Submission 536
Professor Will Bateman
Submitter group: Individuals.
Position labels are not shown for individual submitters.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
Argues constitutional limits require accountable humans to exercise public power and text-based AI may assist them. Says that other legislative powers can permit automated changes to legal rights, subject to constitutional constraints and human control. Recommends government process redesign, skills, education and human-reserved jobs to maintain independent scrutiny.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues that the Constitution was drafted on the assumption that only human beings with defined characteristics can exercise governmental power, limiting use of AI to exercise legislative, executive or judicial power.
Australia’s Constitution was drafted on the assumption that only human beings with defined characteristics and connections to Australia have the capacity to exercise governmental power. Thus, there are constitutional limitations on using AI to exercise the legislative, executive or judicial powers of the Australian government.
Argues other legislative powers may allow AI processes affecting legal rights without direct human involvement, subject to structural constitutional constraints.
Other heads of legislative power may provide for the creation of processes or procedures in pursuance of their specific subject-matter which provide for the creation, alteration and extinguishment of legal rights, obligations, privileges and immunities without direct human involvement and may include the use of AI programs. Those legislative powers are, however, subject to an important structural constraint
Argues that only human judges may exercise Commonwealth judicial power.
Thus, only human judges may exercise the judicial powers to adjudge and punish criminal guilt, review the legality of government action and conclusively determine legal rights
Argues that wide-scale AI use in government without regard to constitutional limits risks mass invalidation of decisions, liability for officials and compensation claims.
Any wide-scale implementation of AI within the Parliament, a Department of Government, public sector agency or an arm of the judiciary without an appreciation of the constitutional limits risks catastrophic legal consequences: including, mass invalidation of government decisions, tortious or criminal consequences for public officials and high-value compensation claims against the Australian government and public sector bodies.
States that AI programs can and should be used to help human public officials perform their tasks more efficiently and effectively.
AI programs can (and should) be used to enable human public officials to organise and perform their allocated tasks more efficiently and effectively.
Argues that officers supervising AI must be equipped to scrutinise its outputs independently, which requires human-reserved jobs and skills-development pathways in the public sector.
to ensure that any Minister or officer reviewing/supervising/controlling an AI program is intellectually and practically equipped to scrutinise the reasoning and outputs of that program entirely independently and in accordance with their public duties to the Australian community. That will require maintaining a high-level of human-reserved jobs and skills-development pathways within all Departments and the broader public sector.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Require that any Commonwealth officer who does or may exercise executive power has the skills to read, analyse and interpret information relevant to policy-generation and decision-making.
Any Commonwealth officer who does (or may) exercise executive power must have the intellectual and practical skills necessary to read, analyse and interpret any textual, audio/visual or numerical information relevant to the policy-generation and decision-making process;
Require that any Commonwealth officer has the intellectual and practical skills to justify, in written or oral form, the basis for any decision made under legislation or with legal consequences.
Any Commonwealth officer must have the necessary intellectual and practical skills to justify (in written or oral form) the basis for any decision they make under legislation or with legal consequences;
Require judges exercising Commonwealth judicial power to have skills to review, analyse and interpret legal and factual material and personally perform core judicial acts, including reviewing evidence and expressing reasons.
Any judge appointed by the Commonwealth (or reposed with Commonwealth judicial power) must have the intellectual and practical skills to review, read, analyse, calculate and interpret any legal and factual material (including material submitted orally) relevant to resolving disputes within their jurisdiction. Any such judge must also be required personally to perform the core acts necessary to exercise judicial power, including reviewing and analysing factual and legal material relevant to resolving disputes and express their reasons for decision;
Educate parliamentarians on AI policy and voting risks, including foreign allegiance and impermissible delegation of legislative power to a non-biological agent.
All current and future parliamentarians must understand the risks that arise from relying on AI programs to formulate policies and guide their voting behaviour, particularly as they relate to allegiance, obedience, or adherence to a foreign power and impermissible delegation of legislative power to a non- biological agent.
Have all arms of government urgently address risks from foreign AI companies collecting and retaining confidential government process information.
All arms of government and public sector instrumentalities must urgently address the risks to the integrity and security of their processes posed by allowing foreign AI companies to collect and retain confidential and systematically-critical information regarding government processes and the collective welfare of the Australian people.
Use AI to help human public officials organise and perform allocated tasks more efficiently and effectively.
AI programs can (and should) be used to enable human public officials to organise and perform their allocated tasks more efficiently and effectively.
Design new government processes so the constitutional basis of powers remains intact.
Mitigating those risks will require all arms of government to design new processes to ensure that the constitutional basis of their powers remains intact.
Develop executive education and skills pathways enabling ministers and officers to scrutinise AI reasoning and outputs independently, maintaining human-reserved jobs and skills-development pathways throughout departments and the public sector.
For the executive departments and agencies, novel approaches to education and skills development/maintenance must be developed to ensure that any Minister or officer reviewing/supervising/controlling an AI program is intellectually and practically equipped to scrutinise the reasoning and outputs of that program entirely independently and in accordance with their public duties to the Australian community. That will require maintaining a high-level of human-reserved jobs and skills-development pathways within all Departments and the broader public sector.
Have independent judiciary members consider court work allocation, reporting and staffing to preserve human labour and diligence in core judicial fact-finding, law application and judgment.
For judicial institutions, careful thought must be given to safeguarding the collective and individual commitment of judicial officers to maintain standards of human labour and diligence, rather than relying on AI tools to perform core judicial functions, including of fact-finding, law application and judgment. That will require consideration by the independent members of the judiciary of the appropriate organisation internal to the relevant court of work allocation, reporting and staffing.
Educate current and future parliamentarians on maintaining their allegiance to the Commonwealth despite the availability of foreign-owned AI programs, and on maintaining their own human moral and conscientious judgment in exercising legislative power.
For electoral institutions, it is vital to educate current and future parliamentarians on the importance of maintaining their allegiance, obedience, or adherence to the Commonwealth of Australia despite the availability of foreign owned and controlled AI programs. It is also vital to educate current and future members and Senators on the importance of maintaining their own human moral and conscientious judgment in the exercise of their collective legislative power.