Submission 446
Mr David Gould
Submitter group: Individuals.
Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
A mathematics teacher and PauseAI Australia volunteer describes educational benefits and assessment challenges from AI, alongside concerns about human purpose and extinction. Recommends a US-China treaty to pause frontier AI, public consent before companies advance, solving alignment before building superintelligence, and public discussion of these issues.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Says that the author's mathematics faculty has adopted a rule of no take-home assessment except where AI use can be managed or detected.
In the mathematics faculty, we have implemented a general rule of having no take-home assessment, except in cases where we think we can manage or easily detect the use of AI.
Says the author appreciates the value AI can bring for everyone, including students, and considers the ACT restriction on student use of AI on school systems not the right way to handle AI.
I appreciate the value that AI can bring for everyone, including my students. It should be noted that currently ACT public school students are not permitted to use artificial intelligence on school systems, which I feel is not the right way to handle AI.
Says the author is afraid, citing scientists and engineers saying that the risk of extinction is real and potentially imminent.
I am afraid. I do not think that the vast majority of people are sufficiently afraid. This is because I pay attention to the fact that scientists and engineers are saying that the risk of extinction is real and potentially imminent.
States that at present the world seems much closer to building superintelligence than to aligning it with human values.
If we do build a superintelligence, we need to ensure that it is aligned to human values. At present, we seem to be a lot closer to the superintelligent part than we are to the aligned part.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Enable ACT public-school students to learn what AI can do so they can make informed decisions, rather than prohibit AI use on school systems.
It should be noted that currently ACT public school students are not permitted to use artificial intelligence on school systems, which I feel is not the right way to handle AI. Students need to learn about what AI can do so that they can make informed decisions.
Committee members, parliament and government should take the extinction threat seriously and act, with concern guided by intellect.
This is because I pay attention to the fact that scientists and engineers are saying that the risk of extinction is real and potentially imminent. I really hope that this committee, the parliament and the government is paying attention also. You need to be more afraid than you appear to be, and that fear -guided by intellect - should help fuel you to take the necessary action.
Pause frontier AI development by starting work on a US-China treaty.
The best solution to the above problems is a pause in frontier AI development. We need to start work on getting a treaty between the United States and China that accomplishes this.
Do not permit AI companies to rush ahead without public consent, allowing time to decide what kind of world to create and how to respond to AI.
we need time to determine what kind of world we want to create and how we need to respond to AI. There are many potential benefits to gain; a golden future is possibly within sight. But we need to ensure that all the things that humans value do not simply disappear because we were not given a say. AI companies should not be permitted to rush ahead without our consent.
Take time to solve the alignment problem, and choose not to build superintelligence if solving it proves impossible.
On the extinction threat, we need time to solve the alignment problem. If we discover that solving it is impossible, we need to choose not to build superintelligence.
Committee members should raise these issues with parliament, government, media and the public.
On both, the members of this committee need to start raising these issues with the parliament, the government, the media and the public.