AI Inquiry Atlas

An unofficial, independent guide to the public records of the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence. Not connected with the Parliament of Australia or the committee. Its makers also made a submission (no. 481; see About). Summaries and scores are written by AI and can be wrong: check the original before relying on them.

Submission 56

APRA AMCOS

Submitter group: Creative sector.

An AI model identified the submitter group and wrote the summary, key points and recommendation summaries. Counts do not measure importance or merit.

Open in the interactive guide

Summary

Read the original submission for the full text.

APRA AMCOS argues for consent-based AI training licences, disclosure, IP valuation, enforcement, ICIP legislation and a sovereign creative AI fund. It opposes copyright exceptions and one-off compensation, while allowing statutory mechanisms where licensing is unavailable, with voluntary licensing obligations and refusal rights. It says its policy does not purport to represent every member’s individual views.

Key points

Quotes are the submitter’s own words. Text taken from documents, including scanned pages read by text-recognition software, can differ from the PDF. Check the original. Listed in the same order as on the submission’s page in the interactive guide.

  1. It says no multinational large language model platform operating in Australia has approached it about a training licence.

    Not one of the multinational Large Language Model platforms operating in Australia has approached APRA AMCOS to ask what a training licence would cost, how one would be structured, or what obtaining one would require.

  2. Argues that the AI licensing agreements it lists each required locating rightsholders, agreeing terms and paying, at scale, without needing a copyright exception.

    Every one of those AI licensing agreements required locating rightsholders, agreeing terms and paying money, at scale. None needed an exception to get access to these significant sources of copyright material.

  3. APRA AMCOS argues a one-off compensation fund is not a licence because the value AI systems generate is ongoing.

    A compensation fund isn't a licence. A licence is a price knowingly agreed between a buyer and a seller, which the seller may refuse. A one-off fund is a number chosen by the buyer. There's a deeper problem than the size of it: the value these systems generate isn't one-off, it's ongoing.

  4. APRA AMCOS argues copyright should be valued as a national asset, and that valuation completed before any legislative change to AI training rules.

    Copyright appears to be the only significant national asset this country is being asked to commoditise without first establishing the economic value, and that valuation should be commissioned urgently and completed before any legislative change proceeds.

  5. Argues that the rights-administration layer is a sovereign asset maintained by rightsholders.

    The administrative layer is a sovereign asset, and it exists because rightsholders maintain it.

  6. Says statutory or extended collective mechanisms may suit content without licensing solutions, provided voluntary licensing is pursued where available.

    APRA AMCOS is not opposed in principle to a statutory or extended collective mechanism as a legitimate licensing solution for some content types where licensing solutions are unavailable, but we don’t believe that statutory solutions of this nature should be introduced in the absence of an obligation to purse voluntary licensing arrangements where licensing solutions are available

Recommendations

Recommendations are shown beside the submission’s own words. Listed in the same order as on its page in the interactive guide.

  1. Have the Committee ask every AI platform, tech and business industry body appearing before it, in writing, what prevents it from licensing high-value content today, and publish the answers.

    The Committee should ask every AI platform, tech and business industry body appearing before it, in writing, what prevents it from licensing high-value content today, and publish the answers.

  2. Legislate a training data record-keeping and disclosure obligation for any AI model made available in Australia, in detail sufficient for a rightsholder to determine whether their works have been used.

    Legislate a training data record-keeping and disclosure obligation for any AI model made available in Australia, in detail sufficient for a rightsholder to determine whether their works have been used.

  3. Commission an urgent Commonwealth IP asset valuation measuring accumulated value rather than annual activity, completed before considering legislative change to copyright material in AI training.

    Commission an urgent Commonwealth valuation of Australia's intellectual property asset class, measuring the accumulated value of Australia's intellectual property rather than annual economic activity, and complete it before considering any legislative change affecting the treatment of copyright material in AI training.

  4. Create a new cause of action against making an AI model available in Australia if it was developed using copyright material in a way that would have infringed Australian law, wherever the training took place.

    Create a new cause of action against making an AI model available in Australia if that model was developed using copyright material in a way that would have infringed Australian law — regardless of where the training took place.

  5. Legislate with audit rights, disclosure obligations, penalties and enforcement, on the basis that AI companies will do what the law requires and no more.

    The Committee should proceed on the basis that these companies will do what the law requires of them and no more, and legislate accordingly, with audit rights, disclosure obligations, penalties and enforcement.

  6. Treat the stand-alone Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property legislation committed to in Revive as urgent, bring forward its digital and AI provisions, and consult directly with First Nations creators.

    Treat the stand-alone Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property legislation committed to in Revive as urgent, bring forward its digital and AI provisions, and consult directly with First Nations creators disseminating ICIP through digital platforms on the legislative options.

  7. Include APRA AMCOS members and creators disseminating ICIP through digital platforms in consultation on ICIP legislative options.

    The stand-alone legislation to protect Indigenous Cultural and Intellectual Property (ICIP) included in Revive is now urgent, and we encourage the Australian Government to consult with APRA AMCOS members and creators disseminating ICIP through digital platforms to be consulted on legislative options.

  8. Establish a $500 million Commonwealth fund over four years for lawful sovereign creative AI development based on consent, credit and remuneration, funding capability and provenance infrastructure rather than substitution.

    Establish a Commonwealth fund of $500 million over four years for lawful Australian sovereign AI development in the creative sector, operating on consent, credit and remuneration, and funding capability and provenance infrastructure rather than substitution.

    A program corrected obvious text-recognition errors in this quote for display.

  9. Exclude music competing with human-made works in the commercial marketplace from sovereign AI funding; require consent, credit, remuneration and participation at the rightsholder’s election.

    This sovereign AI development should support Australian industry and artistic capability rather than substitution, so it wouldn't fund music competing with human-made works in the commercial marketplace. Any development would also operate on consent, credit and remuneration with participation at the rightsholder's election.

  10. Require platforms seeking to train on AI-generated content in this territory to show voluntary licences for identified repertoire including Australian works, sufficient training-data disclosure, and accounting for previously ingested material without amnesty.

    All AI platforms looking to train on AI generated content this territory must show: 1. Voluntary direct licences covering identified repertoire in the relevant copyright class, including Australian repertoire. 2. Disclosure of copyright material used in training, in detail sufficient for a rightsholder to determine whether their work was used. 3. An accounting for material already ingested, rather than an amnesty for it.

  11. Introduce any statutory or extended collective licensing mechanism only where licensing solutions are unavailable, with an obligation to pursue voluntary licensing where available and an onus on platforms to exclude content whose rightsholders have refused consent.

    APRA AMCOS is not opposed in principle to a statutory or extended collective mechanism as a legitimate licensing solution for some content types where licensing solutions are unavailable, but we don’t believe that statutory solutions of this nature should be introduced in the absence of an obligation to purse voluntary licensing arrangements where licensing solutions are available, and where the onus lies on platforms to exclude from their training, content that rightsholders have exercised their right to refuse consent to such training.

  12. Fund licensed opt-in data, provenance and rights identification, metadata and registries, output detection and watermarking, First Nations-controlled protocols, creator-controlled tools, remuneration research and licensed-data access for small and medium Australian developers.

    we also propose a Commonwealth fund of $500 million over four years to support sovereign Australian AI development in the creative sector on a lawful basis. It would fund: • licensed, opt-in material available to Australian developers and researchers; • provenance, attribution and rights identification infrastructure; • metadata standards, work registries, output detection and watermarking; • First Nations-governed data protocols developed with and controlled by the relevant communities; • creator-controlled tools and research into remuneration models; and • access for small and medium Australian developers to lawfully licensed data.

  13. Invite every member of the Australian Parliament to sign the Paris Commitment for the Creators of Tomorrow.

    A signing campaign is now open at cisac.org/pariscommitment. We invite every member of the Australian Parliament to add their name.

Read the original

In some quotes a program corrected obvious text-recognition errors for display.

Open in the interactive guide