AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 436

Ms Heidi James

Submitter group: Individuals.

Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

A personal submission expressing concern about the pace of AI adoption, its effects on living standards, jobs, regional communities and the environment through data centre demand, and catastrophic AI risk. Asks the Committee to hear expert evidence, pause data centre approvals, require renewable energy, pursue an international frontier AI agreement and strengthen copyright law.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Says it has not been adequately explained how AI will improve the living standards of ordinary Australians.

    It has not been adequately explained how AI will improve the living standards of ordinary Australians. Much of the public discussion focuses on the extraordinary wealth being accumulated by the CEOs and founders of major AI companies, rather than on measurable improvements to the lives of Australian families.

  2. States that the submitter is already seeing people lose work to automation and argues that job losses do not constitute an improvement in living standards.

    I am already seeing people lose work to automation, and we are only at the beginning of this transformation. Job losses mean loss of income, security, wellbeing and a sense of purpose and value. These outcomes do not constitute an improvement in living standards.

  3. Argues there is a risk that data centres become an extractive industry that places pressure on local water, electricity and communities while profits go to investors.

    There is a real risk that data centres become a new form of extractive industry: profitable to investors while consuming significant amounts of local water and electricity and placing additional pressure on communities and the environment.

  4. Argues that Commonwealth AI use must meet strong transparency, privacy, security and accountability requirements, particularly for foreign-developed models.

    The adoption of AI by Commonwealth departments and agencies must be subject to strong transparency, privacy, security and accountability requirements, particularly where systems are based on foreign-developed models and datasets.

  5. Argues that Australian creative and intellectual work needs strong protection against unauthorised use for AI training.

    AI companies have benefited enormously from the work of writers, artists, scientists, researchers, musicians and other creators, including Australian cultural and creative workers. There must be strong protections against the unauthorised use of Australian intellectual and creative work to train AI systems.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Hear independent evidence on catastrophic/systemic AI risks, including AI-enabled biological and cyber capabilities and potential loss of control, and explicitly address them in the report.

    That the Committee hear directly from independent experts on catastrophic and systemic AI risks, including AI-enabled biological and cyber capabilities and potential loss of control, and address these risks explicitly in its report.

  2. Pause new data centre approvals pending an independent assessment of location, planning processes, energy and water needs, and impacts on communities, infrastructure and the environment.

    That approvals for new data centres be paused pending an independent assessment of their location, planning processes, energy and water requirements, and impacts on communities, infrastructure and the environment.

  3. Hear directly from community groups, local councils, citizens and independent experts about data centre concerns.

    The Committee should hear directly from community groups, local councils, citizens and independent experts about these concerns.

  4. Require new data centres to demonstrate additional, reliable renewable generation without increasing reliance on coal and gas.

    That new data centres be required to demonstrate access to additional, reliable renewable energy generation and not increase Australia's reliance on coal and gas.

  5. Advocate for an international agreement to independently verify, monitor and appropriately pace frontier AI development, with meaningful verification, safeguards and enforcement mechanisms, not merely voluntary commitments.

    That Australia advocate for an international agreement to independently verify, monitor and appropriately pace the development of frontier AI systems. Any agreement must include meaningful verification, safeguards and enforcement mechanisms, not merely voluntary commitments.

  6. Strengthen Australian copyright/IP laws to protect intellectual, cultural and creative work, requiring consent, attribution and fair compensation for use in training or developing commercial AI systems.

    That Australian copyright and intellectual property laws be strengthened to protect Australian intellectual, cultural and creative work, including requirements for consent, attribution and fair compensation where such work is used to train or develop commercial AI systems.

  7. Governments should slow down, consult widely and establish appropriate safeguards on AI.

    This concern is not limited to the public. Recent reporting has highlighted growing unease about the pace of AI development even among senior industry figures. This should reinforce the need for governments to slow down, consult widely and establish appropriate safeguards.

  8. Subject Commonwealth AI adoption to strong transparency, privacy, security and accountability requirements, particularly where systems rely on foreign-developed models and datasets.

    The adoption of AI by Commonwealth departments and agencies must be subject to strong transparency, privacy, security and accountability requirements, particularly where systems are based on foreign-developed models and datasets.

  9. Keep sensitive health, employment, financial and personal information protected under Australian law and democratic oversight.

    Australians should have confidence that sensitive information—including health, employment, financial and personal data—is protected and remains subject to Australian laws and democratic oversight.

  10. Have government clearly explain what information is provided to foreign companies, how it is used, where it is stored and what safeguards apply.

    Government must clearly explain what information is being provided to foreign companies, how it is being used, where it is stored and what safeguards apply.

  11. Hold a genuine public conversation on what AI should do, trade-offs, beneficiaries and limits.

    Australians deserve a genuine public conversation about what we want AI to do, what we are prepared to give up, who should benefit, and what limits must apply.

  12. Prioritise Australian sovereignty, democratic accountability, environmental sustainability, privacy, employment, cultural/intellectual property and community wellbeing in AI policy.

    AI policy must prioritise Australian sovereignty, democratic accountability, environmental sustainability, privacy, employment, cultural and intellectual property, and the wellbeing of communities.

  13. Give Australians a meaningful voice in deciding the AI future rather than requiring acceptance of AI as inevitable.

    We should not be required simply to accept AI as inevitable. Australians should have a meaningful voice in deciding what future we are building.

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide