Submission 444
Mr Colin Cassidy
Submitter group: Individuals.
Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
A professional voice actor describes unauthorised cloning and monetisation of their voice and proposes FAIRGO: layered copyright, an inalienable biometric right limited to digital replication, collective AI licensing and market-access obligations for major platforms. Recommends consent safeguards, Australian governance, platform funding, lighter obligations for smaller entities and genuine research, and staged implementation.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues copyright reform alone cannot protect performers because copyright protects works rather than people, and cloning a voice from public recordings may infringe no copyright.
But copyright reform alone will not protect performers, because copyright protects works, not people. A voice clone built by listening to my publicly available recordings may infringe no copyright at all.
Argues that, now that cloning is possible, standard contracts assigning all rights in a recording operate as a transfer of the performer's biometric identity.
When a recorded performance can be used to reconstruct the performer - their voice print, face and movement - an assignment of all rights in the work operates, by default, as a transfer of the performer's biometric identity itself.
Argues that eight gaps in Australian law, industry practice and international standards make the present situation possible.
Eight gaps in Australian law, industry practice and international standards make the present situation possible. They are set out here in the order the proposed scheme resolves them.
Proposes FAIRGO as a statutory scheme using existing copyright institutions rather than a new agency, in line with the Government's decision against a dedicated AI Act.
FAIRGO is proposed not as a new federal agency but as a statutory scheme delivered through Australia's existing, proven copyright institutions. This respects the Government's December 2025 decision against a dedicated AI Act and a new AI regulator in favour of uplifting existing technology-neutral laws.
Argues that models trained on properly licensed Australian content have clean provenance and a defensible legal basis, and that provenance is becoming a commercial asset.
A model trained on properly licensed Australian voices, faces, screen content and text is a model with clean provenance and a defensible legal basis. In a global market moving towards transparency obligations, provenance is becoming a commercial asset rather than a compliance cost.
Argues copyright and fraud, scam, deepfake and vulnerable-person safety risks share a root cause: no verified, enforceable link between synthetic human voices/faces and the people replicated.
The risks the Committee is examining - fraud, scams, deepfakes and the safety of vulnerable Australians - share a single root cause with the copyright question: there is currently no verified, enforceable link between a synthetic human voice or face and the real person it replicates.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Define in the Copyright Act the constituent layers of a work (concept, script, composition, sound effects, performances, visual content, recording) so rights in each can be held and licensed separately.
Define in the Copyright Act 1968 the constituent layers of a work - concept, script, composition, sound effects, performances, visual content and the recording itself - so that the rights in each layer can be identified, held, licensed or assigned separately.
Create an inalienable biometric right covering voice, face, distinctive likeness, biomechanical movement and DNA/genome data: defined-use licensing only, never assignment/waiver; digital replication only, leaving the 2002 human-cloning prohibition unchanged.
Create a new statutory right in a person's biometric identity - voice, face, distinctive likeness, biomechanical movement traits, and DNA and genome data - that is inalienable: licensable for defined uses, but never assignable or waivable. This right governs digital replication only and does not disturb the Prohibition of Human Cloning for Reproduction Act 2002.
Require non-waivable biometric-licence consent: free, specific, informed, time-limited, revocable at any time, independently advised and personal, with underlying identity never assignable.
Legislate a non-waivable consent floor for biometric licences, drawn from emerging international practice: free, specific and informed; time-limited; revocable at any time; independently advised; and personal, with the underlying identity never assignable.
Distinguish in statute at least three tiers of consent for AI ingestion (training and digital replica, production processing, dubbing and translation), so consent to one use is not consent to all.
Distinguish in statute at least three tiers of consent for AI ingestion - training and digital replica, production processing, and dubbing and translation - so that consent to one use is never treated as consent to all.
Void blanket performer moral-rights waivers, restore non-excludable attribution, and clarify copyright assignment gives no right to mine recordings to replicate contributors’ biometric identities.
Render blanket moral rights waivers in performer contracts void, restoring attribution as a non-excludable right, and clarify by statute that assignment of copyright in a recorded work conveys no right to mine that work in order to replicate a contributor's biometric identity.
Mandate interoperable ISCC, C2PA, ISO/IEC 24745:2022 and ISO/IEC 30107 standards for identification, provenance and biometric protection; establish an Authorised Digital Replica Register and free internationally interoperable consent register.
Require platforms operating in Australia to implement and interoperate with recognised international standards - ISO 24138:2024 (ISCC) for content identification, C2PA Content Credentials for provenance, ISO/IEC 24745:2022 and the ISO/IEC 30107 series for biometric protection - and establish an Authorised Digital Replica Register alongside a free consent register interoperable with international registries.
Establish collective AI-training/output licensing through declared societies, with member/union rate consultation and Copyright Tribunal rates; declare an AWGACS-model Performers’ Society of Australia for performance and biometric layers.
Establish a statutory collective licensing scheme for AI training and output uses, administered by the existing declared collecting societies with rates set in consultation with members and unions and held by the Copyright Tribunal, and declare a new Performers' Society of Australia on the AWGACS model to cover the performance and biometric layers, which no existing society represents.
Support enactment of standalone Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property legislation, administered by a First Nations-controlled body.
Support the enactment of standalone Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property legislation, administered by a First Nations-controlled body, to protect communally held material that copyright cannot reach.
Require infringers to act, with regulator complaints/enforcement, standing evidence, agency escalation partnerships and copyright small claims to avoid placing enforcement burdens on victims.
Where infringement occurs, the law must compel the infringer to act, rather than loading the financial and procedural burden onto the person infringed against. A complaints and enforcement function attached to the regulator, standing evidence and escalation partnerships with the agencies best placed to assist, and a copyright small claims jurisdiction would ensure that no Australian is passed from body to body, over months, without a pathway to enforcement.
Condition major-platform market access on training-data transparency and records, a mandatory Australian representative for service of process, platform-funded independent audits and civil penalties scaled to global turnover.
Make compliance a condition of market access for major AI platforms, including training-data transparency and record-keeping, a mandatory Australian legal representative for service of process, platform-funded independent auditing, and civil penalties scaled to global turnover.
Fund the scheme through licence fees and a major-platform cost-recovery levy, requiring no ongoing taxpayer support after establishment; retain Australian governance and independent audits without privileged platform access to creator data.
The scheme is funded by licence fees and a cost-recovery levy on major AI platforms. No ongoing taxpayer funding is required beyond establishment. Funding confers no control: the shared infrastructure remains Australian-governed and independently audited at all times, and platforms hold no privileged access to the consent, licensing or usage data of Australian creators.
Create a rebuttable presumption of unlicensed use where platforms withhold records; require Australian representatives to receive court orders and answer within set deadlines, with independent audits and deterrent turnover-scaled penalties.
Rather than relying on perfect detection, the scheme shifts the burden of proof onto platforms through duties enforced at the point of market access: training-data transparency records, a rebuttable presumption of unlicensed use where records are withheld, a mandatory Australian legal representative through whom court orders can be served and must be answered within set deadlines, platform-funded independent auditing, and civil penalties scaled to global turnover so that non-compliance is never cheaper than licensing.
Indicatively apply major-platform duties to generative-AI developers/deployers exceeding $10 million annual Australian revenue or one million Australian users; apply lighter obligations to smaller entities and genuine research.
Obligations would apply to any major AI platform - indicatively, an entity developing or deploying generative AI systems with annual Australian-sourced revenue above ten million dollars or more than one million Australian end users. Smaller entities and genuine research uses would face lighter-touch obligations, preserving space for Australian AI startups while capturing the global platforms where the money is.
Pursue mutual recognition of licensing and consent registries with the European Union, the United Kingdom and like-minded jurisdictions.
Australia is well placed to be a jurisdiction where licensed, auditable training data can be sourced with confidence, and should pursue mutual recognition of licensing and consent registries with the European Union, the United Kingdom and like-minded jurisdictions so that Australian creators are paid for offshore use and vice versa.
Require Australian-operating platforms to check and honour verified non-consent declarations; record authorised replica purposes, licensees, territories, expiry, revocation and an auditable chain of title.
A free consent register would allow any Australian to lodge a verified declaration of non-consent to AI replication, interoperable with international registries such as the Human Consent Registry launched in June 2026. Platforms operating in Australia would be required to check and honour it. Its counterpart, the Authorised Digital Replica Register, would record the replicas people have consented to, with permitted purposes, licensees, territories, expiry and revocation status, and an auditable chain of title.
Keep registers from becoming public raw-biometric databases; encrypt and control access to biometric references and, wherever technically possible, use revocable or renewable protected templates.
Neither register would be a public database of raw voiceprints or facial scans: biometric references would be encrypted, access-controlled and, wherever technically possible, held as revocable or renewable protected templates.
Require mandatory, conspicuous labelling of synthetic voices and likenesses in commercial content.
Mandatory, conspicuous labelling of synthetic voices and likenesses in commercial content would follow, consistent with the transparency direction of the EU AI Act and delivered technically by the provenance layer.
Set performance-based standards for approved watermarking and fingerprinting systems competing on robustness, interoperability, security and resistance to removal.
The proposal therefore specifies a performance-based standard, so that approved watermarking and fingerprinting systems compete on robustness, interoperability, security and resistance to removal,
Fund a two-year watermarking/fingerprinting pilot co-designed with MEAA and the Australian Association of Voice Actors and evaluated by the Australian AI Safety Institute before the scheme relies on those systems.
The proposal therefore specifies a performance-based standard, so that approved watermarking and fingerprinting systems compete on robustness, interoperability, security and resistance to removal, with a funded two-year pilot co-designed with the MEAA and the Australian Association of Voice Actors and evaluated by the Australian AI Safety Institute before the scheme relies on any of them.
Begin staged legislation, copyright and biometric reforms, registers/standards specification, society declarations, ICIP support, small-claims design and the watermarking pilot in 2027.
The scheme is designed to be legislated in stages rather than all at once. Phase 1 (2027). Amendments to the Copyright Act establishing the layered definitions, tiered AI ingestion consent categories, strengthened performers' rights and the collective licensing scheme; introduction of the biometric identity right, including digital replica provisions and the voiding of blanket moral rights waivers; specification of the Authorised Digital Replica Register and the performance-based watermarking standard; declaration of collecting societies and founding of the Performers' Society of Australia; Government support for standalone ICIP legislation; design of the copyright small claims pathway; commencement of the watermarking pilot.
In 2028, activate internationally interoperable registers, accredit federated participants, commence platform transparency/records duties and complaints/small claims, enable automated policy-based licensing portals and make initial Copyright Tribunal rate determinations.
Phase 2 (2028). Consent register and Authorised Digital Replica Register live and interoperable internationally; accreditation of the first federated participants; transparency and record-keeping duties in force for major platforms; small claims pathway and complaints function operational; rights portal supporting automated, policy-based licensing decisions; first Copyright Tribunal rate determinations.
Implement full conditional-market-access enforcement, statutory review and mutual-recognition pursuit in 2029.
Phase 3 (2029). Full enforcement including conditional market access; statutory review; pursuit of mutual recognition agreements.
Use a creator-majority advisory board with guaranteed creator/performer, society, First Nations, industry and consumer seats; develop OAIC privacy-by-design, tribunal rate review, enforcement merits review and statutory review after three years.
Governance would be anchored by a creator-majority advisory board with guaranteed seats for working creators and performers, collecting societies, First Nations representatives, industry and consumer advocates; privacy-by-design settings developed with the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner, so the scheme tracks works rather than individual Australians; tribunal review of rates, merits review of enforcement decisions, and a statutory review after three years.
Encrypt, access-control and harden consent/biometric registers, portals and exchanges; make participants traceable, auditable and answerable, with clear liability and enforceable consequences for security or trust breaches.
6. Cyber-secure. The registers, portals and data exchanges that carry consent and biometric data must themselves be encrypted, access-controlled and hardened, so that a scheme built to protect identity never becomes a new target. 7. Compliance. Every participant, and above all every platform handling identity and consent data, must be traceable, auditable and answerable, with clear liability and enforceable consequences whenever security or trust is breached.
Provide transparent labelling of AI material across all media to maintain clear boundaries between real and synthetic content.
5. Clear labelling. Transparent labelling of AI material across all media, so that clear boundaries are maintained between what is real and what is not.