Submission 541
Arts Law Centre of Australia
Submitter group: Creative sector.
An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.
Summary
Read the original submission for the full text.
Arts Law argues artists need control, remuneration and enforcement of copyright, moral rights and Indigenous cultural rights, while noting its view that AI models authorise infringement is untested. It proposes small claims, opt-in payments, performer and child protections, culturally authorised ICIP takedowns and a cultural fund, arguing existing copyright cannot provide all needed redress.
Key points
Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.
Argues that, with no effective regulation, copyright and moral rights infringement continues at all stages of generative AI training and output.
Arts Law is disheartened that with no effective regulation and despite the issue being at the forefront of agendas for the last few years, infringement of copyright and moral rights continues at all stages of generative-AI training and output.
Argues that AI licensing arrangements tend primarily to target large, unencumbered back catalogues, so not all artists benefit.
While present and potential AI licensing arrangements may inform ways in which artists with sufficient bargaining power contract in future, such arrangements tend primarily to target large, unencumbered back catalogues which means that not all artists benefit from them.
Argues that requiring artists to seek protection only through an opt-out system risks reinforcing their disempowerment, and that reform should let them challenge unauthorised use directly.
to require artists to seek protection only through an opt-out system risks reinforcing their present disempowerment. Any reform attempting to genuinely empower artists to exercise control over generative AI exploitation must enable them to challenge unauthorised exploitations directly through accessible legal processes.
States that, although passing off and consumer law may offer limited redress, no specific Australian law prohibits unauthorised use of a person's voice or likeness.
Whilst passing off and consumer protection laws against false and misleading conduct may offer limited redress in certain circumstances, there is no specific law prohibiting the unauthorised use of a person's voice or likeness in Australia currently, leaving performers exposed to exploitation and commercial misuse.
Argues that generative AI creates new Indigenous cultural and intellectual property hazards for which current Australian law has no remedy.
Generative AI introduces significant new ICIP hazards for which Australian law currently has no remedy.
Says the validity of problematic AI terms is unclear and its view that current AI models authorise copyright infringement remains untested in Australia.
Whether all problematic terms would be considered valid if challenged in litigation is unclear. Similarly, whether Arts Law’s view that current AI companies’ models authorise copyright infringement would be upheld by Australian decision-makers is presently untested.
Recommendations
Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.
Bolster existing laws and improve artists' access, including a small claims court for copyright and moral rights infringement.
in addition to bolstering existing laws and making it easier for artists to leverage and access them (for instance, with a small claims court for copyright and moral rights infringement claims;
Establish a fair and equitable artist remuneration scheme.
with a small claims court for copyright and moral rights infringement claims; a fair, equitable remuneration scheme;
Oblige generative AI providers to enable creators to opt in to use of their works for a fee or other benefit consistent with established principles.
the obligation on generative AI systems providers to enable creators to opt in to systems using their works in exchange for a fee or other benefit in keeping with established principles)
Provide more education and awareness-raising about the law and about AI.
and more education and awareness-raising about the law and about AI
Protect performers, including voice actors, through statutory prohibitions on unauthorised AI cloning, safeguards against unreasonable contractual demands and specific protections for vulnerable stakeholders such as child actors.
Arts Law advocates for greater regulatory protection of performers including voice actors, including through clear statutory prohibitions on unauthorised AI cloning, safeguards against unreasonable contractual demands and specific protections for vulnerable stakeholders like child actors.
Develop and support infrastructure empowering artists to exert control over unauthorised appropriation of their works and likenesses, as industry disinterest in private regulation and fallible technical opt-outs will not do so.
However, industry disinterest in private regulation and the fallibility of potential technical opt-out measures will require the development and support infrastructure empowering artists to exert such control over unauthorised appropriations of artists’ works and likenesses/identities to be effective.
Ensure any reform empowering artists' control over generative AI exploitation lets them challenge unauthorised exploitation directly through accessible legal processes.
Any reform attempting to genuinely empower artists to exercise control over generative AI exploitation must enable them to challenge unauthorised exploitations directly through accessible legal processes.
Support artist-centred moral-rights enforcement infrastructure, with low-cost dispute resolution and enforcement for claims of low individual economic value, and expedited takedowns.
For moral rights to be effective in the context of generative AI, there must be more support for artist-centred enforcement infrastructure. The importance of moral rights provides further justification for developing low- cost dispute resolution and enforcement avenues for claims of low individual economic value. Both control mechanisms, in the forms of expedited take-down measures and a small claims jurisdiction for infringement, are necessary to enable moral rights to achieve their objects in the context of generative AI.
Urgently address widespread theft, misappropriation and misrepresentation of First Nations traditional cultural expressions and knowledge amplified by generative AI, including through the promised standalone ICIP legislation.
We would like also to speak to promised laws, in the form of standalone legislation for Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property (ICIP), and the need to urgently address widespread theft, misappropriation and misrepresentation of Australia’s First Nations peoples’ traditional cultural expressions and knowledge, amplified through generative AI.
Require AI companies to demonstrate capacity for immediate takedown of offensive imagery, misrepresentations or misappropriated expression upon complaint, with First Nations-led solutions and appropriate cultural authority.
The circumstances demand a holistic response to these concerns, incorporating obligations on AI companies to demonstrate their capacity for immediate takedown of offensive imagery or other misrepresentation or misappropriated expression upon receipt of a complaint, First Nations-led solutions and appropriate cultural authority.
Provide urgent support for a cultural fund to support artists and the arts.
Arts Law submits that legal need is bound up with the necessity of urgent support for a cultural fund to support artists and the arts.
Ensure laws and regulations reward artists and provide consultation and remuneration for use of their works in generative AI.
Further, we see it as a crucial part of Australia’s ethos of giving people a fair go that we ensure that our laws and regulations result in artists being rewarded for their efforts and that they are consulted and remunerated for the use of their valuable works that have, thus far, been core sources of content powering generative AI systems and tools.