the submitter group and chose the extracts. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Extracts from the submission, in the submitter’s own words.
Extracts
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Automated Decision Making (ADM). It has alarming similarities to the system used in the Robodebt scheme, and as the Committee would know this is not acceptable. There are some decisions that must be made by a human being and not by any form of AI, because it requires something that AI does not possess – human instinct and intuition.
Using ADM technology is useful, but it must be backed up by human oversight to ensure accuracy. This will provide confidence in it's use both by the departments and by the community that rely on said departments for the proper delivery of government services.
Any issues that originate from outside Australia are hard to regulate without pushback and negotiation is needed.
Creating fake videos is already happening and can paint people – not neccessarily public figures either – in a way that would be in violation of both defamation law and intellectual property law.
The use of AI will increase the options in this area for general criminals, terrorists and foreign governments who would seek to have an effect on our country in a number of ways.
It all snowballs and the over reliance on technology is primarily at fault for the extended delays. This is my point. We can not over rely on technology like this, and this especially applies to AI.
Extracts from recommendations
Extracts chosen by an AI model, in the submitter’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Given what I said already about the United States, we need a wide scale response in order to compete otherwise we will fall behind and be over run.
AI relies heavily on online access, and in the regions in Australia this is still an issue. While it is improving, location should not be a hold back.
Other barriers include fear of AI in that it is seen as a job killer in the same way the industrial revolution was way back when. Fear in 2026 is a major driver to a lot of society's issues and it needs to be realistically allayed as quickly as possible. The width of options across several industries does more to change jobs instead of eliminate them – as long as it is done correctly. This sounds socialist – but if one wants to make money at the expense of others it can be done and should be stopped as quickly as possible. And I'm talking about legitimate use as distinct from criminal use.
The only view I have here (given what I said in (d) above covers a lot of this) is the fact that the internet and related computer technology – by it's very nature – is hard to control due to external factors of competition from other countries and the ever present threat of cyber attacks. We need protections in place in this regard.
The education system absolutely needs to adjust to this across all spheres, and given the early access children have to technology in general schools must have access to it under proper controls of course in primary education.
This has to be a long term strategy across 13 years at school from Prep through to Year 12 and must include career guidance that is tailored widely and flexibly in high school.
Then there are the retraining options for adults now – which is also something that should be happening already. This is why free TAFE is so important as one example, alongside the university sector to follow up on the 13 years of schooling for our future work force.
There are some decisions that must be made by a human being and not by any form of AI, because it requires something that AI does not possess – human instinct and intuition.
Using ADM technology is useful, but it must be backed up by human oversight to ensure accuracy. This will provide confidence in it's use both by the departments and by the community that rely on said departments for the proper delivery of government services.
Negotiation with other countries on the other hand is definitely to our benefit (and theirs as well) where we can combine resources and protect ourselves from the unregulated regimes whether it be the United States or Russia at minimum.
This is an area where the states and territories have to be involved as defamation law does fall to them as one example. Federal guidance in this space from the office of the Attorney General would be well advised.
Defence against cyber attacks are one thing, but prevention is better than cure. Achieving that on the other hand is extremely hard and we have to be brought up to date in this area to be in the best position to combat this.
But we do have to include the United States in this defence, given recent notes that the President has authorised private companies to engage in cyber attacks against those who operate against the United States. Without government control at their end this will lead to errors and may affect us by accident with alarming consequences. It's why we need to take a lead in this.
Both shut down the V/Line rail system in Victoria, with the Telstra outage causing a 36 hour shut down. This would have been avoided if there was a manual back up in place, and said back up should be semi localised and driven by humans.
AI is not something to be taken lightly and the Albanese government is aware of this already. I ask that all other members of Parliament regardless of political leaning take the same attitude, in particular the members of this Select Committee.