AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 524

The Australia Institute

Submitter group: Research institutes.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

Argues that the most immediate AI risks amplify existing human weaknesses: deepfakes in politics, AI as an excuse for poor government decisions, and free-riding on creators. Recommends truth in political advertising laws, considering an AI revenue tax, human-centred copyright reform and archiving of scanned works. An attached Senate paper argues data centre benefits are uncertain and strong regulation is needed.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. Says generative AI has already disrupted political debate by making sensationalistic and inaccurate political content easier to produce.

    Generative AI has already disrupted political debate and dialogue by making it easier to produce sensationalistic and inaccurate political content.

  2. Argues in the attached Senate paper that AI data-centre proliferation could accelerate climate change and increase electricity prices.

    The most significant risk of AI data centre proliferation is their impact on the energy market, potentially accelerating climate change and increasing electricity prices.

  3. Argues that AI can become an excuse for secretive, poor-quality government decision-making, comparing it to Robodebt.

    AI can become an excuse for secretive and poor-quality government decision-making. In this sense, it is similar to the automated and illogical processes behind the Robodebt scandal. In both cases, human responsibility and accountability are abandoned in favour of supposedly objective and impartial processes.

  4. Argues that AI companies are free-riding on creators and have called for copyright exceptions to scrape works locally.

    AI companies are free-riding on creators, and they have called on the Australian government to carve-out exceptions in copyright laws so that they can scrape copyright works locally.

  5. Argues that the productivity gains expected from AI by bodies such as the Productivity Commission are yet to appear in the data.

    While organisations such as the Productivity Commission and Australian Treasury are expecting higher productivity thanks to AI,4 this is yet to be borne out in the data. Past technological advancements have not reliably increased productivity.

  6. Argues that the remedy for poor governance is to fund public services, stop using consultants for core work and hold public servants to account for AI use.

    There is no single recommendation that will address poor quality governance. The solution is to fund public services properly, stop using management consultants to do core government work and hold public servants to account for their use of AI.

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Fund public services properly, stop using management consultants for core government work and hold public servants to account for their use of AI.

    There is no single action that will address poor quality governance; the solution is to fund public services properly, stop using management consultants to do core government work and hold public servants to account for their use of AI.

  2. Adopt truth in political advertising laws with provisions on fake sound, images and video.

    Adopt truth in political advertising laws, including specific provisions about fake sound, images and video such as those created through generative AI.

  3. Consider a tax on AI-related revenue funding culture and research and compensating for AI harms.

    Consider a tax on AI-related revenue, with the proceeds funding culture and research and otherwise compensating for AI-related harms.

  4. Approach copyright reform from a human angle rather than serving AI or tech companies.

    Parliament to approach any copyright reform proposals from a human angle rather than what serves AI or tech companies.

  5. Consider requiring digital copies of AI-scanned creative works to be archived by a government body, possibly the National Library of Australia or National Archives.

    Requiring the digital copies of any scanned works to be sent to a government body for archiving (perhaps the National Library of Australia or the National Archives) would still serve the purpose of taking one physical copy out of circulation for each scanned copy, without placing the information beyond the reach of the rest of humankind forever.

  6. Establish a clear chain of responsibility in government and consequences for incompetence and cruelty.

    A good start would be truth in political advertising laws, a clear chain of responsibility in government (and consequences for incompetence and cruelty), and taxes on AI to compensate for the harm it causes.

  7. In the attached Senate paper: take a sober assessment of the potential benefits and costs of data centre investment and design policy accordingly.

    If Australia is to avoid another disaster like gas, mining, salmon, gambling and more, the Government needs to take a sober assessment of the potential benefits of data centre investment, its costs, and design policy.

  8. In the attached Senate paper: regulate to protect Australians from harm and confirm that investments provide public benefit before, if needed, later investing in proven technologies.

    Resisting the flamboyant and urgent rhetoric of Big Tech companies, regulating to protect Australians from harm, confirming that investments provide public benefit, and then, if needed, later investing in proven technologies is more likely to serve the interests of the Australian people.

Read the original

Open in the interactive guide