Submission 523
Australian Retail Council (ARC)
Submitter group: Industry bodies.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
The Australian Retail Council argues that effective AI adoption is a national productivity priority and that retail can demonstrate its benefits. It describes uneven retail adoption, barriers, effects on retail work and agentic commerce, and recommends a retail coordination forum, grants to industry associations, training (including its Retail Institute) and applying existing law rather than additional AI-specific regulation.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
ARC argues that weak productivity performance makes effective AI adoption a national economic priority, and that retail can make a significant contribution as a major employer and point of contact with new technologies.
Australia’s weak productivity performance and stalled living standards make the effective adoption of AI a national economic priority. Retail can make a significant contribution to the success of the AI opportunity as the industry is both a major employer and a daily point of contact between Australians and new technologies.
ARC's survey found that although most respondents regard AI as important to their strategy, few have embedded it in core business processes.
Although 53 per cent of ARC survey respondents regard AI as critical or important to their future strategy, just 6 per cent have embedded it in core business processes.
In ARC's survey, skills gaps (52%) and difficulty identifying use cases and integrating with existing systems (46% each) were the most commonly cited barriers to AI adoption.
Skills and expertise gaps were identified by 52 per cent of ARC survey respondents as limiting AI adoption in their business. Difficulty identifying worthwhile use cases and integration with existing systems were each nominated by 46 per cent.
ARC states that current evidence does not indicate widespread AI-related job losses in retail, though tasks within some roles will change.
Current evidence does not indicate widespread job losses in retail attributable to AI, although the tasks within some roles will change.
Says AI-specific regulation should be a last resort, only where existing frameworks cannot be sufficiently adapted and technology-neutral regulation cannot adequately address the risk.
ARC also supports its recommendation that AI-specific regulation should be a last resort, considered only where existing frameworks cannot be sufficiently adapted and technology-neutral regulation cannot adequately address the risk.
ARC says responsibility in agentic commerce should reflect what each party operates, authorises and controls.
Responsibility should reflect what each party operates, authorises, and controls. A retailer deploying an agent within its own systems needs to manage its access to information and transaction functions, record its actions, and be able to withdraw that access.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Provide regulator guidance using common retail scenarios to help businesses apply existing privacy, consumer, intellectual-property and cybersecurity obligations consistently.
Practical guidance from relevant regulators, using common retail scenarios, would help businesses apply existing privacy, consumer, intellectual- property, and cybersecurity obligations consistently.
Require any proposal for further AI regulation to identify a specific harm and explain why existing law, enforcement or guidance cannot adequately address it.
Any proposal for further regulation should identify a specific harm and explain why existing law, enforcement or guidance cannot adequately address it.
Have Government and ministers champion responsible AI with evidence of service, safety and productivity benefits, investment needs, risk responses, privacy protections, human oversight and accountability.
The Australian Government should be a clear and consistent public advocate for the responsible AI adoption. Ministers should explain the improvements businesses and workers are achieving, the investment needed to extend them and how risks are being addressed. With public confidence remaining low, government should present practical evidence of applications that improve customer service, make work safer and help businesses become more productive. It should also explain the privacy protections, human oversight, and accountability that make those applications trustworthy.
Have the Office of AI publish an adoption-and-investment implementation agenda assigning responsibility and reporting progress, using measured outcomes and industry case studies while protecting commercially sensitive information.
The Office of AI should publish an implementation agenda that identifies barriers to adoption and investment, allocates responsibility for addressing them and reports on progress. Its reporting should draw on measured outcomes and practical industry case studies while protecting commercially sensitive information.
Recognise retail as a major channel for productivity, safety and customer-service improvements.
Retail should be recognised as a major industry through which improvements in productivity, safety and customer service can reach Australians.
Engage constructively with technology providers, investors, researchers and businesses adopting AI.
Government should engage constructively with technology providers, investors, researchers and businesses adopting AI.
Have Government, working with DISR and states and territories, provide timely, predictable decisions on AI infrastructure proposals meeting published energy, water, security and community-impact requirements.
Government should engage constructively with technology providers, investors, researchers and businesses adopting AI. Working with the Department of Industry, Science and Resources and state and territory governments, it should provide timely and predictable decisions on AI infrastructure proposals that meet its published requirements on energy, water, security and community impacts.
Use public statements and regulatory decisions to give businesses and workers confidence that responsible innovation is welcome in Australia.
Its public statements and regulatory decisions should give businesses and workers confidence that responsible innovation is welcome in Australia.
Establish a standing Retail Economy Coordination Forum with relevant Commonwealth agencies, a lead minister and officials; identify cross-portfolio issues, coordinate responses, escalate unresolved barriers and prioritise AI adoption and productivity.
The Australian Government should establish a standing Retail Economy Coordination Forum involving relevant Commonwealth departments and agencies, with a designated lead minister and department officials. Retail policy spans economic, employment, skills, consumer affairs, competition, digital regulation, supply chains, infrastructure and crime portfolios, and more. The forum should identify issues that cross portfolio responsibilities, coordinate responses and escalate unresolved barriers to the responsible ministers. AI adoption and productivity should be an early standing item.
Support a retail AI Cooperative Research Centre, recognising retail’s research and commercialisation opportunity in the 2027 AI Accelerator round.
support a retail AI Cooperative Research Centre, recognising retail’s research and commercialisation opportunity in the 2027 AI Accelerator round.
Share Cooperative Research Centres Program findings and reusable tools beyond participating businesses, subject to intellectual-property and confidentiality arrangements, potentially informing the proposed small-business support.
Government should also explicitly recognise retail’s research and commercialisation opportunity in the forthcoming 2027 AI Accelerator round of the Cooperative Research Centres Program. Findings and reusable tools should be shared beyond participating businesses, subject to appropriate intellectual-property and confidentiality arrangements and could inform the small-business support proposed in recommendation 4.
Make AI-specific regulation a last resort where existing frameworks cannot be sufficiently adapted and technology-neutral rules cannot adequately address risk; favour proportionate, risk-based, outcome-focused responses, technology-neutral wherever possible.
ARC supports the Productivity Commission’s recommendation that regulatory responses to AI should be proportionate, risk-based, focused on outcomes, and technology-neutral wherever possible. ARC also supports its recommendation that AI-specific regulation should be a last resort, considered only where existing frameworks cannot be sufficiently adapted and technology-neutral regulation cannot adequately address the risk.
Assess the additional risks arising from particular uses of AI and whether existing law, guidance or enforcement can address them.
Government should apply this approach by assessing the additional risks arising from particular uses of AI and whether existing law, guidance or enforcement can address them.
Do not attach additional obligations to routine retail applications simply because they use AI; make any new requirements respond to an identified gap and be proportionate to the likelihood and severity of harm.
Routine retail applications should not attract additional obligations simply because they use AI. Any new requirements should respond to an identified gap and be proportionate to the likelihood and severity of harm.
Avoid duplicating obligations retailers already meet under privacy, consumer, employment and cybersecurity law or, where applicable, the Security of Critical Infrastructure Act.
Governments should avoid duplicating obligations retailers already meet under privacy, consumer, employment and cybersecurity law, or, where applicable, the Security of Critical Infrastructure Act.
Ensure the multiple AI-related reviews and reform processes across Commonwealth, state and territory governments produce a coherent policy framework, with proposals considered together to identify overlaps, resolve conflicts and assess cumulative impact.
The multiple AI-related reviews, consultations and reform processes underway across Commonwealth, state and territory governments need to produce a coherent and consistent policy framework, with proposals considered together to identify overlaps, resolve conflicting requirements and assess their cumulative impact on businesses.
Prioritise harmonisation and lower unnecessary compliance costs, with consistent cross-jurisdiction requirements avoiding duplicative assessments, conflicting guidance and repeated reporting.
Regulatory harmonisation and reducing unnecessary compliance costs should be explicit priorities. Retailers operating across jurisdictions need consistent requirements that allow them to deploy useful applications without duplicative assessments, conflicting guidance or repeated reporting.
Have the Office of AI work with Commonwealth departments, states, territories and regulators to identify and address overlapping or inconsistent AI requirements.
Through its existing coordination role, the Office of AI should work with responsible Commonwealth departments, state and territory governments and relevant regulators to identify and address overlapping or inconsistent requirements.
For Office of AI harmonisation work with responsible departments, states, territories and regulators, publish actions, agencies and timeframes and a process for ARC and members to raise practical examples.
Through its existing coordination role, the Office of AI should work with responsible Commonwealth departments, state and territory governments and relevant regulators to identify and address overlapping or inconsistent requirements. This work should publish proposed actions, responsible agencies and timeframes, with a clear process for ARC and its members to raise practical examples.
Have the National AI Centre work with industry and relevant agencies to adapt supplier-assessment and procurement resources for commercial retail use, especially for businesses without specialist legal and technical teams.
The National AI Centre should also work with industry and relevant agencies to adapt existing supplier-assessment and procurement resources for commercial retail use, particularly for businesses without specialist legal and technical teams.
Fund SME-retailer AI outreach and support covering opportunities, data readiness, supplier selection, customer/business information protection, work-process changes and staff capability.
The Australian Government should fund practical outreach and support to help small and medium-sized retailers understand AI opportunities and apply them in their businesses. Smaller retailers may lack the time, specialist staff and resources to identify suitable applications and assess their value, even where tools and government support are available. Support should also address data readiness, supplier selection, protection of customer and business information, changes to work processes, and staff capability.
Fund industry associations’ targeted AI engagement with ASBFEO and the National AI Centre, using demonstrations, workshops and direct engagement to identify benefits and applications and connect retailers with advice, training and implementation support.
Government should provide grant funding to relevant industry associations to deliver a targeted industry-specific AI awareness and engagement program, working with the Australian Small Business and Family Enterprise Ombudsman and the National AI Centre. Through practical demonstrations, workshops and direct engagement, the program should help retailers understand where AI could benefit their businesses, identify worthwhile applications, and connect with existing advice, training and implementation support.
Have the National AI Centre work with ARC and AI Adopt Centres to connect engagement to assistance, identify support gaps, link workforce training and incorporate research findings as available.
Building on the existing AI Adopt Program, the National AI Centre should work with ARC and AI Adopt Centres to connect this engagement with practical assistance and identify gaps in support. The program should connect with the workforce training proposed in recommendation 5 and incorporate relevant findings from the research proposed in recommendation 2 as they become available.
Support SaCSA, ARC, employers, employee representatives and training providers so retail workers and managers can develop practical AI and data skills.
The Australian Government should support SaCSA, ARC, employers, employee representatives and training providers to ensure retail workers and managers can develop practical AI and data skills.
Connect retail AI skills work with the Future Skills Organisation's national AI-skills initiatives and use relevant existing resources and competencies.
This work should connect with Future Skills Organisation’s national AI-skills initiatives and use relevant existing resources and competencies.
Consider practical AI and data skills through SaCSA's Retail Qualifications Continuum Review and subsequent training-product development.
SaCSA’s current Retail Qualifications Continuum Review provides an immediate opportunity to assess how well proposed training products address the changing tasks and capabilities identified in this submission. ARC recommends that practical AI and data skills be considered through that review and subsequent training-product development.
Support ARC’s Retail Institute and other providers’ task-specific modules where qualification change is unnecessary or cannot meet immediate needs; include self-paced learning and approved-tool onboarding accessible across stores, distribution centres and offices.
Workplace learning should complement nationally recognised training. ARC’s Retail Institute and other providers should be supported to develop short modules addressing specific retail tasks where a qualification change is unnecessary or cannot meet an immediate need. Delivery should include short, self-paced learning and onboarding to approved tools so that employees in stores, distribution centres and offices can participate, including those unable to attend scheduled classes.
Consider training on approved tools, data handling, output checks, limitations, human judgement and safe AI-enabled work.
Training could cover topics such as approved tools, data handling, checking outputs, recognising limitations, exercising human judgement, and working safely alongside AI-enabled systems.
Support management skills in identifying worthwhile applications, assessing data and suppliers, adapting processes and evaluating results.
Managers and business owners also need to identify worthwhile applications, assess data and supplier requirements, adapt processes, and evaluate results.
Recognise employers' use of AI, automation and digital technologies to make retail work safer.
Government should recognise employers’ use of AI, automation, and digital technologies to make retail work safer.
Have ARC’s position inform Government’s existing tripartite Artificial Intelligence Workplace and Employment Forum work.
ARC’s position should inform the Government’s existing work through the tripartite Artificial Intelligence Workplace and Employment Forum.
Prioritise guidance and consistent existing workplace obligations over separate statutory approval, mandatory AI agreements or other new technology conditions; have Government work with states, territories and regulators within their responsibilities.
Government should prioritise practical guidance and consistent application of existing obligations rather than introduce a separate statutory approval process, mandatory AI implementation agreement or other new condition on introducing workplace technology. The Australian Government should work with states, territories and relevant regulators within their respective responsibilities.
Have Safe Work Australia build on its AI guidance with ARC, retail employers and worker representatives on practical retail examples of AI used to create safer work.
Safe Work Australia should build on its existing AI and digital-technology guidance by working with ARC, retail employers, and worker representatives on practical retail examples for how employers may deploy AI to create safer work environments.
Ensure its approach to agentic commerce preserves retailers' ability to compete, invest in their own customer services and determine how independent AI agents interact with their businesses.
The Australian Government should ensure that its approach to agentic commerce preserves retailers’ ability to compete, invest in their own customer services and determine how independent AI agents interact with their businesses.
Directly involve ARC and its members in Treasury's existing work on agentic commerce.
Treasury’s existing work should directly involve ARC and its members so that policy reflects the practical requirements of retail transactions.
Keep retailers and marketplaces free to develop shopping assistants, rank and present offers, and set commercial/security conditions for access to systems, product information and transaction functions, subject to existing law.
Retailers and marketplaces should remain free to develop their own shopping assistants, present and rank offers within their services, and set commercial and security conditions for access to their systems, product information and transaction functions, subject to existing law.
Avoid a general obligation for retailers and marketplaces to give independent agents access or disclose algorithms.
ARC does not support a general obligation to provide independent agents with access or to disclose algorithms.
Address demonstrated conduct by AI intermediaries that excludes retailers, misrepresents their offers or harms competition, using existing competition and consumer law where it can effectively do so.
Government should address demonstrated conduct that excludes retailers, misrepresents their offers or harms competition, using existing competition and consumer law wherever it can effectively address the problem.
Keep retailers accountable for their own services and decisions; do not assign an independent agent’s statements or actions to a retailer merely because the agent interacts with its business.
Retailers should remain accountable for their own services and decisions, while responsibility for an independent agent’s statements or actions should not be assigned to a retailer merely because the agent interacts with its business.
Distinguish the responsibilities of retailers, model and agent providers and payment providers under existing law.
Policy and industry arrangements should distinguish the responsibilities of retailers, model and agent providers, and payment providers under existing law.
Support retailers in voluntary industry-led agentic-transaction standards with AI providers, banks, payment providers and consumers, covering agent identity, customer authorisation, limited information/function access and tracing actions after errors or disputes.
ARC supports voluntary, industry-led standards that make agentic transactions reliable and protect customer authorisation. Practical arrangements should help parties establish an agent’s identity, verify what a customer has authorised it to do, limit its access to the information and functions needed for a transaction, and trace its actions when an error or dispute arises. Government should support retailer participation in existing standards work alongside AI service providers, banks, payment providers and consumer representatives.