Submission 445
Mr David Court
Submitter group: Individuals.
Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
A visual artist describes likely commercial creative job displacement, lost entry-level pathways and reduced trust in images. Recommends mandatory AI-content labelling, provenance metadata, targeted communications regulation, worker rights, opt-in algorithmic feeds and stronger public media and arts institutions. Argues copyright law is unlikely to steer AI effectively, distinguishing fine art's contextual value from commercial images.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Says job displacement in creative industries will likely happen first and fastest in commercial areas, and has already begun.
From my experience and my understanding, the job displacement in creative industries will likely happen in commercial areas first and most quickly, and has already been happening.
Argues that loss of entry-level roles removes the pathway to expertise and seniority for creative workers.
These kind of entry level positions disappearing will mean losing rungs from the ladder of development for creative workers - if the entry level job in photography or animation or visualisation is now being done by AI, what is the pathway to expertise and seniority?
Recommends transparency about AI use and attribution in official outputs, through regulation of media and broadcast platforms or best practice in government outlets and departments.
I would advocate for transparency about uses of AI and attribution in outputs from official channels, whether this is regulation on media organisations, broadcast platforms - traditional or social media - or best practice behaviour from government owned outlets and departments.
Argues that top-level IP law benefits large copyright holders able to litigate, and recommends opt-in algorithmic social media feeds to steer platform incentives.
I think that rather than this kind of top level IP law, which benefits large copyright holders with the resources to litigate - like record labels etc. - proposed regulation around opt-in algorithmic social media feeds is a step in the right direction for using legislation to steer the incentive of these platforms.
Says the biggest impact of AI on the image economy is the possibility that any image could be generated by AI, which affects people's relationship to every image.
The biggest impact of AI on the image economy is the possibility that any image you come across could be GenAI, and this affects your relationship to every image.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Require AI-content labelling and embedded provenance metadata.
Suggest mandatory AI-content labelling (similar to social media disclosure tags) and embedded provenance metadata
Encourage organisational commitments against AI use, or at least disclosure of AI-use policy, in official communications.
Encourage organisational commitments against or at least disclosure of policy for AI use in official communications
Introduce more, specifically targeted regulation of AI use in communications, similar to public broadcast or truth-in-advertising regulation.
I think there clearly needs to be more and specifically targeted regulation about use of AI in communications, similar to public broadcast or truth in advertising regulations.
Ensure AI transparency and attribution in official outputs through media and platform regulation or government best practice, using labels or provenance metadata.
I would advocate for transparency about uses of AI and attribution in outputs from official channels, whether this is regulation on media organisations, broadcast platforms - traditional or social media - or best practice behaviour from government owned outlets and departments. This could be tags on digital content put out similar to an Instagram or tiktok ‘this contains AI generated imagery’ label, or metadata embedded in digital content that contains information about how it was created.
Set best practice for organisations with suggested policies on AI use in official communications and the workplace, such as commitments not to use generated images in communications or marketing.
Best practice for organisations could also be set with suggested policies of how AI is to be used in official communications or in the workplace - ie. statements saying organisations or companies commit to not using generated images in their communication strategies or marketing.
Give workers the right to decline AI tools and AI surveillance integrated into work software, similar to the right to disconnect.
Similar to the ‘right to disconnect’, workers should have the right to not be required to: 1. Use AI tools in their workflow if they don’t want to 2. Be surveilled at work with AI tools integrated into work software
A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.
Support opt-in algorithmic social media feeds as a regulatory lever.
proposed regulation around opt-in algorithmic social media feeds is a step in the right direction for using legislation to steer the incentive of these platforms.
Strengthen reliable, verified sources of truthful images and visual culture, including the ABC, public galleries and museums, with incentives benefiting people.
The solution to this is to strengthen reliable and verified sources of truthful images, institutions that are creators of images and visual culture who have incentives that benefit people rather than platforms or private owners. These operators, things like the ABC, public art galleries and museums, institutions that historically were the source of visual culture, and have been left to fend for themselves while the internet has taken over as our source of visual culture and information.
Support and strengthen trusted public media and arts institutions such as the ABC and SBS, nationally and locally, and art organisations.
To create a culture of strong, reliable and trustworthy visual culture through arts and media, trusted institutions need to be supported and strengthened - this means support for art organisations and media outlets - ABC and SBS nationally and locally
Regulate major private media organisations to create or re-create an environment of trust around them, rather than requiring them to compete with low-quality content in the attention economy.
as well as regulation of major private media organisations to create or re-create an environment of trust around them, rather than letting them be required to compete with slop in the attention economy of the internet.
Provide more support for public institutions, state and national galleries and major arts organisations.
On the Arts side of this strengthening, this means more support for public institutions, state and national galleries and major arts organisations.
Read the original
In some quotes a program corrected obvious text-recognition errors for display.