Submission 516
First Nations Digital Inclusion Advisory Group
Submitter group: Government.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
An advisory group to the Minister for Communications describes the impact of AI on First Nations Australians, covering digital inclusion gaps, Indigenous data sovereignty and copyright, harms such as racism, and co-designed opportunities. It recommends costed inclusion measures, stronger protections for First Nations content, embedding First Nations perspectives in government AI instruments, and a First Nations AI governance body.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues that First Nations people without access to affordable, reliable internet will be excluded from the benefits of AI.
if First Nations people do not have access to affordable and reliable internet, they will be excluded from the benefits of AI.
Says that AI model development using First Nations knowledge is eroding cultural control and access, compounded by limited copyright protection for Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property.
As AI companies develop models that harness and utilise First Nations knowledge, cultural control and access to this knowledge is being eroded. This is compounded by the lack of clear protection within existing copyright laws for Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property (ICIP).
Says an opt-out for AI training will not sufficiently protect First Nations artists, producers and creators.
The Advisory Group believes that the institution of an ‘opt-out’ for training will not provide sufficient protection for First Nations artists, producers and creators.
Argues that without First Nations governance over data, digital systems risk privileging non-First Nations worldviews.
Without First Nations governance over data, digital systems risk privileging non-First Nations worldviews as a default, while marginalising First Nations knowledges, lore, values and lived realities.
Says active co-design of AI has shown positive results for First Nations groups, where AI enabled rather than replaced community expertise.
Active co-design of AI systems and the use of community insights has shown positive results for First Nations groups, where AI has worked as an enabler, not a replacement, for human and community expertise.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Establish a clear pathway guaranteeing First Nations cultures can safely and enjoyably benefit from AI.
the Advisory Group recommends that a clear pathway be established to guarantee that First Nations cultures are able to safely and enjoyably benefit from AI.
Make First Nations Australians’ AI connectivity, affordability and digital skills an explicit, costed element of future government AI policy.
We recommend that the elements underpinning First Nations Australians’ ability to use and benefit from AI, including connectivity, affordability and digital skills, are an explicit and costed element of future Government AI policy.
Include openly available long-tail material in AI regulation even where identifying rights holders and arranging voluntary licences is difficult or impossible.
In a modern digital landscape, the Advisory Group believes that it is critical to ensure sufficient protection is provided for all material, including ‘the long tail’ (i.e.material that is openly available online for which striking voluntary deals is unrealistic or impossible). While this long tail of small and individual copyright owners can make identifying and buying licences difficult, this should not preclude its inclusion in regulatory approaches to AI.
Overhaul copyright law and AI policy for all Australians.
The Advisory Group acknowledges that issues of copyright affect all Australian creatives and their works, and we believe that copyright law and AI policy must be overhauled for all Australians.
Consult on First Nations groups’ limited protections and compensation avenues for traditional knowledge and cultural stories, strengthening ICIP protection in line with Closing the Gap Priority Reform 4.
The Advisory Group notes, however, that First Nations cultural groups and individuals, especially those experiencing digital exclusion, have fewer protections and avenues through which to pursue compensation for traditional knowledge or cultural story. It is important that future consultation on INDSG&C covers these broader issues, including stronger protection for ICIP, in line with Priority Reform 4 of the National Agreement on Closing the Gap.
Institute further protections for First Nations content that prioritise the agency of First Nations artists.
the Advisory Group recommends that the Australian government institute further protections for First Nations content that prioritises the agency of First Nations artists.
Consider government-level blacklisting of certain terms or sources for AI scraping, or a central licensing hub where long tail First Nations content may be willingly uploaded in exchange for fair compensation.
This could include government-level blacklisting of certain terms/sources for AI scraping, or the creation of a central licensing hub for First Nations content where long tail content may be willingly uploaded in exchange for fair compensation.
Consider how to embed Indigenous Data Sovereignty, Governance and Copyright in AI policy and regulatory frameworks, including implementing Priority Reform 4 and stronger safeguards for First Nations cultural content.
The Advisory Group recommends the Committee consider how to embed IDSG&C in the policy and regulatory frameworks for AI, including implementing Priority Reform 4 of Closing the Gap and stronger safeguards around First Nations cultural content.
Implement Indigenous data sovereignty, governance and copyright to protect knowledge authority, embedded cultural/ethical/legal frameworks, and oversight and accountability for decisions affecting First Nations peoples.
In response to Sections 1(e),(f), and (g) of the Committee’s Terms of Reference, implementing IDSG&C in this context serves to guarantee: • knowledge sovereignty, including whose knowledge is recognised as authoritative • sovereignty, including which cultural, ethical and legal frameworks are embedded in digital systems • decision-making sovereignty, including who has oversight and accountability when systems affect First Nations peoples.
Consider including core elements of a culturally grounded Data Sharing Agreement in Commonwealth data-sharing or AI-procurement agreements as a practical first step.
A practical first step in achieving this could come from including core elements of a culturally grounded Data Sharing Agreement in Commonwealth data- sharing or AI-procurement agreements.
Treat culturally safe, secure internet access as a key metric of First Nations connectedness as AI adoption grows.
As services and technology are increasingly shifting towards AI adoption, the ability to access the internet in a culturally safe and secure way must be regarded a key metric in understanding how connected First Nations people are.
Deploy AI without further exposing First Nations Australians to online harms, including racism and misinformation, and empower communities to shape their narratives.
The Advisory Group would like to emphasise that deployment of AI services must be done in a way which does not further expose First Nations Australians to online harms, such as racism and misinformation, and which empower them to shape the narratives that affect their communities.
Deem AI deployment in settings likely to affect First Nations Australians inherently 'high risk'.
deployment of AI in settings where there is a likelihood of impact on First Nations Australians should be deemed inherently ‘high risk’.
Ensure increasingly AI-run online moderation operates properly and in a culturally appropriate way to prevent further harm.
As online moderation shifts to increasingly AI-run systems, it is imperative that these systems operate properly and in a culturally appropriate way to prevent further harm.
Embed First Nations perspectives into existing government instruments: the mandatory Framework for Governance of Indigenous Data, the Guidance for AI Adoption, the AI Safety Institute, the National AI Centre and Closing the Gap's intergovernmental architecture.
the Advisory Group recommends that First Nations perspectives be embedded into instruments Government has already built or funded, including the mandatory Framework for Governance of Indigenous Data, the new Guidance for AI Adoption, the AI Safety Institute, the National AI Centre, and Closing the Gap's own intergovernmental architecture.
Inform government AI use through genuine engagement with affected First Nations communities, Closing the Gap and data-sovereignty alignment, accountability and justice, and authentic co-design purpose-built for empowerment, research and innovation.
The Advisory Group also recommends that the the use of AI systems by governments is informed by: • genuine engagement with impacted First Nations communities, • alignment with Closing the Gap reforms and data sovereignty principles, • accountability and justice for First Nations people • authentic co-design, purpose-built to drive empowerment, research and innovation.
Implement a nationally recognised First Nations AI governance body to guide governments in implementing First Nations-owned, domain-specific language and cultural-data models under IDSG&C principles.
we similarly recommend that Australia implement a nationally recognised First Nations AI governance body to guide governments in implementing First Nations-owned, domain-specific language and cultural-data models, built and governed under IDSG&C principles.