AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 384

Mr John Borley

Submitter group: Individuals.

Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

An artist proposes a 'Cultural Dividend': the idea that companies deriving substantial commercial value from generative AI might contribute to sustaining the cultural ecosystem, in addition to and not instead of copyright, licensing and payment to creators. It asks the Committee to consider investigating the principle, with First Nations leadership and expert input.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Says that where creative work trains commercial AI systems, creators should have meaningful rights around consent, attribution, licensing and payment.

    I support strong copyright protections for artists and creators. Where creative work is used to train commercial AI systems, creators should have meaningful rights around consent, attribution, licensing and payment.

  2. Argues that copyright protects particular creative works while the cultural inheritance beyond it is much bigger.

    Copyright protects particular creative works and the rights associated with them. Our cultural inheritance is much bigger than that.

  3. States that a Cultural Dividend would not replace copyright, licensing, consent, attribution or direct payment to creators.

    A Cultural Dividend would not replace copyright. It would not replace licensing, consent, attribution or direct payment to creators.

  4. Says any mechanism would need transparent and independent governance, with artists and cultural communities involved in deciding how it worked.

    I would be wary of simply creating another funding pool controlled by a small number of institutions. Any mechanism would need transparent and independent governance, with artists and cultural communities involved in deciding how it worked.

  5. Says the dividend should not put a price on cultural inheritance or the public domain but should value sustaining it.

    The Cultural Dividend should not put a price on our cultural inheritance. It should put a value on sustaining it. The public domain should remain public.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Protect artists’ control over commercial AI training use, including giving or refusing permission where legally required and being paid where appropriate.

    Artists should be able to control how their work is used. Where permission is legally required for commercial use of their work in developing AI, they should be able to give or refuse that permission and, where appropriate, be paid.

    A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  2. If a Cultural Dividend is developed, preserve copyright, licensing, consent, attribution and direct creator payments; do not treat the dividend as satisfying those obligations.

    A Cultural Dividend would not replace copyright. It would not replace licensing, consent, attribution or direct payment to creators.

  3. If a Cultural Dividend is developed, keep cultural inheritance and the public domain free to encounter, learn from and build upon.

    The Cultural Dividend should not put a price on our cultural inheritance. It should put a value on sustaining it. The public domain should remain public. People should remain free to read Shakespeare, look at old paintings, listen to old music, learn languages, explore archives and make new things from what came before them. The Cultural Dividend should not change that.

  4. If a contribution mechanism is developed, exclude mere encounters with cultural material: consider substantial business value, a levy or better alternatives, with relevant experts.

    Nor do I think a company should owe money simply because an AI system has encountered cultural material. The question arises further down the line, when companies build enormously valuable businesses using technologies that have benefited from that inheritance. At that point, perhaps there should be a contribution towards sustaining the cultural ecosystem. I deliberately say perhaps. A levy might be one way of doing it. There may be better mechanisms that I haven't considered. That is something economists, lawyers, artists, cultural organisations, technologists, government and others with the appropriate expertise could work out together.

  5. Consider supporting the wider cultural ecosystem, including libraries, archives, museums, collections, creators and communities maintaining languages, knowledge, traditions and stories.

    I don't think the money should simply go to artists either. Artists make culture, but we don't make or preserve it alone. Libraries and archives preserve it. Museums and public collections care for it. Writers, musicians, filmmakers, designers, performers and others extend it. Communities maintain languages, knowledge, traditions and stories. A Cultural Dividend could help sustain that wider cultural ecosystem and support new creative work that will eventually become part of what future generations inherit.

  6. Require transparent, independent governance of any mechanism, with artists and cultural communities involved in decisions, avoiding control by a small number of institutions.

    I would be wary of simply creating another funding pool controlled by a small number of institutions. Any mechanism would need transparent and independent governance, with artists and cultural communities involved in deciding how it worked.

  7. Respect Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultural rights and develop any Cultural Dividend with First Nations leadership, rather than treating that material as belonging to everybody.

    Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultural knowledge and expression involve questions of custodianship, authority and Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property that conventional copyright does not necessarily capture. Recent Australian commentary by ICIP expert Dr Terri Janke similarly stresses that AI can compromise cultural protocols and authority. [5] CULTURAL DIVIDEND - 4 Any Cultural Dividend would need to respect those rights and be developed with First Nations leadership rather than treating that cultural material as something that simply belongs to everybody.

  8. Consider whether smaller businesses and the largest technology companies should be treated differently, alongside effects on prices, competition, contribution levels, distribution and international operations.

    A contribution might affect prices or competition. Smaller businesses should not necessarily be treated in the same way as the world's largest technology companies. There would be difficult questions about who should contribute, how much, where the money should go and how Australia could act when AI companies operate internationally.

  9. Consider whether cultural inheritance contributes economic value to generative AI not adequately recognised through copyright and licensing alone.

    Whether cultural inheritance contributes economic value to generative AI that is not adequately recognised through copyright and licensing alone.

    A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  10. Consider whether companies deriving substantial commercial value from generative AI should contribute to sustaining Australia’s cultural ecosystem.

    Whether companies deriving substantial commercial value from generative AI should make some form of contribution towards sustaining Australia's cultural ecosystem.

  11. Consider government investigation of a Cultural Dividend or similar mechanism’s economic and legal feasibility with artists, creators, First Nations representatives, cultural organisations, economists, lawyers, technologists and the technology sector.

    Whether the Australian Government should investigate what a Cultural Dividend, or similar mechanism, could look like, including its economic and legal feasibility, with artists and creators, First Nations representatives, cultural organisations, economists, lawyers, technologists and the technology sector involved in that work.

Read the original

In some quotes a program corrected obvious text-recognition errors for display.

Open in the interactive guide