Submission 468
Mr Harm Ellens
Submitter group: Individuals.
Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
Four members of standards committees, writing in a personal capacity, argue that Australia's sovereign AI capability depends on sustained participation in international AI standards bodies. They propose an Australian AI Standards Fellowship and Support Facility funding 15-25 experts nominated through Standards Australia committees each year, with defined funding, selection, governance and reporting arrangements.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues that Australia's sovereign AI capability and security need sustained, supported Australian participation in international standards committees.
Australia’s sovereign AI capability and security needs sustained and supported Australian participation in the committees and working groups that shape those standards.
States that existing arrangements lack systematic financial support for the individual Australian experts who do the standards work.
Australia already has important standards coordination, AI capability-building and adoption support administered by DISR, Standards Australia and the National AI Centre. The missing element is systematic financial support for individual Australian experts who undertake the substantial preparatory, drafting, consultation, negotiation and follow-up work required to shape the international standards for the benefit of Australia.
Argues that international standards shape the technical and governance expectations organisations must meet to sell, deploy, procure, assure and regulate AI systems.
Standards shape the technical and governance expectations that organisations must meet to sell, deploy, procure, assure and regulate AI systems.
Argues that participation relying on individual goodwill is fragile, key-person dependent and lacks succession planning.
Participation that depends on individual goodwill is fragile. It is key-person dependent. It has no succession planning. It can end abruptly when an expert changes employer, retires or simply runs out of capacity.
States that fellows would act as independent technical experts, with Australian standards positions formed by domestic consultation.
Government funding must not become ‘government voice’. Fellows would participate as independent technical experts through the mirror-committee process, with Australian standards positions formed by domestic consultation as they are now.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Recommend that the Government establish an Australian AI Standards Fellowship and Support Facility, funded by the Office of AI in PM&C and administered by DISR in partnership with Standards Australia and the National AI Centre.
That the Committee include a recommendation in its report that the Australian Government establish an Australian AI Standards Fellowship and Support Facility. That the facility be funded by the Office of AI in the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet, and administered by DISR in partnership with Standards Australia and the National AI Centre
Support 15-25 Australian AI Standards Fellows annually over an initial three-year establishment phase.
support 15–25 Australian AI Standards Fellows annually over an initial three-year establishment phase;
Support international AI standards including SC 42, and AI-adjacent ISO/IEC work on data governance, cybersecurity, information security, privacy, digital identity, safety, resilience, assurance, environmental sustainability, conformity assessment and critical infrastructure.
The Australian AI Standard Fellowship and the Support Facility should support participation in: 1. international standards committees developing AI and related standards, including ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 42 on AI; 2. ISO and IEC committees developing AI-adjacent standards in data governance, cyber security, information security, privacy, digital identity, safety, resilience, assurance, environmental sustainability, conformity assessment and critical infrastructure;
Support sector-specific ISO/IEC work in agriculture, resources, health/medical research, advanced manufacturing, financial services, energy, transport and defence-related supply chains relevant to Australian capability and exports.
sector-specific ISO and IEC committees relevant to Australian capability and export potential, including agriculture, resources, health and medical research, advanced manufacturing, financial services, energy, transport and defence-related supply chains;
Support OECD AI policy, measurement, classification, governance and interoperability work relevant to later standardisation, regulation or procurement.
OECD AI work that influences international policy, measurement, classification, governance and interoperability concepts relevant to subsequent standardisation, regulation or procurement.
Include IEEE in priority AI, AI-adjacent and sector-specific participation alongside ISO, IEC and OECD.
support participation in priority ISO, IEC, IEEE and OECD AI, AI-adjacent and sector-specific work;
Cover the full contribution cycle, including preparation, international participation, technical drafting, domestic consultation, mentoring, dissemination, reporting, specialist analysis and travel.
cover the full contribution cycle, including preparation, international participation, technical drafting, domestic consultation, mentoring, dissemination, reporting and necessary specialist analysis, as well as travel;
Use merit-based selection against national-interest priorities, committee relevance and demonstrated potential and/or capacity for substantive contributions to international AI standards.
use merit-based selection against national-interest priorities, committee relevance and demonstrated potential and/or capacity to make substantive contributions to international standards involving AI;
Direct at least 85% of funding to individual fellows, cap administration at no more than 10% and report it annually, and pay fellows directly rather than through intermediaries.
At least 85% of the facility's funding should flow directly to individual fellows for their time, analysis, travel and consultation work, with administration capped at no more than 10% and reported annually. Payment should be made directly to fellows, not routed through intermediaries, with a focus on priority international AI standards and policy work.
Keep fellows independent through mirror committees and domestic consultation; use Office of AI reporting for non-confidential policy intelligence, without government direction of technical positions.
Government funding must not become ‘government voice’. Fellows would participate as independent technical experts through the mirror-committee process, with Australian standards positions formed by domestic consultation as they are now. Reporting to the Office of AI would be non-confidential intelligence to inform policy, not direction of technical positions.
Limit supported AI-adjacent and sector-specific work to matters with a tangible AI link.
as well as committees relevant to data governance, cyber security, privacy, digital identity, conformity assessment, safety, critical infrastructure, financial services, agriculture, health, resources, environmental sustainability, advanced manufacturing and other areas of Australian comparative AI advantage, insofar as they have a tangible link to AI.
Review the facility's scope annually, with the Office of AI publishing a priority list informed by advice from Standards Australia, the National AI Centre, agencies, regulators, national-security bodies and public advocacy groups.
This scope should be reviewed annually. The Office of AI should publish a priority list informed by advice from Standards Australia, the National AI Centre, relevant agencies, regulators and national-security bodies and public advocacy groups.
Limit eligibility to formally mirror-committee-nominated individuals with a track record of substantive standards contributions.
Eligibility should be limited to individuals formally nominated through a relevant Standards Australia mirror committee with a track record of making substantive contributions to standards development.
Keep nomination, selection and fund-holding as separate functions: Standards Australia nominates and coordinates but neither selects fellows nor holds or disburses funds, and declares any financial interest in program activities.
Nomination, selection and fund-holding should be separate functions. Standards Australia's role is to nominate and coordinate; it should neither select fellows nor hold or disburse fellowship funds, and should declare any financial interest in program activities.
Have the Office of AI convene an independent selection panel including relevant mirror-committee members serving personally.
Applicants should be assessed by an independent selection panel convened by the Office of AI and include members of relevant Standards Australia mirror committees serving in a personal capacity
Assess expertise/contribution capacity, national priorities, committee/work relevance, mirror-endorsed annual plans, national benefits, consultation/reporting/knowledge-transfer/mentoring plans and holistic multi-stakeholder cohort representation.
1. Demonstrated technical expertise and proven capacity to contribute substantively. 2. Alignment with published national-interest and AI standards priorities. 3. Relevance of the nominated international committee or work item. 4. An approved annual contribution plan, endorsed by the relevant mirror committee. 5. Expected benefits for Australian competitiveness, exports, regulatory readiness or risk management. 6. A practical plan for domestic consultation, reporting, knowledge transfer and mentoring. 7. Holistic multi-stakeholder representation amongst the fellowship cohort.
Give the selection panel a non-Commonwealth majority serving personally; publish criteria and appointments/work statements; require active mirror-committee membership at application; recuse applicants and directly interested panel members.
The panel should have a majority of members who are not Commonwealth employees and who serve in a personal capacity, publish its criteria in advance, and publish all appointments with a short statement of the international work each fellow will undertake. Fellows should be active members of the relevant mirror committee at the time of application. Panel members who are themselves applicants, or who have a direct interest in an application, should be recused from relevant assessments.
Make selection merit-based and open to all mirror-committee nominees, giving priority to contributors with no employer support, including from SMEs, academia and consumer, public-interest or government bodies.
Selection should be merit-based and open to all mirror-committee nominees. Priority should be given to contributors who have no employer support, including those from SMEs, academia and consumer, public- interest organisations or government bodies.
Appoint candidates to the highest-priority international issues.
Candidates should be appointed to work on the highest-priority international issues.
Keep eligibility independent of employment status, including personally participating public employees whose agency neither funds nor directs the work, subject to affiliation disclosure and reasonable employer outside-activity requirements.
Eligibility should not depend on employment status. Experts who participate in a personal capacity — including those employed in the public sector where the agency does not fund or direct their standards work — should be eligible on the same terms as any other mirror-committee nominee, subject to disclosure of relevant affiliations and their employer's reasonable outside-activity requirements.
Fund only additional contributions, prioritising unsupported experts; welcome disclosed employer/institution co-funding, require existing same-work support declarations and exclude activity already funded through employment, grants or institutional roles.
Funding should be ‘additional’. It should support contributions that would not otherwise occur, give priority to experts without employer support, and welcome disclosed co-funding from employers or institutions. Applicants should declare any existing support for the same work, and the panel should not fund activity already resourced through employment, research grants or institutional roles.
Cover protected analytical/preparation time; travel, accommodation, participation and document access; domestic stakeholder consultation; international-development briefings; mentoring; and mirror-committee/Office of AI reporting.
Eligible costs should include: 1. Protected time and funding to analyse drafts, prepare technical positions and develop proposed text. 2. Travel, accommodation, meeting participation and document-access costs. 3. Domestic consultation with industry, government, regulators, researchers and relevant stakeholder groups. 4. Briefings on emerging international developments and domestic implications. 5. Mentoring of emerging standards contributors. 6. Reporting to the relevant Standards Australia mirror committee and the Office of AI.
Give each fellow a three-year appointment, renewable subject to annual performance review, committee need and strategic priority, with clear milestones and final acquittal.
Each fellow should have a three-year appointment, renewable subject to annual performance review, continuing committee need and strategic priority. The fellowship should require clear milestones and final acquittal.
Have the Office of AI fund/oversee, set annual priorities, approve funding, coordinate agencies, monitor and report; DISR administers.
The Office of AI should fund and oversee the facility as a national capability program, with DISR administering it. The Office of AI should set annual priorities, approve funding, coordinate agency input, monitor outcomes and report publicly.
Retain Standards Australia nomination/coordination and technical/process advice; have the National AI Centre link Australian capability, adoption and industry networks.
Standards Australia should retain its role in nominating and coordinating Australian experts through national mirror committees. It should advise on committee relevance, participation arrangements, technical standing and alignment with Australia’s standards-development processes. The National AI Centre should assist with links to Australian AI capability, adoption and industry networks.
Have the Office of AI publish a six-month update on governance, eligibility, selection, the first cohort, supported committees, early activities and needed adjustments.
The Office of AI should publish an implementation update six months after establishment, and should report on governance, eligibility, selection criteria, the first fellowship cohort, committees supported, early activities and any adjustments required.
After the first full year, publish a non-confidential annual Priorities and Influence Report identifying supported ISO, IEC, IEEE and OECD priorities.
After the first full year, the Office of AI should publish an annual Australian AI Standards Priorities and Influence Report. It should contain non-confidential information only. It should report: 1. The priority ISO, IEC, IEEE and OECD work supported.
Report fellows/committees, Australian contributions, emerging issues, engagement/knowledge transfer, program measures and next-year priorities; set targets at establishment for contributions, proposals, leadership, consultations/briefings and continuing participation.
2. The number of fellows appointed and details of the committees covered. 3. The types of Australian contributions made. 4. Emerging issues relevant to regulation, procurement, exports, resilience and national capability. 5. Domestic engagement and knowledge-transfer activities. 6. Program measures, with targets set at establishment, including: substantive contributions made; proposals progressed; Australians holding leadership positions (convenor, editor, project leader, liaison officer); consultations or briefings delivered; and the proportion of fellows continuing standards participation. 7. Priority areas for the next year.