AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 476

Ms Jo Grant

Submitter group: Individuals.

Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

Argues that AI’s environmental, cultural and political harms warrant enforceable National AI Standards, a moratorium on further AI uptake except essential security uses, and a data-centre construction moratorium pending investigation. Recommends restrictions on foreign AI companies, renewable-powered data centres, protection for dark skies and action against orbital data centres.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Argues for an immediate moratorium on further AI uptake and data-centre construction, especially foreign-owned LLMs and data centres, pending urgent, thorough governmental review.

    I believe that these harms are both evident and vast enough to warrant an immediate moratorium on the further uptake of AI and building of data centres in Australia – especially foreign-owned and operated Large Language Model AI platforms and data-centres –pending urgent but thorough governmental review

  2. Argues that data centres required for AI are deeply problematic for Australia's environment.

    Secondly, data centres required for AI are deeply problematic for Australia’s environment.

  3. Argues that governments should protect the night sky from devastation by AI companies, and that Australia should outlaw AI companies that have or intend to launch orbital satellites.

    Governments around the world, including in Australia, should protect this treasure at all costs, not tolerate its devastation by AI (and other) companies. Australia should outlaw any AI company who has or intends to launch orbital satellites from any jurisdiction to help avoid these worst outcomes for our night skies.

  4. Argues that large language models are the product of theft, plagiary and cultural destruction, with works taken without consent, compensation or credit.

    Large-Language Model AI in particular are the product of theft, plagiary and cultural destruction. Countless works of writing, art, and cultural products have been stolen without consent, compensation or credit to develop AI (in the process of so-called model “training”) private profit.

  5. Argues that large American AI companies are unaccountable to the Australian public and that their access to politicians and government should be strictly limited and regulated.

    As these American AI companies are unaccountable to the Australian public, their access to politicians and government needs to be strictly limited and regulated.

  6. Argues that governments could misuse AI for surveillance and propaganda and that every legislative effort should be made to prevent this in Australia.

    There is very real potential for governments (in Australia and around the world) to misuse AI for political purposes, such as surveilling, tracking and stifling political opponents, and generating propaganda to consolidate and expand power. Every legislative effort should be made to prevent this outcome in Australia, and to work towards reducing this around the world.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Urgently review American AI companies’ anti-democratic and anti-social behaviour, beneficial AI uses for all Australians, equitable not-for-profit models and mitigation of data-centre harms.

    pending urgent but thorough governmental review towards: 1) investigating the anti-democratic and anti-social behaviour of American AI companies; 2) determining which uses of AI will be beneficial for all Australians; 3) fostering the development of not-for-profit and more equitable and socially useful AI models; and 4) mitigating the significant harms wrought by AI’s hardware in the form of data centres.

  2. Subject AI companies operating in Australia to stringent conditions preventing further harm through contracts with polluting fossil-fuel companies.

    Hence, AI companies that wish to operate in Australia should be subject to stringent conditions to ensure they do not cause Australia and Australians further harm through their contracts with polluting fossil fuel companies.

  3. Deny Australian operating licences to companies generating fossil-fuel pollution anywhere in the world.

    Therefore, companies that generate fossil fuel pollution anywhere in the world should not be given licence to operate in Australia.

  4. Legislate robustly to mitigate AI data centres’ significant water impacts.

    Large AI data centres use significant amounts of water for cooling.8 Water is already scarce in many parts of Australia, which is highly susceptible to frequent and prolonged drought – and will be more so in coming decades under worsening impacts of climate change. Thus, robust legislation will be required to mitigate this significant impact.

  5. Take steps to prevent additional satellite launches worsening night-time light pollution’s impacts on human health, wildlife and ecosystems.

    Night-time light pollution is already diminishing human health, impacting wildlife and ecosystems.13 Thus, steps should be taken to avoid the worsening of these outcomes by the launch of countless more satellites.

  6. Outlaw AI companies that have launched or intend to launch orbital satellites from any jurisdiction, to protect night skies.

    Australia should outlaw any AI company who has or intends to launch orbital satellites from any jurisdiction to help avoid these worst outcomes for our night skies.

  7. Make every legislative effort to prevent government AI misuse for surveillance, repression and propaganda in Australia, and work to reduce it worldwide.

    There is very real potential for governments (in Australia and around the world) to misuse AI for political purposes, such as surveilling, tracking and stifling political opponents, and generating propaganda to consolidate and expand power. Every legislative effort should be made to prevent this outcome in Australia, and to work towards reducing this around the world.

  8. Develop new National AI Standards setting ethical, equitable, democratic, environmentally sustainable, accountable, transparent and non-harmful principles for AI operating in Australia, with limited input from AI tech companies because of conflict of interest.

    Develop new National AI Standards that outline ethical, equitable, democratic, environmentally sustainable, accountable, transparent and non-harmful principles by which AI operating in Australia must meet. The input of AI tech companies in drafting these standards should be limited due to their conflict of interest;

  9. Develop effective mechanisms to enforce the new National Standards.

    Develop effective mechanisms to enforce these new National Standards;

  10. Issue an immediate moratorium on further uptake of AI, except where absolutely essential for national and other forms of security, while the new National Standards are developed.

    Issue an immediate moratorium on the further uptake of AI, except where absolutely essential for national and other forms of security, while new National Standards are developed;

  11. Issue an immediate moratorium on construction of data centres in Australia pending further investigation and regulation.

    Issue an immediate moratorium on the construction of data centres in Australia pending further investigation regulation;

  12. Phase out, followed by outlawing, AI owned and operated by tech companies that have exhibited anti-democratic values and that generate fossil fuel pollution anywhere in the world.

    The phase out followed by outlawing of AI that is owned and operated by tech companies that have exhibited anti-democratic values, and that generate fossil fuel pollution anywhere in the world;

  13. Require data centres in Australia to be powered by renewable energy in perpetuity.

    Data centres in Australia must be powered by renewable energy in perpetuity;

  14. Phase out and cancel government contracts with American AI companies.

    The phase out and cancelling government contracts with American AI companies;

  15. Roll back the use of AI in Australia, subject to rigorous regulation that meets the National Standards.

    Rolling back the use of AI in Australia, subject to rigorous regulation that meets the aforementioned National Standards;

  16. Conduct a thorough review of the political tendencies and behaviours of foreign-owned AI companies.

    Conduct a thorough review of the political tendencies and behaviours of foreign-owned AI companies;

  17. Legislate to limit the access of AI and other lobbyists to politicians.

    Legislate to limit the access of AI and other lobbyists to politicians.

  18. Encourage the development of Australian and not-for-profit AI models.

    Encourage the development of Australian and not-for-profit AI models;

  19. Work with other countries to develop a global treaty on AI and its data centres.

    The Australian Government should work with other countries to develop a global treaty on AI and its data centres;

  20. Recognise dark skies as a national heritage value worthy of conservation.

    The Australian Government should recognise dark skies as a national heritage value worthy of conservation;

  21. Lead a global movement to prevent the deployment of orbital data centres.

    The Australian Government should lead a global movement to prevent the deployment of orbital data centres.

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide