Submission 527
Australian Small Business and Family Enterprise Ombudsman (ASBFEO)
Submitter group: Government.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
The small business ombudsman describes AI as offering productivity and cost reduction opportunities for small businesses alongside new risks and adoption barriers. It asks for government support to build small business capability, practical and proportionate AI governance, and consolidated access to AI resources.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Says that its assistance data and research indicate small business owners increasingly rely on AI tools, with challenges mostly relating to inaccurate or misleading AI-generated information.
The ASBFEO’s assistance data and research indicates small business owners are increasingly relying on AI tools to support business operations, seek information, complete administrative tasks and explore opportunities for business growth. At the same time, small business owners are reporting a range of challenges, most of which relate to inaccurate or misleading AI-generated information.
Says barriers to small business AI adoption include resource constraints, uncertainty about value, limited skills and perceived high upfront costs.
barriers, for example, small business’ resource constraints, uncertainty about the potential value of AI to their business, limited understanding of (and skills needed to apply) AI tools, and perceived high upfront costs for uncertain benefits.
Argues that integrating AI governance with a business’s broader risk framework helps identify related risks and coordinate mitigation.
Integrating AI governance within a business’s broader risk framework enables related risks to be identified and allows for a more streamlined, coordinated approach to risk mitigation.
Says its experience indicates that small businesses engage more with guidance delivered through trusted local industry and professional networks than directly from government.
The ASBFEO’s experience indicates that small businesses are more likely to engage with material delivered through trusted industry and professional networks, especially those which operate locally, rather than directly interfacing with government.
Says stakeholder feedback indicates government AI resources are fragmented, sometimes duplicative and difficult to navigate.
Feedback from stakeholders, however, indicates that the range of resources available is fragmented across multiple agencies, is sometimes duplicative, difficult to navigate and is often overwhelming to engage with.
States that regional and remote small businesses face digital infrastructure and connectivity barriers to AI uptake.
Small businesses in rural, regional and remote Australia face particular challenges with regard to digital infrastructure and internet connectivity, which can impede routine business activities and act as a barrier to the uptake of cloud-based AI tools.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Make AI governance fit-for-purpose and proportionate to small-business circumstances, enabling decisions about data protection, output oversight, extent of disclosure to customers/employees, and customer issue reporting.
AI governance measures should be fit-for-purpose to enable a small business to determine and put in place, in a way which is practical and proportionate to their circumstances, risk mitigation measures to manage: • how data and personal information is stored and protected • how the business can provide adequate oversight of AI-assisted outputs • the extent to which AI use should be disclosed to customers or employees • how a customer can report an AI-related issue
Address harm from AI system failure, accountability for AI outcomes, and testing and monitoring AI tools.
• the harm which could occur if AI systems fail • who is accountable for the outcomes of AI use • how to test and monitor AI tools.
Provide practical, accessible government guidance and support focused on building small business capability to adopt AI.
Government support should extend to practical, accessible guidance and other supports that helps small businesses better understand how AI can improve the productivity and efficiency of their business operations, and to respond to the risks and barriers of adopting AI.
Include building small business capability to take a strategic approach to AI adoption that addresses an identified business need.
Support should include building small business capability to adopt a strategic approach to AI adoption so it addresses an identified business need, such as a business process to improve, or a problem to solve.
Use relatable, preferably real sector-specific case studies showing how a small business has addressed AI opportunities, risks and barriers.
One of the most effective ways to impart information is through relatable case studies – ideally based on real, sector-specific examples that demonstrates in a practical way how a small business has addressed the various opportunities, risks and barriers.
Consider a concierge-style advisory service to help small businesses identify suitable AI services and resources.
This could be supported through the development of a concierge-style advisory service that helps small businesses identify which services and resources suit their needs.
Offer fit-for-purpose training, including interactive training tailored to practical problems businesses face when using AI.
fit-for-purpose training courses, including interactive training tailored to the practical problems businesses face in using AI
Support peer learning through trusted intermediaries, including industry associations and professional advisers.
peer-learning, drawing on trusted intermediaries, including industry associations and professional advisers
Provide opportunities for small-business users to engage with AI-tool developers to help test and refine.
opportunities for small business users to engage with developers of AI tools to help test and refine.
Develop a single online hub for small business linking to AI support services, programs and information.
The ASBFEO therefore recommends the development of a single online hub specifically designed for small business that has links to the various AI support services, programs and information that are available.
Take account of small business diversity, including business type, digital literacy, language and location, in designing support.
government should take account of the diverse nature of their characteristics, including business type, digital literacy, language preferences and geographic location.