AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 426

Mr Hugh McFarlane

Submitter group: Individuals.

Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

Argues that AI is a generational opportunity and that government choices should spread the AI dividend across Australia and keep part of it in the country. Proposes fiscal and wage measures, multinational tax compliance and a digital services tax review, a managed data centre rollout with community consultation and infrastructure obligations, and sovereign AI in areas of comparative advantage rather than frontier models.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Argues that without deliberate policy, growth from AI will disproportionately go to capital owners rather than workers.

    Put more simply, even if AI augments the productivity of the existing Australian workforce and adds up to $116 billion over ten years to the economy, a disproportionate percentage of that growth will go to wealthier capital owners rather than workers.

    A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  2. Argues that current and future governments should be prepared to proportionally tax any growth in capital income from AI innovation, including by broadening the corporate tax base or raising corporate and capital gains tax rates.

    As such, current and future governments should be prepared to proportionally tax any growth in capital income from AI innovation, including through a broadening of the corporate tax base, or increases to overall corporate and capital gains tax rates.

  3. Argues that if AI substantially lifts productivity without mass layoffs or significantly weakened labour demand, government should encourage public and private sector wage growth.

    The inverse scenario is one where AI innovation creates substantial productivity increases without causing mass layoffs or significantly weakened labour demand.9 In that ‘business as usual’ scenario, government should encourage wage growth in the public and private sectors to ensure labour receives its fair share of the enlarged productivity pie.

  4. Argues that Australia should redouble efforts to prevent multinational tax avoidance, especially on AI-related licences, royalties and fees, and strongly consider a destination-based tax approach to digital services.

    Australia should therefore redouble efforts to prevent multinational tax avoidance, especially where AI-related licenses, royalties and other fees are concerned. We should also strongly consider a destination-based tax approach to digital services.

  5. Argues that a managed and coordinated data centre rollout would help Australia move away from the price-taker dynamic and negotiate with frontier AI firms on a more even basis.

    A managed and coordinated data centre rollout will help Australia move away from the ‘price-taker’ dynamic and enable us to negotiate with frontier AI firms on a more even basis.

  6. Argues that Australia should not attempt sovereign frontier AI and should focus sovereign effort on specific use cases in areas of comparative advantage.

    We will be most successful when we focus our limited resources to develop AI tools with specific use cases, in areas of comparative advantage. We should not make the mistake of attempting to develop sovereign frontier AI, which would require compute and capital stocks orders of magnitude greater than what is available in Australia.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Be prepared to proportionally tax growth in capital income from AI, including by broadening the corporate tax base or raising corporate and capital gains tax rates.

    current and future governments should be prepared to proportionally tax any growth in capital income from AI innovation, including through a broadening of the corporate tax base, or increases to overall corporate and capital gains tax rates.

  2. If AI substantially increases productivity without mass layoffs or significantly weakened labour demand, encourage public and private sector wage growth so labour shares in productivity gains.

    The inverse scenario is one where AI innovation creates substantial productivity increases without causing mass layoffs or significantly weakened labour demand.9 In that ‘business as usual’ scenario, government should encourage wage growth in the public and private sectors to ensure labour receives its fair share of the enlarged productivity pie.

  3. In that productivity-growth scenario, consider adopting a four-day week, especially if modelling shows AI-led wage growth likely to trigger a wage spiral.

    The inverse scenario is one where AI innovation creates substantial productivity increases without causing mass layoffs or significantly weakened labour demand.9 In that ‘business as usual’ scenario, government should encourage wage growth in the public and private sectors to ensure labour receives its fair share of the enlarged productivity pie. Alternatively, Australia could adopt the four-day work week, especially if modelling showed AI-led wage growth was likely to trigger a wage spiral.

  4. Redouble efforts to prevent multinational tax avoidance, especially on AI-related licences, royalties and other fees.

    Australia should therefore redouble efforts to prevent multinational tax avoidance, especially where AI-related licenses, royalties and other fees are concerned.

  5. Strongly consider a destination-based tax approach to digital services.

    We should also strongly consider a destination-based tax approach to digital services.

  6. Commission an independent review into the feasibility of a digital services tax, which would remain in place pending widespread international adoption of Pillar 1.

    the Australian Government should commission an independent review into the feasibility of a digital services tax (DST), which would remain in place pending widespread international adoption of Pillar 1.

  7. Require data centre investors to fund wraparound infrastructure: renewable generation at least matching consumption, grid connectivity, low-impact cooling and new water infrastructure where necessary, alongside adequate community consultation.

    We can make deliberate choices to ensure data centres are built correctly and deployed with adequate community consultation. This includes requiring investors to pay for the necessary wraparound infrastructure. The amount of investment capital pouring into data centres is clear evidence that investors have the funds to cover this additional infrastructure, including renewable energy generation to contribute at least as much power to the grid as consumed, as well as grid connectivity, low-impact cooling systems and new water infrastructure where necessary.

  8. Also consider noise pollution, traffic management and risks to the housing sector from increased construction costs in data centre planning.

    governments should also consider noise pollution, traffic management and risks posed to the housing sector by increased construction costs, which could drive wealth inequality if it triggers a surge in property prices.

  9. Avoid handing frontier AI firms and jurisdictions decisive influence over critical infrastructure.

    Finally, we should be careful to avoid handing frontier AI firms and jurisdictions decisive influence over our critical infrastructure, which would undermine efforts to increase our leverage through data centres.

  10. Develop sovereign AI for specific use cases in areas of comparative advantage: agriculture, resources, health and medical research, advanced manufacturing, financial services and defence, through public and private sector effort.

    Significant effort should be made across the private and public sectors to develop sovereign AI capabilities in specific areas where Australia has a comparative advantage, such as agriculture, resources, health and medical research, advanced manufacturing, financial services and the defence industry.

  11. Work to reduce government reliance on foreign vendors for public sector AI solutions.

    Governments should also work to reduce their reliance on foreign vendors to deliver public sector AI solutions.

  12. Focus limited resources on AI tools for specific use cases in areas of comparative advantage; do not attempt sovereign frontier AI.

    We will be most successful when we focus our limited resources to develop AI tools with specific use cases, in areas of comparative advantage. We should not make the mistake of attempting to develop sovereign frontier AI, which would require compute and capital stocks orders of magnitude greater than what is available in Australia.

Read the original

In some quotes a program corrected obvious text-recognition errors for display.

Open in the interactive guide