AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 437

Ms Joanna Giannone

Submitter group: Individuals.

Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

Argues from a parent's perspective that Australia should pursue AI's benefits but that policy should also account for lost entry-level opportunities and human economic consequences, not only productivity. Proposes an Ethical AI Employment and Workforce Framework including workforce impact measurement, a cost ledger, procurement assessments, transition protections, education monitoring and resilience requirements.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Says they are not asking Parliament to stop AI but to ensure people are protected as well as technology.

    I am not asking Parliament to stop AI. I am asking Parliament to make sure we do not wake up in five years and discover that we protected technology better than we protected people.

  2. Argues that employment statistics should capture jobs never created because technology performs the work, as well as redundancies.

    A job that disappears through redundancy is visible. A job that is never created because technology can perform it is invisible. Australia's employment statistics must be capable of measuring both.

  3. Argues that entry-level work is the first rung of a career ladder and that AI performing it could weaken the pipeline of experienced workers.

    For many young Australians, entry-level work is not simply a wage. It is the first rung of a career ladder. If AI performs the routine work through which young people historically developed judgement, communication, problem-solving and professional confidence, organisations may improve short-term productivity while weakening the pipeline of experienced people they will need later.

  4. Asks Parliament to require organisations to account for human consequences when material technology changes human work.

    I am asking Parliament to establish a minimum national expectation that when material technology changes human work, organisations account for the human consequences as part of the decision.

  5. Argues that companies should disclose the full economics of significant AI deployments rather than compare AI prices only with avoidable wages.

    Companies should disclose the full economics of significant AI deployments. A business case should not compare the price of AI only with the wages that can be avoided.

  6. Argues that AI safety should include whether the transition to AI is safe for workers and society.

    But AI safety should not be defined only as whether an AI system behaves safely. It must also encompass whether the transition to AI remains safe for the people, workforce and society that AI is intended to serve.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Measure workforce change now, before obvious redundancies, including reduced recruitment, fewer hours, unfilled vacancies, eliminated tasks, redesigned roles and disappearing entry-level opportunities.

    That is precisely why action is needed now. We should not wait until redundancies become obvious before measuring the earlier stages of workforce change: reduced recruitment, fewer hours, non-replacement of vacancies, elimination of tasks, redesign of roles and the disappearance of entry-level opportunities.

  2. Make Australia's employment statistics capable of measuring both jobs lost through redundancy and jobs never created because technology performs the work.

    A job that disappears through redundancy is visible. A job that is never created because technology can perform it is invisible. Australia's employment statistics must be capable of measuring both.

  3. Preserve pathways into employment through which young people learn to apply AI, rather than only teaching them to use it at school or university.

    We need to preserve pathways into employment through which young people learn to apply AI - not simply teach them to use it while they are at school or university.

  4. Establish an Australian Ethical Employment Principle requiring organisations to account for human consequences when material technology changes human work, while allowing responsible automation.

    4. Establish an Australian Ethical Employment Principle I am not asking Parliament to protect every existing job forever or to prevent responsible automation. I am asking Parliament to establish a minimum national expectation that when material technology changes human work, organisations account for the human consequences as part of the decision.

  5. Assess human earning, learning, progression and judgement; effects on families, communities, mobility, regions, generations and trust; and productivity, quality, innovation, competitiveness and who benefits.

    5. Measure HUMAN + SOCIETY + ECONOMY • HUMAN: Can people still earn, learn, progress and exercise meaningful judgement? What happens to displaced workers and people entering the workforce? • SOCIETY: What happens to families, communities, social mobility, regional economies, intergenerational opportunity and trust? • ECONOMY: What productivity, quality, innovation and competitiveness benefits are created - and who receives them?

  6. Require workforce-impact measurement beginning with pre-deployment employment baselines and what AI, automation or robotics performs, including task augmentation or removal, expected financial benefits and workforce effects.

    6. Require companies to measure the full workforce impact • Employment baseline - Headcount, hours, vacancies, recruitment, entry-level positions, apprenticeships, graduate roles and tasks before deployment. • Technology intervention - What the AI, automation or robotics system performs; whether it augments, reduces or removes human tasks; expected financial benefits; and expected workforce effects.

  7. Measure roles, hours and entry pathways reasonably expected with and without deployment, plus training, mentoring, junior experience, progression, judgement, critical thinking and professional capability.

    • Employment Opportunity Counterfactual - What roles, hours and entry pathways would reasonably exist without the technology compared with what is expected to exist after deployment, (e.g., An assessment of what human-centric workforce growth would look like if the technology were not deployed). • Experience and capability impact -Training, mentoring, junior exposure to real work, progression pathways and effects on judgement, critical thinking and professional capability.

  8. Measure actual post-deployment employment, hours, recruitment, wages, redeployment, redundancies, contractor use, productivity and role changes, plus retraining, redeployment and transition costs shifted to workers, families or government.

    • Actual outcomes- Headcount, hours, recruitment, wages, redeployment, redundancies, contractor use, productivity and role changes after implementation. • Human transition cost - Retraining, redeployment, transition support and other costs shifted from the organisation to workers, families or government.

  9. Include AI dependency and resilience in workforce-impact measurement: human-readable knowledge, data portability, recovery, human override and operation without a model, vendor or agent.

    • AI dependency and resilience - Human-readable knowledge retention, data portability, recovery capability, human override and ability to operate if a model, vendor or agent becomes unavailable.

  10. Require companies to disclose the full economics of significant AI deployments through a Human Impact Cost Ledger comparing AI costs with labour savings and transition costs.

    Companies should disclose the full economics of significant AI deployments. A business case should not compare the price of AI only with the wages that can be avoided. A Human Impact Cost Ledger should compare model or token costs, computing, integration, monitoring, errors, rework and vendor dependency with labour savings and the cost of transition, retraining, redundancy and lost workforce capability.

  11. Require material procurement to include a Human & Society Technology Impact Assessment covering workforce impact, entry-level pathways, training, knowledge, resilience, privacy, security, transition planning and post-implementation outcomes.

    Material procurement should require a Human & Society Technology Impact Assessment covering workforce impact, entry-level pathways, training, organisational knowledge, resilience, privacy, security, transition planning and measurable post-implementation outcomes.

  12. Examine how ISO/IEC 42001 and ISO/IEC 42005 can be incorporated into a practical national procurement and reporting framework.

    ISO/IEC 42001 provides an AI management-system framework and ISO/IEC 42005:2025 provides guidance for assessing impacts of AI systems on individuals, groups and society. Australia should examine how these standards can be incorporated into a practical national procurement and reporting framework.

  13. Consider applying equivalent disclosure expectations to large private organisations whose technology deployments materially affect employment.

    Government should also consider applying equivalent disclosure expectations to large private organisations whose technology deployments materially affect employment.

  14. Commission independent employment-law, industrial-relations, human-rights and economic advice on permanent displacement through AI, automation or robotics, considering enhanced payments, redeployment, retraining, portable benefits and longer-term transition obligations.

    Government should commission independent employment-law, industrial-relations, human-rights and economic advice on whether transition protections remain adequate where an employer permanently removes roles through AI, automation or robotics. The review should consider enhanced transition payments, redeployment obligations, retraining, portable benefits and other mechanisms that recognise that the benefit of the technology may accrue over many years while the worker bears the immediate loss of income.

  15. Establish a Future Workforce and Education Monitor linking technology adoption, occupational change, graduate outcomes, entry-level opportunities and education planning.

    Government should establish a Future Workforce and Education Monitor linking technology adoption, occupational change, graduate outcomes, entry-level opportunities and education planning.

  16. Where a verified technology shock materially changes a qualification's employment prospects, examine targeted HELP protections, transition pathways and remedies to ensure informed choices, without guaranteeing every graduate a job.

    Where a verified technology shock materially changes the employment prospects associated with a qualification, Government should examine targeted HELP protections, transition pathways and other remedies. The objective is not to guarantee a job to every graduate; it is to ensure that young Australians are not encouraged into pathways without adequate information about rapidly changing occupational demand.

  17. Establish minimum resilience requirements for critical organisations: human-readable knowledge retention, independent records, data portability, tested recovery, meaningful human override and ability to operate without a particular AI provider.

    Government should establish minimum resilience requirements for critical organisations: human-readable knowledge retention, independent records, data portability, tested recovery procedures, meaningful human override and the ability to continue essential operations without a particular AI provider.

  18. Examine priority rules for situations where commercial AI workloads compete with emergency services or critical infrastructure for scarce resources, with human safety and essential services taking precedence.

    Government should also examine priority rules for situations where commercial AI workloads compete with emergency services or critical infrastructure for scarce computing, communications, energy, logistics or other resources. Human safety and essential services must take precedence.

  19. Define AI safety to include whether the transition to AI remains safe for the people, workforce and society it is intended to serve, not only whether an AI system behaves safely.

    But AI safety should not be defined only as whether an AI system behaves safely. It must also encompass whether the transition to AI remains safe for the people, workforce and society that AI is intended to serve.

  20. Establish an Ethical AI Employment & Workforce Framework, applied progressively as AI, automation and robotics develop, as guardrails balancing technology benefits against impacts on people, employment, education and resilience.

    I propose that Australia establish an Ethical AI Employment & Workforce Framework - a practical governance framework that can be applied progressively as AI, automation and robotics develop. The framework should not prevent responsible innovation. It should establish guardrails so that the benefits of technology are balanced against its impact on people, employment, education, organisational resilience and society.

  21. Require material AI investment and procurement decisions to account for technology costs and human transition costs.

    4. Human Impact Cost Ledger Require material AI investment and procurement decisions to account for technology costs and human transition costs.

  22. Track junior, graduate, apprenticeship and early-career opportunities through a Future Workforce & Experience Gap Monitor to identify lost career ladders.

    6. Future Workforce & Experience Gap Monitor Track junior, graduate, apprenticeship and early-career opportunities and identify where the traditional career ladder is being removed.

  23. Establish priority rules where commercial AI activity could compete with emergency services or critical infrastructure.

    9. Critical-Service AI Priority Rules Establish rules for circumstances where commercial AI activity could compete with emergency services or critical infrastructure.

  24. Require material workforce-impact claims to be independently verified and predicted outcomes compared with actual outcomes.

    Require material workforce-impact claims to be independently verified and predicted outcomes compared with actual outcomes.

  25. Establish an implementation timetable and regular review mechanism so governance evolves at the pace of the technology.

    Establish an implementation timetable and regular review mechanism so governance evolves at the pace of the technology.

  26. Recognise that current workers and future workers are both affected.

    I am asking the Committee to recognise that current workers and future workers are both affected.

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide